News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Move myself to inactive by kevin_thibedeau on Sunday December 19, 2021 @03:18AM (#29612322)
You used to be able to bypass throttling by watching the video in browser during the download.
Re:Move myself to inactive by usr1106 on Sunday December 19, 2021 @05:35AM (#29612847)
I have always wondered why video sites (who don't want downloaders for various reasons) serve their content faster than required for normal speed viewing. Well, I don't complain, but I wonder.
Re:Move myself to inactive by gattilorenz on Sunday December 19, 2021 @05:39AM (#29612868)
For buffering, since there might be a network hiccup sometime in the future. But generally also a better user experience if the user wants to skip a few seconds/minutes forward.

And I guess the bandwidth required also depends on the video bit rate/format/compression ratio, so you need to implement a lot of smarts to make sure you don't serve something too slow or too fast, and still people would be able to download the video, albeit at a slower speed. So, basically, it's not worth it.

Re:Move myself to inactive by foxfluff on Sunday December 19, 2021 @06:44AM (#29613190)
The primary reason I've used ytdl is to work around youtube's crappy buffering.

In the past you used to be able to leave a youtube page open and it'd buffer the whole video but now it stops at like.. thirty seconds? Have fun watching when their servers can't serve.

Re:Move myself to inactive by varenc on Sunday December 19, 2021 @05:37PM (#29619219)
They address this by having the video player stop buffering more than 30 seconds ahead. It's also less compute resources for the servers to send all the bytes for the next 30 seconds to a client at max speed, let the client disconnect and wait 3-5 seconds, then give them the next 3-5 seconds immediately when it's requested. If they only let you download video at a rate slightly faster than video playback rate than all clients would have a constantly open connection downloading video which would tie up more resources.
Re:Move myself to inactive by kaetemi on Sunday December 19, 2021 @07:13AM (#29613320)
Video streams are just a series of 2-second-long video files. It's no different from any regular CDN.

(The real money is in the compression processes.)

Re:Move myself to inactive by cube00 on Sunday December 19, 2021 @08:36AM (#29613810)
I was surprised by just how many small chunks (as you said 2 seconds, a few hundred kilobytes) the browser has to request and string together to make a video stream that play smoothly and that I can skip around. It's kinda amazing when you think about it.