News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by mrobot on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:04PM (#29676670)
The constant onslaught of US "news" drumming up war on China and Russia is very scary. The production value of this site and the detail of its design are a problem. Reuters is a problem. This is indeed war propaganda. I do think the United States is on the offensive in this "cold war", and they they want it to be hot. United States foreign policy has historically been, let's say, less than helpful. I really do not believe China is a threat to the world.

What exactly is there to stand up to? Why not cooperate with China for mutual good? I believe Chinese leadership when they say all they want is a more multilateral world. US simply can't stop being world hegemon. Looking at the way people post both on this site and on Reddit about China, it's all same old Yellow Peril racism if you ask me. Really getting sick and tired of everyone just uncritically taking in US war propaganda and jumping on the war wagon.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by monkeycantype on Friday December 24, 2021 @04:58PM (#29678161)
I would love to be able to work with the people of China and Russia as you’re suggesting, I think the great mass of people in all these countries would, but you’re blurring the populations of the countries and the strategic plotting of the national leaders. I wonder if you might be making the terrible mistake that almost all of us seem to make, of seeing your country from the intimate perspective of family, friends and ordinary people living their lives, and others through the words and actions of national politicians. I think the leaders of all of these countries are threats to the world, and not because they necessarily have plans of expanding their empire across the globe, but because their primary goal is to hold power in their own country which requires theatre to the populace and flows of wealth to their core supporters. China doesn’t need to retake Taiwan, there are already Chinese people there doing just fine, Russia doesn’t need to threaten Ukraine, US doesn’t need its military practically everywhere, but the leaders in each of those countries can’t back down on any of those things or their person hold on power is over
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by chii on Friday December 24, 2021 @07:35PM (#29679171)
The leader exists because the (majority of) people implicitly allow it. The calculus of whether to resist and /or topple the leader is whether the individual is worse off without doing so.

In China, most people are better off with the current leadership (than the previous), and the economic prospects is at least looking good for them. They wouldn't want to rock the boat obviously.

So despite the fact that the people of china is peaceful and willing to cooperate unlike the CCP's external stance, they do hold responsibility for the actions of their leaders.

I take the same stance with the USA's actions under trump - this is in no way targeted at any particular country.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by monkeycantype on Saturday December 25, 2021 @05:01AM (#29681926)
I suppose I agree with you. But we’re all at fault here.

We’re born into a world with existing power structures that know how to defend themselves, that know the amount of carrot and stick that will this dismal compromise together. There’s no obvious way to change them, and by the time you’re big enough to try anything you have people you love, and a sense of what you risk. In the west we have nice memories of peaceful marches changing things. Even people who won’t discuss Tiananmen, know about the cultural revolution, about the millions that died in the civil war, and no illusions as to the danger of trying to change China

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by yumraj on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:41PM (#29677028)
> I really do not believe China is a threat to the world.

Tibetans, Uighars, HKers and citizens of almost all the countries that share a land or sea border with China will disagree with you.

And so will all the countries, such as Lithuania, and private companies who have been forced to toe CCP line.

I can keep going on…

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by jonnybgood on Friday December 24, 2021 @03:52PM (#29677634)
> Why not cooperate with China for mutual good? I believe Chinese leadership when they say all they want is a more multilateral world.

China is attacking Lithuania economically for opening a Taiwanese Representative Office. China is not cooperating for mutual good.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by zepto on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:07PM (#29676701)
The build up of troops on the border of Ukraine, and the Chinese military incursions into Taiwan’s airspace have not been drummed up by the US news.
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by devy on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:34PM (#29676970)
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by zepto on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:43PM (#29677059)
Can you summarize that?
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by justicezyx on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:20PM (#29676826)
So first, Taiwan is not sovereign nation. Under international law, Taiwan and mainland is one nation. So there is no such concept of Taiwan airspace per international law.

And, the so-called incursion is to Taiwan's air defence identification zone. That zone covers majority of Fujian province. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_Defense_Identification_Z... Literally, mainlanders are intrusion Taiwan adiz constantly. That's how ridiculous the western media repotting has been nowadays. They'll refuse to even acknowledge an obviously physically impossible situation, and blame on China...

