News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Internet Archive as a default host-of-record for startups by FrostKiwi on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:34PM (#29639779)
Public data is... public. No one should be stopped from saving a public page and nothing should stop Internet Archive, be it robot or human. There is if course a need for removal of archived content infringing on someone's rights, whatever that might be, but "archive with consent" will fail for the goal of preserving culture. I think it's worrying that some online newspapers enacted archive blockers or IA needing DMCA excemptions, just so companies can't DMCA anything with their name on it. To preserve journalistic integreity and to save culture, even if it collides intellectual property rights, "archive with consent" won't cut it.
Re:Internet Archive as a default host-of-record for startups by orev on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:42PM (#29639884)
Content posted on a web site is NOT “public” (domain), it is (in the US) automatically copyrighted to the author, unless they specifically waive those rights. Just because you can see it through a browser doesn’t in any way mean you can make it yours and do what you want with it.
Re:Internet Archive as a default host-of-record for startups by Mezzie on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @03:50PM (#29641950)
It doesn't matter.

Archives are exempt from being forbidden to create copies due to copyright infringement. The Library of Congress can make all the copies it wants, it just can't SELL them.

Now, there is a question whether a private company should legally be able to BE an archive of record, but as of now there's no legal reason they can't be, I believe. So it's legal.

Re:Internet Archive as a default host-of-record for startups by FrostKiwi on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:55PM (#29640074)
Absolutely true. "unless they specifically waive those rights" - if archiving entailed contacting the owner with a legal archive request, we would have archived basically nothing. Luckily there are exceptions for Internet Archive in place. My point is, if "by consent" was the requirement to archive information, we would have archived nothing.
Re:Internet Archive as a default host-of-record for startups by ImprobableTruth on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:51PM (#29640000)
We store books in public libraries even if they aren't public domain and authors can do nothing to prevent them from doing so.
Re:Internet Archive as a default host-of-record for startups by ghaff on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @01:10PM (#29640248)
First sale doctrine in the US. If I buy a physical book, I can give it, loan it, throw it in the trash, etc. This doesn't apply to making electronic copies--see what happened with Google Books for example.
Re:Internet Archive as a default host-of-record for startups by rat9988 on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @12:56PM (#29640085)
If you buy the book, you have an authorization to do so. But you can't put copies of it.
Re:Internet Archive as a default host-of-record for startups by Mezzie on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @03:51PM (#29641956)
You do if you're an archive, actually.