Re:Tell HN: AWS appears to be down again
by jeremyjh on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @03:53PM
(#29655034)
I don't think putting the hardware into the rack is really the sticking point; what people like about the cloud is that it abstracts all kinds of details away for them and provides a cohesive system to manage it. AWS, Azure and Google are actually selling something like what you are talking about now [1], where for whatever legal/legacy/performance reason you need it on-prem but still want to pay AWS 5x the cost just to give you the same management interface, and they have some kind of pod they slap into your data-center.
What does it tell you that there is a market for this, where essentially what you are buying from them is a management and control plane, when other companies like BMC have been selling that as a standalone product for decades (and for the most part failing to live up to their customer's actual expectations)?
[1] https://www.bizety.com/2020/06/28/aws-outposts-google-anthos...
edit: I actually think a big pull of the cloud is also about shutting down archaic internal IT organizations that have been slowing people down so that it takes weeks and weeks to launch a simple new webservice. Better to give your programmers a cloud account and let them get shit done.
AWS maintains a fiction of turnkey infrastructure, and the reality of building your own is so starkly different that I haven't seen an IT group for some time that could successfully push back on these sorts of discussions.
Building your own datacenter is still too much like maintaining a muscle car, fiddly bits and grease under your fingernails all the time, meanwhile the world has moved on, and we now have several options in soccer mom EVs that can challenge a classic Corvette in the quarter mile, and obliterate its 0-60-0 time. There is no Hyundai for the operations people, and there should be.
I don't know the physics of shipping such a thing, but I think we really do need to be able to buy a populated and pre-wired rack and slot it into the data center. Literally slot it in. If you've ever been curious about maritime shipping, you know that they have a system for securing containers to cranes, trailers, each other, and I don't see a reason you couldn't steal that same design for mounting a server rack to the floor. Other than the pins would need to be removable (eg, a bolt that screws into a threaded hole in the floor) so you don't trip on them.
In a word, we need to make physical servers fungible. There are any number of things that we need to do to get there, but I think we can. Honestly I'm surprised we haven't heard more of this sort of talk from Dell, especially after they bought VMWare. This just seems like a huge failure of imagination. Or maybe it's simply a revolution lacking a poster child. At this rate that 'child' has already been born, and we are just waiting to see who it is.