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by diego_moita on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:38PM (#29677004)
> So first, Taiwan is not sovereign nation. Under international law,

And who made that "international law"? The CCP? Taiwan is sovereign because they want to be, overwhelmingly.

China's imperialism towards Taiwan is just imperialism, like in Tibet and Hong Kong. And like Russia in Ukraine.

Nothing different than the U.S. did in Philippines, Iran and Latin America during most of 20th century.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by newbear1 on Friday December 24, 2021 @03:31PM (#29677443)
International laws are defined by international community through some Democratic process. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_law
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by zepto on Friday December 24, 2021 @03:37PM (#29677497)
In the multilateral case, recognition of Taiwan by the UN has long been something that China has had veto power over.

In the unilateral case, China prevents individual countries from recognizing Taiwan or even implying it’s independence through threats and retaliation.

A recent example: https://news.yahoo.com/china-threatened-send-lithuania-garba...

The only reason Taiwan is not considered sovereign under international law is because China has prevented it.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by CogitoCogito on Friday December 24, 2021 @03:46PM (#29677575)
> The only reason Taiwan is not considered sovereign under international law is because China has prevented it.

Same question as here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29677548

Which "international law" are you referring to that doesn't consider Taiwan sovereign? Maybe you mean to say that Taiwan/ROC is not a member of the UN? That is true, but it doesn't mean that Taiwan isn't a sovereign country. Switzerland didn't become a sovereign country only in 2002.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by zepto on Friday December 24, 2021 @04:58PM (#29678160)
Yes, this is a fair point. I was referring primarily to the fact that the UN doesn’t recognize Taiwan as a separate entity and doesn’t give it a seat independently from the mainland - e.g. The WHO has been blocked from doing so by the CCP.

But, you are right, this is not the same at all as an ‘international law’ establishing that Taiwan is not a sovereign country.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by newbear1 on Friday December 24, 2021 @04:10PM (#29677762)
> In the multilateral case, recognition of Taiwan by the UN has long been something that China has had veto power over.

I think you are just stating that that is part of the international law, right? Law is just law. It went to effect for stakeholders agree that they can abide by bits ruling.

Texas is not independent because US does not allow that. Right? Because the law dictates that the sovereign power is legally the care giver of a group of population on a land.

You are mixing law and self conscience.

https://www.lowyinstitute.org/the-interpreter/would-war-over....

This is relatively balanced description on the issue. One can certainly see that the politics have made the matter intentionally vague.

And nternational law is not necessarily written. It could be some commonly agreed principles. For example, there is no written law says US government can govern the land on here. It's based a certain aggreed upon concepts in people's mind.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by zepto on Friday December 24, 2021 @04:54PM (#29678125)
No - see the other commenter. There is no international law stating that Taiwan is part of China.

If you can provide us with a link to the law in question, we might be able to go into this question in more detail.

Until then I think it’s fair to assume that you are mistaken.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by CogitoCogito on Friday December 24, 2021 @03:43PM (#29677548)
> International laws are defined by international community through some Democratic process. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_law

Which "international law" exactly states that Taiwan is a part of "China"? For example, the UN certainly has never taken that position. (Many people mistakenly believe that UN Resolution 2758 says that, but even a cursory reading of the short resolution shows.)

[dead]
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by zepto on Friday December 24, 2021 @04:56PM (#29678146)
I think it’s clear that there is nothing to support your claim that there is any ‘international law’ that establishes that Taiwan is part of the mainland.

It is literally only a position of the CCP and nothing more.

As I have pointed out, your account was created three years ago, but was silent until a couple of hours ago, when you have used it only to support the claim that Taiwan is part of mainland China, never commenting on anything else.

[dead]
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by zepto on Friday December 24, 2021 @07:10PM (#29679037)
> If you want to advance the idea that it's only China mainland had this idea of Taiwan is part of China, then you already made a US centric view that is very likely to be wrong.

As I said elsewhere - if you can provide us a link to this international law, we can discuss it, and we can see if I am wrong.

As it is, it is clear that there is no international law establishing that Taiwan is part of China, and nothing you can point to.

Once again, I will mention that you created this throwaway account 3 years ago, and only activated it in the last few hours to make comments solely supporting the CCP’s claim to Taiwan.

