The test covers the grades 3-9 math curriculum. Not having that kind of basic math literacy is pretty big barrier to being able to evaluate, much less teach, Social Science materiak at the secondary level (the only level where you would likely have a dedicated Social Science teacher.)
And subjecting students to that kind of incompetence—as those from already-disadvantaged backgrounds will be the least likely to have a home environment that counterbalances it—is a far bigger force institutionalizing racial disadvantage than the test itself ever could be.
And if they're not at the secondary level, they're probably supposed to be teaching math.
> The Divisional Court found that the Math Proficiency Test had an adverse impact on entry to the teaching profession for racialized teacher candidates
So the concern is that the tail is wagging the dog -- in the sense that trying to have a certain mix of teachers from various backgrounds drives the requirements instead of requirements being guided by what students need from their teachers
Pretty scary situation. The dumb are winning with the dumbest of arguments and now you can't even test for it to prevent it :)
1. Every policy either is racist, or antiracist. There are no neutral policies.
2. "Racialized" teachers are unable to pass a math test in order to be eligible for the job.
3. Because the policy does not produce an equal outcome, the policy is therefore racist.
Add on top of that, the Smithsonian's ridiculous publication, suggesting that things like objective truth and math/science are concepts of "Whiteness", and this is the outcome.
Harrison Bergeron would like a word.
I think it is a big deal if any teacher isn't great in math, aside from perhaps PE instructors. Considering how much our whole society is supported by math nowadays and how much the average person sucks at math, perhaps teachers who suck at math are not very good role models for children?
I would have finished this sentence perhaps that’s significant evidence that the average person doesn’t need to be great at math.
Are you suggesting that PE should have different grading procedures than other subjects (which reward measured results, or at least in my school did)? Or are you even suggesting in general that all subjects should be graded like this (and for example someone really bad at math but "trying really hard" should actually be getting A's and B's)?
Of course, you could establish a similar grading schemes for physical education, but that would essentially look like grading based on effort and participation.
Oh and in primary school, teachers would go in the teachers lounge to smoke while they were given a break by us being in PE.
For PE we had normatives we were supposed to meet -- so many pullups, etc (based on old soviet army normatives I think :)), and if you don't you got corresponding grade.
I would make sense to break PE course into two -- one about theory and one about skill and have two separate grades for them.
> Learners wishing to enroll in the Mathematics - Intermediate Additional Basic Qualification course may take this test in lieu of official transcript(s) showing proof of successful completion of a minimum of two full university degree credit courses or the equivalent in the teaching subject.
Ontario teaching licenses have qualifications for various grade levels and subject areas. This qualification is intended for people who intend to teach mathematics in grades seven through nine, and the sample test questions reflect that. I very much doubt this test is the one referred to by the courts. If it is, the qualification would be irrelevant (assuming test results reflect the ability to teach a subject competently).
Spent months training her up to a middle school level. We moved states and she took test. No math questions on it…
It think she's covering for a lack of paying attention.
Or maybe she's young, and standards have really slipped? Because otherwise no.
I used to tutor. Quite a lot of kids missed something simple somewhere in the beginning and then were skating by having passable but not good grades. Not understanding what is taught, but getting enough points.
The tutoring consisted of going beck few years and teaching them basics again. They improved, but school never did that "maybe this person now can learn the thing he/she missed 3 years ago".
I remember “factorization” not clicking for me for the longest time in public school. My grades slowly got worse, until the right teacher came along and explained it in a way that clicked. I proceeded to have a successful math focused education in high school and university.
I wonder if part of it is that kids are at the mercy of what their teachers want to teach / the curriculum. I think kids often know which things they struggle with… they need help articulating it, and then someone to work with them through it.
We had one elementary teacher in particular who stated that there was 1 study done in some Nordic country that proved homework does not help. (reference to said study was not provided). Interesting that if you look at high school there is tons of homework; same for university. If that 1 study had any merit it would have applied across all levels. The real truth is that practice makes perfect. But teacher unions do not want that burden on teachers and students suffer in the end. I do not get why elementary schools don't assign homework (I have no doubt private elementary schools do - they get better results).
If you have a parent who recognizes this short changing and is capable of supplementing the education there is a chance for recovery or at least mitigating a decline.
"She has 100m of plastic edging to encloses a circular garden." Hard to believe they let this slip through.
> 7. A number cube is labeled 1 to 6. [...]
What's wrong with the word 'die'?
> 12. There is a linear relationship [...] What type of variation is this relationship and what is its initial value?
What on earth does 'variation' mean here? As far as the answer key is concerned the answer should be 'A partial variation with an initial value of $50.'. Which makes no sense to me whatsoever.
> 13. A rectangle has an area of 5^𝑥2 + 15𝑥 square units. Determine expressions for the length and the width of the rectangle.
Surely that depends on your aspect ratio? It could be sqrt(5x^2 + 15x) for both.
Also their answer key lists the area in question 4 in cm for some reason, if you're going to use units at least use the right one. And you just know someone is going to be anal about question 8, since the answer key doesn't list the exact value '100m/pi' but the approximate 31.8 m.
Also I hope they got a calculator otherwise the answer to question 15 which involves trigonometry is downright unfair.
> What's wrong with the word 'die'?
One usual excuse is to make it clear that it's a d6, rather than a d20 or something, but that's already clear here. The other reasons are that dice still have a connotation of being related to gambling in some people's eyes, which makes it politically incorrect to use the term, and that "die" being a homonym for life ending means that it's also politically incorrect to say.
The test is so basic, it's shame that teachers pushed it up to court.
Just a random pick from samples:
> Nada is landscaping her front yard. She has 100m of plastic edging to encloses a circular garden. What is the diameter of the garden?
We seriously expect teachers to not know about the Pi number?
We expect too little of people. The bar is too low.
Disuse is not incompetence.
Now, they could make every history/language/music teacher try to relearn all these things in order to pass the test and forget it all again, but it's hard to believe it's not a big waste of everyone's time and energy.
Perhaps we expect too little of people, but there's nothing wrong with specialization.
I think it isn't a huge deal if an English or French or Social Studies teacher isn't great in math, but is otherwise a good candidate.
But should someone who fails the math proficiency test be a math teacher? Probably not.
Society should try to match everyone with jobs which they are capable of doing, teaching is a good job. We shouldn't unnecessarily exclude people from doing A just because they lack the skills for doing B.
Here is examples of what is on the test:
https://cpl.oise.utoronto.ca/course/mathematics-proficiency-...
Video discussion of the test questions: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T-7fnPD_c7w