News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fundamental physical theory is being replaced with a pseu... by katmannthree on Thursday December 23, 2021 @02:11PM (#29665307)
> It’s like imaginary numbers are fake and don’t exist

It's even better than that. Working from the other side, we generally take the natural numbers N = {0, 1, 2, 3, ...} to be "real" in a philosophical sense as we have an implied mapping of x in N fundamentally describing possession of discrete quantities of goods. This get a little more tricky when you generalize it to the integers Z = {..., -2, -1, 0, 1, 2, ...}, but we still consider these physically grounded as you can "owe" a discrete quantity of goods to someone. This is an incomplete mapping to reality as possession of y goods where y is in Z- doesn't actually describe where your y goods go to, but it's useful enough that we ignore that.

Now that's all good and well for discrete quantities of goods, but what about fractional quantities? We need a new system to describe more numbers between the numbers we already have. Thus we defined the set of rational numbers Q = {n | n = p/q where p, q are in Z and q is not 0}. This lets us compactly describe almost any number we want between the existing integers. Most still consider these to be physically grounded, because we created these to describe concrete things in our reality which they do very compactly. You can claim that at least some of these are physically grounded in reality as using 1/3 a cup of flour or buying 1/2 a watermelon is certainly something one can very clearly and explicitly do.

The rationals have some issues though, namely that they still have holes in them. Suppose you want to describe the relationship between the diameter of a circle and its circumference. The constant you use to transform one to the other, π, does not exist in Q. You can get as close as you like, but you can't actually reach it. That's a bit of a problem for people whose job it is to make sure that the things math says are correct are actually fully correct. There are other problems, suppose you want to make a rectangular plot of land whose area is 2 square miles. How long does each side need to be? You can get as close as you like by using rational numbers, but the actual length of that side (sqrt(2)) is not in Q.

To fix this, we then very delicately construct the set of real numbers R = {x | where x is in {Q and all of the numbers described above which are missing from Q}}. This is where the physical grounding of the numbers starts to get ugly, because as it turns out that just like for some numbers in Q (consider 22/7, which does not evaluate to a fixed number of digits but rather goes on forever) these are uncountable and most of them unrepresentable, i.e. if you tried to write the number out completely on a piece of paper the universe isn't big enough to hold it (and in some cases, you can't even specifically refer to the number in constructive terms as with π). This turns into a whole philosophical debate which IMO is silly but some people do take pretty seriously.

But wait, there's more! The field of real numbers is closed under addition and multiplication (and thus subtraction and division), but it's _not_ closed under some other operations. Suppose you're an EE trying to represent physical signals that very much do exist in reality, and you need to take the root of a negative real number because that is a meaningful quantity in context of the still physically grounded thing you're modeling. Well you can take the root of a negative real number, but that number is not itself a real number. Thus we must define the imaginary numbers to hold those negative roots and then the complex numbers to join the imaginary numbers back to the reals.

In every single one of these steps, the new numbers were created to describe aspects of our observed physical reality. The break from the common definition of "numbers are real because I can go buy 24 tangerines and 24 is a number" happened way back at the integers where we added a reflection around the end of the natural numbers. From a perfectly reasonable perspective then, the real and imaginary numbers are both "real" in that they describe actual physical things that exist even though you can not in fact buy -1 apples or 22/7 cats or π bananas or sqrt(-1) movie tickets.

Re:Fundamental physical theory is being replaced with a pseu... by SideburnsOfDoom on Thursday December 23, 2021 @03:49PM (#29666296)
> The break from the common definition of "numbers are real because I can go buy 24 tangerines and 24 is a number"

If I have two dogs, and you swap one of them out for a different dog; well, it's not the same and I'd notice.

What I find interesting about "24 apples" is that all of those apples are in fact also unique individuals - none are identical, they have different weights, percentage moisture, sugar content, number and positioning of seeds, etc. Their exterior markings will be as unique as fingerprints. None of them are really interchangeable.

Saying that "there are 24 of the same thing here" is an _abstraction_ of reality. It's our perception, our agreement that they can be considered "the same thing", but it is not a physical reality.

It might be real for of protons, but not of people, cats, apples or tangerines. Macroscopic objects are not numbers.

Re:Fundamental physical theory is being replaced with a pseu... by katmannthree on Thursday December 23, 2021 @04:19PM (#29666597)
Exactly. Every instance of the belief that elements of some particular number systems are "real" is a mapping of the human abstraction representing that number system to another human abstraction of some other system of objects that are considered to be "actually real."

