News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Human geneticists curb use of the term ‘race’ in their pa... by jevoten on Thursday December 23, 2021 @09:46PM (#29669454)
Is this effort shared by, for example, Chinese and Russian geneticists, or is it purely a Western endeavor?

Edit: It seems my suspicion was correct, and at least Chinese anthropology does not share the Western aversion to 'race':

https://lesacreduprintemps19.files.wordpress.com/2011/07/on-...

Re:Human geneticists curb use of the term ‘race’ in their pa... by polski-g on Thursday December 23, 2021 @10:07PM (#29669599)
The latter. The problem with this line of thinking is that race is a genetic term. Crime investigators can determine race from a blood droplet. NHS has a monthly begging campaign for "black blood" donations.

And the biggest thing is that race corresponds to generic ancestry with 99.86% accuracy: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1196372/

Re:Human geneticists curb use of the term ‘race’ in their pa... by nverno on Thursday December 23, 2021 @10:24PM (#29669763)
They can also distinguish at a much finer level than the typical black, white, asian races. It's a social construct because the cutoff for being one or the other is determined by whatever matters to people in a society, not because science can distinguish them.
Re:Human geneticists curb use of the term ‘race’ in their pa... by jevoten on Thursday December 23, 2021 @10:39PM (#29669865)
That the precise cutoffs are socially constructed does not imply the categorization itself is not biological. It's simply a coarse clustering based on kinship, that can be reproduced without reference to any society.

Edit: To the replies claiming the categorization is arbitrary and mostly cultural - that does not appear to be the case. In fact, it almost perfectly corresponds to genotype principal component plot clusters, as https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29669918 noted:

https://youtu.be/iegYpOG6mQI

I.e. the categorization corresponds to what you get when you consider all/many genes, and not a few arbitrarily chosen ones, like those that determine eye or hair color.

Re:Human geneticists curb use of the term ‘race’ in their pa... by nverno on Thursday December 23, 2021 @10:50PM (#29669955)
You could group people by hair color or eye color as well, without reference to any society. But, the social importance of that grouping could vary greatly between societies. Eg. not many people care about who is an Ionian or an Achaean in modern society.

The racial distinctions (at least today in the west) are associated with biological traits, and specifically the ones that are visually obvious. But, I think those biological traits are used socially to distinguish groups that are considered different for other reasons (values, beliefs, etc.).

Re:Human geneticists curb use of the term ‘race’ in their pa... by ofTheFountain on Thursday December 23, 2021 @10:53PM (#29669975)
The categorisation isn't fully biological though, it's far heavier in the cultural camp. And even when it is biological, it's mainly phenotypic, which isn't adequate for genetic research.
Re:Human geneticists curb use of the term ‘race’ in their pa... by esyir on Thursday December 23, 2021 @11:02PM (#29670031)
So is ancestry. All Phylogenetic histories with any form of categorization is by definition a social construct. Social constructs, however, are not useless.
Re:Human geneticists curb use of the term ‘race’ in their pa... by rectang on Thursday December 23, 2021 @10:13PM (#29669654)
> Crime investigators can determine race from a blood droplet.

Such as determining that a person who is ~75% "white" and ~25% "black" is in fact, "black"?

If "race" is a "genetic term" it is certainly not only a "genetic term".

Re:Human geneticists curb use of the term ‘race’ in their pa... by Aeolun on Thursday December 23, 2021 @10:12PM (#29669643)
In other words, it corresponds 100% with genetic ancestry, it’s just asking people to self identify their race that’s problematic.
Re:Human geneticists curb use of the term ‘race’ in their pa... by nefitty on Thursday December 23, 2021 @10:17PM (#29669690)
That's what confuses me. Some people say race is a construct, but then why do ads for sickle cell medicine only have black actors in them?

I don't see how cloaking or censoring ideas of race benefits humanity. I know there's specific problems that are more common in my race. I WANT doctors and scientists to acknowledge that and use that information to improve treatments.

I don't feel outraged, just sort of confused as to what the incentives at play here are.

Re:Human geneticists curb use of the term ‘race’ in their pa... by csee on Thursday December 23, 2021 @10:37PM (#29669851)
It is both a social construct as well as a physically real thing. Those two things aren't mutually exclusive, and more people need to understand that. Most of the debate in this area is language games.

Consider running a PCA on a matrix of everyone's alleles < actually, this is legit interesting, has anyone done it? >. Hypothesis: A bunch of the top few components will correspond to commonly understood racial groups that people have created based on observable phenotypic clusters. In this sense, it's a real physical thing. Duh.

However, at the same time, the components are an abstraction, and the common conceptualization of what these components mean and how they relate to reality is somewhat of a mental construction. There will be other high variance components that don't relate to racial categories. We probably don't even notice them. And our racial categories probably don't map that cleanly to the actual underlying components.

Re:Human geneticists curb use of the term ‘race’ in their pa... by wrp on Thursday December 23, 2021 @10:35PM (#29669837)
The problem is in the variation of what people mean by "race". In popular culture, people generally use it as a synonym for ethnicity. In genetics, it means the same as "breed" does when referring to animals. The first is a social construct. The second is a grouping of heritable traits.
Re:Human geneticists curb use of the term ‘race’ in their pa... by vmception on Thursday December 23, 2021 @10:25PM (#29669776)
what they're trying to convey is that certain phenotypes have correlations to an overly broad construct, and with your example it is only showing that certain debilitating evolutionary paths are correlated or exclusively within a subset of people with those phenotypes

not that hard, to me, let me know when you get there though

Re:Human geneticists curb use of the term ‘race’ in their pa... by nefitty on Thursday December 23, 2021 @10:46PM (#29669927)
You're being unnecessarily condescending when my comment was sincere and inviting of new information. I'm not really sure what you intended to accomplish with that last line, except making yourself feel superior to a stranger online who hasn't read some book or taken some class you have?
Re:Human geneticists curb use of the term ‘race’ in their pa... by vmception on Thursday December 23, 2021 @10:49PM (#29669946)
yeah you’re right, so without that last line what do you think

its not supposed to be new information, its supposed to deconstruct that people in the largest continent on the planet have the most genetic diversity and only chose/were forced to group together for shared representation after noticing they all got a shitty parallel experience in some other continents

the same concept applies to other groups that happen to overlap in some unique phenotypes

Re:Human geneticists curb use of the term ‘race’ in their pa... by nefitty on Thursday December 23, 2021 @11:14PM (#29670105)
Ah ok, that makes sense. Thanks for acknowledging my criticism of your comment and clarifying your idea.