[dead]
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by zepto on Friday December 24, 2021 @10:42PM (#29680186)
>> CCP’s claim to Taiwan.

> That's China mainland's claim

No, it’s the CCP. The CCP is the government of the mainland and it is the government that makes the claim.

> throw away accounts have no connection to a particular point of view.

If you say so, but then can you explain why you created a throwaway account 3 years ago, only to use it now only for the purpose of defending the CCP’s claim to Taiwan?

[dead]
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by zepto on Saturday December 25, 2021 @06:30AM (#29682381)
> CCP/China that's the same thing. You might want separate you cannot separate your head from your body.

You contradicted me earlier when I called it the CCP’s claim, so I guess you have changed your mind.

> The throw away account. I don't get it. Throw away are created for temporary use. After this episode of chat, this account will disappear. I just have quite a few I created in a whim, and use any one from the Google password manager.

Ahh so you created quite a few accounts all at one time, 3 years ago, and you use a different one each time you want to present the CCPs point of view.

That makes sense.

> Lastly, your reasoning of questioning other's motivation through minor details are really killing the conversation.

I’m not questioning your motivation. You have been clear about that. I am simply trying to understand the method.

By creating a set of throwaway accounts to use later, you avoid them appearing to be new accounts which show up in green at the time you use them, which makes it less likely people will notice that they are throwaways.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by will4274 on Friday December 24, 2021 @07:42PM (#29679206)
Please read the link you included in your comment. There is no connection between democratic process and international law except that some of the nation states themselves are democracies.

Note also that capital D Democratic refers to an American political party. Lowercase d democratic is correct for your comment.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by zepto on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:35PM (#29676983)
> So first, Taiwan is not sovereign nation. Under international law, Taiwan and mainland is one nation.

This is the CCP position, yes.

https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=justicezyx

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by lucian1900 on Friday December 24, 2021 @06:14PM (#29678705)
It’s the position of the government in exile in Taiwan, too. The one that’s the side of the civil war that lost and retreated.
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by newbear1 on Friday December 24, 2021 @03:32PM (#29677453)
That's just what reconfigured by international laws. CCP of course will proclaim rulings that are favorable to China.
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by zepto on Friday December 24, 2021 @03:39PM (#29677512)
Not so: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29677497

Also, I see your account was created 3 years ago, but only became active in the last hour to post defenses of the CCP and China.

https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=newbear1

[dead]
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by zepto on Friday December 24, 2021 @05:00PM (#29678179)
> So I think it's useful to hide my identity and make throw away account to just reflect a point.

You made the throwaway account 3 years ago, and only started to use it two hours ago.

> Otherwise, people would start associate my comments to certain ideology allegence.

I think the converse is true. If your account had a history of points of view on different topics people would be far less likely to see it as being driven by ideological allegiance.

> I am just come to provide CCP's view on hot issues.

Thank you for being clear about what you are doing here. That is much appreciated.

[dead]
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by zepto on Friday December 24, 2021 @07:14PM (#29679052)
> Well, if everyone is as open as you are showing here, then it would already be diverse long ago.

How can that be? You created a throwaway account 3 years ago and haven’t used it until now.

[dead]
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by zepto on Friday December 24, 2021 @10:47PM (#29680200)
No - you simply failed to account for why you created a throwaway account 3 years ago, only to use it now.
[dead]
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by zepto on Saturday December 25, 2021 @09:45AM (#29683704)
I think you have already answered in this subthread:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29681040

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by diego_moita on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:34PM (#29676962)
> I believe Chinese leadership when they say all they want is a more multilateral world.

They say but don't do it. China's behaviour towards Canada, Lithuania and most of Eastern Asia is anything but multilateral. It is plain and simple imperialism.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by systemvoltage on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:12PM (#29676741)
Taiwanese Foreign Minister's interview is terrifying, the sheer horror on his face: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c3D0_Bhzbyo

It's also fair to push back on war hungry narratives, it is equally as important to understand all scenarios. Nobody puts this better than Gen. Mark Milley: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vSBN5xBC1L4

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by mcswell on Friday December 24, 2021 @05:11PM (#29678258)
Repeat after me, Mr Robot: Premier Xi looks like Winnie the Pooh. What? I can't hear you!
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by rectang on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:12PM (#29676747)
> Reuters is a problem.