The base case of that mapping is natural numbers representing possession of quantities of fungible objects. That mapping is broken by the negative integers, literally the next step up from the natural numbers. If you're concerned about the reality of the reals you can ramble on about finitism or the holographic principle and how something can possibly be real if you can't name or explicitly define every version of it, or you can recognize that every number system from the natural numbers to the complex numbers shares the property that elements of this system of numbers map to elements of physical systems and thus they are all exactly as real as each other.

Re:Fundamental physical theory is being replaced with a pseu... by scotty79 on Friday December 24, 2021 @03:34AM (#29671602)
Imagine 24 places separated by some distances.

You have 24 somethings. The fact that they are not identical with regards to any physical quantity doesn't matter.

Re:Fundamental physical theory is being replaced with a pseu... by SideburnsOfDoom on Saturday December 25, 2021 @06:00AM (#29682213)
How do you know which items to include in that set of 24 items, and which to exclude? With different criteria it could be a set of 23 items, or of 25, or 1 or none or infinite.

These 24 items are all unique, as are the excluded ones. The inclusion, the concept of set, the grouping, is not real, it is your criterion, mapping, your abstraction of reality.

Re:Fundamental physical theory is being replaced with a pseu... by ChainOfFools on Thursday December 23, 2021 @05:27PM (#29667213)
well, 1 = -1*-1

but the right hand side contains more "information" than the left hand side, being not simply a quantity but a route to getting there from other quantities.

Re:Fundamental physical theory is being replaced with a pseu... by scotty79 on Friday December 24, 2021 @03:40AM (#29671643)
I think physical reality ends with rational numbers. Anything beyond that is math. Very good math that helps us approximate physical reality but math nonetheless.

There is no such thing as physical circle.

Re:Fundamental physical theory is being replaced with a pseu... by katmannthree on Monday December 27, 2021 @12:24PM (#29704484)
I'd be curious to hear a rigorous definition of physical reality for the rationals, IMO only the ones that are also integers have that property. Even those are debatable, owning discrete quantities of things is dependent on human sociocognitive constructs. The concept of the realness of the natural numbers is fundamentally linked to a human definition of realness rather than a first-principles approach like mathematical definitions.

Discrete quantities do seem to exist in as fundamental a sense as anything can, but on small scales and also once you get beyond that you're stuck with probabilistic descriptions. 22/7 is exactly as real as pi, you just use different algorithms to evaluate them to the required degree of precision.

When you try to examine the real world too closely using relative human terms like "exists," things get messy. It feels like I'm physically touching the keyboard keys as I type this but I'm not, it's field repulsion rather than physical contact (or rather, it turns out that what we call physical contact is not). It looks like I'm watching snowflakes swirl on the TV, but that's actually a series of still images exploiting meatspace processing limitations and not the continuous process of the real snowflakes falling outside my window - even though from here I can't really tell the difference. The delicious steaming mug of hot chocolate to my right doesn't actually taste like anything but warm river silt, the flavors are being processed by a different organ entirely. Our concept of reality is inexorably linked to how our brains process the signals around us, and every definition of "realness" I've seen based on human terms is weak.

Re:Fundamental physical theory is being replaced with a pseu... by YeGoblynQueenne on Friday December 24, 2021 @06:09AM (#29672615)
>> You can claim that at least some of these are physically grounded in reality as using 1/3 a cup of flour or buying 1/2 a watermelon is certainly something one can very clearly and explicitly do.

To be fair, in practice you can't ever use exactly 1/3 cup of flour or buy exactly 1/2 a watermelon. So even with the fractionals we've started to wriggle away from physical reality in our effort to model it more precisely.

Re:Fundamental physical theory is being replaced with a pseu... by tim333 on Thursday December 23, 2021 @06:56PM (#29668079)
I don't think imaginary numbers were created to describe aspects of our physical reality. They came about more from mucking about with algebra - if you've solved x^2=4 and then wonder how to solve x^2+1=0. Apparently first by Hero of Alexandria in the 1st century AD. You don't really get to aspects of physical reality that are fundamentally complex until you get to quantum mechanics which was discovered a while after that.
Re:Fundamental physical theory is being replaced with a pseu... by katmannthree on Thursday December 23, 2021 @08:23PM (#29668875)
First conceived of then perhaps, but general acceptance came around Euler’s time where they found value (and anchoring in the real world) as a fundamental component of the representation of wave-like behavior.