Any independent news organization is a problem for the CCP.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by justicezyx on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:16PM (#29676781)
Well, as a matter of fact, any independent news organization is a problem for any modern government. CCP and US establishment are equally fearful of independent news organization. For example, Assange and wikileak.
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by mcswell on Friday December 24, 2021 @05:13PM (#29678266)
I guess you mean that President Trump closed down CNN because it said so much against him, just like President Biden has closed down Fox News.

What? They didn't?

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by mcswell on Friday December 24, 2021 @05:13PM (#29678265)
I guess you mean that President Trump closed down CNN because it said so much against him, just like President Biden has closed down Fox News.

What? They didn't?

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by akimball on Friday December 24, 2021 @09:33PM (#29679811)
The existence of differences does not moot the similarities
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by analyst74 on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:39PM (#29677011)
I'm not old enough to read mainstream news during the 80s, but learnt that there was a period of anti-Japanese fear mongering due to Japan's rising economy. It caused riots, burning of japanese products, and street violence to people who looked like Japanese.

I'm not too worried about war between nuclear powers, but I do fear for Chinese and Chinese-looking people living in the west.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by monkeycantype on Friday December 24, 2021 @05:18PM (#29678312)
We should all worry about the kind of people who would harass Chinese looking people in the west, but as someone in Australia, I’d like to assure you that while it is definitely very hard to move to a new country, a new language a new culture, and there are racists everywhere who tend to be loud and impulsive and hurtful, people here are deeply proud that this is a place where people from around the world have been able to come to make a life and contribute their culture. With each wave of immigration there has been initial wariness and eventual embrace. If you ever get the chance to come to Melbourne, ask people about the post war Vietnamese migration, if you read the media from the time you’d think there was hostility towards Vietnamese, what you’ll actually encounter is pride that Vietnamese are here and a real love for the Vietnamese people. Read about the visas given to Chinese students after Tiananmen, and the pride people have in the hybrid Indigenous/European/Asian culture of Broome which was exempt from the White Australia Policy, and you’ll see the world people want is a very different place to the fearful place our national leaders are dreaming for us
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by monkeycantype on Friday December 24, 2021 @07:43PM (#29679216)
By all means down vote, but please take the time to say why
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by philsnow on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:23PM (#29676865)
> Why not cooperate with China for mutual good?

This works until it doesn't. "American exceptionalism" is not unique to Americans.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by rkk3 on Friday December 24, 2021 @03:16PM (#29677318)
Yep just another piece of the Manufacturing Consent apparatus, this one seems more of just a puff piece though.
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by CountSessine on Friday December 24, 2021 @04:53PM (#29678118)
“Peace for our time”, right?
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by natded on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:16PM (#29676777)
US isn't technically drumming up war on China and Russia; they are promoting war to the last Ukrainian against Russia, and probably the last Taiwanese against China. A difference, but probably enough to help US hitch a long as superpower couple of decades if either of these events take place.

Direct confrontation between Russia, China vs. US is not even in the question. US couldn't defeat couple of goat herders and they're going to level up to S-tier opponents? I wouldn't even bet on US against Venezuela or Iran at this point.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by systemvoltage on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:18PM (#29676803)
> US couldn't defeat couple of goat herders and they're going to level up to S-tier opponents? I wouldn't even bet on US against Venezuela or Iran at this point.

Operation Desert Storm was a success and completely overwhelming. The amount of power projected was incalculable. Here is an extremely detailed account of it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zxRgfBXn6Mg

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by natded on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:24PM (#29676882)
OTOH, US did just this year lose its longest war and it was against Afghanistan. I rely on this closer event. Granted, admitting the loss there was the first step in road to recovery.
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by systemvoltage on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:28PM (#29676917)
It wasn't a conventional war. I don't think there is any defense to the massive fuck up in the Afghanistan exit strategy though. But, to say that US military is incapable of doing anything is a pretty lousy argument.
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by sudosysgen on Friday December 24, 2021 @03:48PM (#29677603)
What is conventional war? Do you think that the Chinese or Russians will play nice and play war ship for ship, plane for plane and tank for tank against the US like the Iraqis did at the beginning?

The US military generally has a very "meh" track record.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by xxpor on Friday December 24, 2021 @05:06PM (#29678227)
Otoh, the us was able to maintain the status quo with the taliban being relegated to the mountains with 3500 troops against ~75000 taliban. The DOD has over 1 million troops at their disposal. If you seriously think Afganistan was more about absolute power vs political willingness.. I just don't know what to say.
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by sudosysgen on Friday December 24, 2021 @05:16PM (#29678295)
That isn't actually right. Yes there were 3500 actual soldiers on the ground, but they also had tens of thousands of afghans they would use for a lot of the dirty work, and multiple thousands of other support personnel necessary outside of Afghanistan. And that was just during the drawdown, during surges there were even more at various points in time.

As for sheer numbers of troops, the US doesn't have the capability to actually outfit, support, and deploy anywhere near a million troops in, for example, the middle east.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by saxonww on Friday December 24, 2021 @06:07PM (#29678674)
I guess it's arguable what the actual whole truth is in Afghanistan, but a lot of writing on it paints the Afghan troops themselves as being unprepared to defend themselves and in many cases unreliable. We were ostensibly trying to help organize and train them, but just being there doesn't mean people will be inspired to take the risks and do the job.

It's also not the first time a highly motivated group of rebels won a guerrilla conflict in Afghanistan. The USSR fought a 9 year unsuccessful war in Afghanistan too, if you don't recall, after probably helping destabilize and overthrow the government; the current Taliban leadership grew out of factions of the mujahideen that ousted the Soviets back in the 1980s.

I'm no military expert, but it does seem like the US is not geared towards massive troop deployments right now. I've always thought that's because the expectation is that we won't have a massive troop war like WW1/WW2 again.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by sudosysgen on Friday December 24, 2021 @11:58PM (#29680558)
The USSR was actually fairly successful once they figured out that brute force was never going to work, and executed the crazy leader of the national government to replace him with a more moderate leader. Their puppet state survived over a year without Soviet support, until Yeltsin sanctioned them. That's something the US never managed to do, not even close, and it took them 9 years instead of 20. Likely if the USSR wasn't moribund the puppet government could have pulled through long enough to start a process of consolidation.

And that's despite massive and direct US support to the Mujahideen, which the US didn't have to worry about.

Afghanistan was a winnable war. The way to win the war was, from the outset, to build a strong state that is fairly self-sufficient and motivated to defend itself, without too much corruption. The US military wasn't able to do that. At every turn they were ineffective in rooting out corruption and moral decay, didn't have anywhere near a workable vision for a path out of the Afghan disaster, and lacked the ability to implement a stable political system.

I agree that the US isn't geared towards massive troop deployments. That's why it's absurd to trot out troop numbers as the person I was replying to did.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by dragonwriter on Friday December 24, 2021 @06:19PM (#29678739)
> after probably helping destabilize and overthrow the government

“Probably”?

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Storm-333

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by saxonww on Friday December 24, 2021 @06:21PM (#29678748)
Yeah I was trying to be more neutral bc I have not studied the history in detail, I just know the high points.
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by morpheos137 on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:14PM (#29676758)
Russophobia is omnipresent in the Western press too. It is simply another form of racism.
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by diego_moita on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:43PM (#29677058)
Speaking as a Latin American, Russia is just another banana republic with 100 million people and nukes.

> simply another form of racism.

That's just plain stupid. I fear their authoritarian and murder leader, I don't fear their people.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by coeneedell on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:25PM (#29676890)
I don't think it's racist to be worried about a nuclear power colonizing its neighbors.
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by natded on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:37PM (#29676998)
Superpower logic is far too cold for terms like colonizing. There is very little focus on such ideological by-products of power when the General Staff makes its considerations and recommendations for the security of the state. If you think in terms like these, from some liberal shitlib university, against military superpowers who can guarantee MAD with nuclear weapons you are not going to make heads or tails any of it.

It is best to purify your mind and just read Thomas Schelling.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by throwway1234 on Friday December 24, 2021 @03:26PM (#29677393)
I‘m a Russian language learner for many years. When you listen to Putin what he tells his Babushkas, you now you cannot trust him one word. BTW, I recommend to listen to him as a learner: He speaks slowly, very articulate with clear pronunciation, so he can tell Babushkas that foreign power are threatening Russia.