News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by dcow on Sunday December 19, 2021 @01:53AM (#29612008)
It really depends on your ethical framework doesn't it? People lie all the time for good reasons. Are those actions unethical? Further, I am struggling to see who was harmed here or how there was any ill intent. On top of that, the results of this study seem like they would be enlightening. It seems like society should want this experiment to be able to take place. Certainly a western liberal understanding of ethics is more sophisticated than “you didn’t tell them you were observing their behavior bzzzzt unethical”?

Put another way, is “right not to be observed (in public)” something we protect? If I write down my observations at a park as I watch humans interact is that unethical simply because I didn’t bring a megaphone and announce my intent? I think the problem is that despite what’s in vogue, I don’t understand how acting in a way that is not illegal even if it impacts somebody else and then observing the results is by default (unquestionably) unethical. Why is that bad? Are there some “case experiments” the research community looks to where humans where harmed that has shaped our modern understanding?

Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by seanhunter on Sunday December 19, 2021 @09:04AM (#29614014)
"People lie all the time for good reasons. Are those actions unethical?" is whataboutism of the worst kind. We're not talking about any other hypothetical case where a person might lie for good reasons. We're talking about this case, and the lie/misrepresentation was at the heart of why it was unethical.

Secondly, you say you don't see who was harmed - the person who posted the original blog post was clearly harmed. She had a panic attack she was so stressed about the legal implications of the implied threat. The fact that someone else may perhaps have not found receiving this email stressful doesn't really matter - that was the effect on her and it was harmful on its face. Remember that people have different life circumstances which affect things like this - someone who was short of money may see a legal threat with implied financial consequences such as this as an existential threat.

Secondly the people who paid money for legal advice were very clearly also harmed. Their harm has a specific monetary value.

Your "put another way" extrapolation is just a complete straw man. Noone here other than you is talking about observing people in the park. This is about a research study which sent an email which some people saw as scammy or threatening in order to gather data about how small websites handle data subject access requests.

Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by dcow on Sunday December 19, 2021 @09:58AM (#29614421)
> We're not talking about any other hypothetical case where a person might lie for good reasons. We're talking about this case, and the lie/misrepresentation was at the heart of why it was unethical.

I don’t find this type of benign use of anonymity/misdirection to be an outright lie of the unethical kind.

> She had a panic attack she was so stressed about the legal implications of the implied threat.

What?! When/where? She said the request stressed her out… come on. If webmasters have panic attacks when encountering spam then perhaps we should outlaw spam (I’d support this).

> Your "put another way" extrapolation is just a complete straw man. Noone here other than you is talking about observing people in the park.

Please… I 100% do not understand the reason why this experiment should be considered unethical and I’m trying to explain what I see as parallels. It’s not a straw man and I’m not the only one.. read down thread.

What I’m looking for is an explanation for why you think that legal normal behavior (even behavior that causes stress) is allowable but legal normal behavior for science is not allowed.

I also believe context motive and intent matter, for the record (which I why I believe censorship imposes a net negative on society, example: comedians are “allowed” to use offensive language). I simply find the intent here to be arguably ethical depending on what your goal is for society.

For example, if the goal is to never have any individual experience 1 ounce more stress than is absolutely required throughout their life, then this behavior is unethical arguably whether it’s an experiment or not but definitely in the case of the experiment because it’s unnecessary. On the other hand, if your goal as a society is to make sure people’s data privacy rights are protected, it seems strictly ethical to conduct such an exercise to raise awareness and document how well institutions comply with the law.

Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by xena on Sunday December 19, 2021 @01:01PM (#29616385)
OP of the blog article. I didn't have a panic attack. If you want access to my private medical information and are not my doctor, you will not get it. Do not assume anything further.
Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by seanhunter on Sunday December 19, 2021 @02:54PM (#29617653)
Sorry. I read another article on here on the same topic where the person did and conflated the two.

...and actually checking again the person said they "verged on" a panic attack, which is clearly less bad

https://blog.freeradical.zone/post/ccpa-scam-2021-12/

Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by watwut on Sunday December 19, 2021 @02:34AM (#29612143)
The formal ethics of research on humans requires informed consent of participants.

You can take framework of sales or management where lie is just being smart, but it is not applicable here.

Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by hatsunearu on Sunday December 19, 2021 @03:58AM (#29612453)
Deception is allowed, but should be scrutinized carefully to determine if it is necessary. In this case, it was not necessary. The researcher could have easily just said "we want to know if you are compliant with CCPA for the purpose of doing this research, could you tell us your policy please"

https://research.oregonstate.edu/irb/research-involving-dece...

quotes:

a) Psychologists do not conduct a study involving deception unless they have determined that the use of deceptive techniques is justified by the study's significant prospective scientific, educational or applied value and that effective nondeceptive alternative procedures are not feasible.

b) Psychologists do not deceive prospective participants about research that is reasonably expected to cause physical pain or severe emotional distress.

c) Psychologists explain any deception that is an integral feature of the design and conduct of an experiment to participants as early as is feasible, preferably at the conclusion of their participation, but no later than at the conclusion of the data collection, and permit participants to withdraw their data.

a) -- Hell no

b) -- I can give the benefit of the doubt that they didn't foresee small website owners getting panic attacks from this threat, but their non-empathetic tone in that apology write up is appalling

c) -- Hell no

The more I think about this the more I'm furious that a supposedly top tier institution like Princeton approved all of this and the "researchers" seems to have 0 fucks to give on ethical experiment design.

Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by sillysaurusx on Sunday December 19, 2021 @04:09AM (#29612493)
Are you sure that this is applicable to OP's situation? It appears to be a set of guidelines, not a requirement. And in fact, I'm skeptical that there are requirements, except on a university-by-university basis -- which is to say, the process seems much less formal than people are saying.

For example, I would feel comfortable with this study if at the bottom it said "Just kidding, we're actually researchers. Can you explain what was going through your mind when you read this?" even though it's technically deceptive.

I'm a former pentester, and deceptions like this were run all day, every day, by a dedicated team. It's often phase one of phishing, since you end up assuming you're talking to a trustworthy source. So I'm wondering why we seem comfortable with that, but not this.

Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by mission_failed on Sunday December 19, 2021 @07:10AM (#29613311)
Pentesters are hired by companies to use underhanded methods to gain access. Pentesters are not randomly spamming websites with deceptive emails, causing owners to suffer mental anguish and consult expensive lawyers.

University researchers are required to abide by ethical standards to prevent abuse of test subjects. One would assume that this should also include not randomly targeting people with deceptive emails causing them mental suffering and unnecessary legal costs.

Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by hatsunearu on Sunday December 19, 2021 @04:21AM (#29612541)
>It appears to be a set of guidelines, not a requirement.

I don't know about you but I learned about deception in research and its ethical implications in high school. To me, grown-ass adults working in the field of STEM not knowing ethical research, let alone a god damn researcher failing spectacularly and causing harm to an ungodly amount of people through the use of automated means is woefully beyond "oopsie, I really shouldn't have done that"

>For example, I would feel comfortable with this study if at the bottom it said "Just kidding, we're actually researchers. Can you explain what was going through your mind when you read this?" even though it's technically deceptive.

This is kinda what debriefing is, but it is usually more substantial than this. But that still feels extremely amateurish in my eyes. The stated research objective was to have a measure on CCPA/GDPA compliance and did not require deception whatsoever. Either the researcher was not imaginative, they didn't give a fuck, or they just wanted to try deception just for fun.

>I'm a former pentester, and deceptions like this were run all day, every day, by a dedicated team. It's often phase one of phishing, since you end up assuming you're talking to a trustworthy source.

I don't know about you but I hear news all the damn time where phishing emails go wrong--like I think I just saw a testimonial on reddit where fake phishing emails were so aggressive that it literally just ended up discouraging people from using email entirely to the point where people missed assignments and shit. Something similar happened in my company as well and a lot of people got furious.

Fake phishing things should also be heavily controlled, like for us, it is entirely voluntary.

Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by richardw on Sunday December 19, 2021 @08:18AM (#29613684)
As a pentester you’d likely get an OK from the client on which methods were acceptable. Can you phish, etc. An exec would hire you to test their company and you still wouldn’t have carte blanche on methods. I assume you didn’t just YOLO random companies that you thought would be good for your security paper.

Full disclosure: I’ve listened to at least 20 episodes of Darknet Diaries. I’m basically already in your network. ;)

Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by dawnbreez on Sunday December 19, 2021 @01:03PM (#29616406)
> I'm a former pentester, and deceptions like this were run all day, every day, by a dedicated team. It's often phase one of phishing, since you end up assuming you're talking to a trustworthy source. So I'm wondering why we seem comfortable with that, but not this.

Because pentesters get permission up-front. What the hell kind of pentesting operation are you running where trying to penetrate a site that isn't already one of your clients? You'd be in hot water, legally, if you did that--because the sites affected would have every reason to assume that you're malicious.

This is exactly the thing that was gone over last time, in the U of M case where researchers knowingly submitted exploitable code to see how the Linux kernel team would react. They were also compared to pentesters--but pentesters get permission first, and the U of M people didn't, which is why they were treated as malicious by the kernel team.

If you do not have rules of engagement that were agreed upon by the pentesting team and the client, you are not pentesting, you are committing some form of crime. Stop claiming that pentesters are allowed to phish/exploit things without permission, it makes everyone in that community look bad.

Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by sillysaurusx on Sunday December 19, 2021 @04:04AM (#29612471)
As a researcher, I find this fascinating. Would you mind citing the requirements that all human research requires consent?

I agree with it, and I feel it's my duty to be well-informed on this. So I thought I'd ask you.

Everything I can find is only applicable for medical research, and not social research.

Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by aspaceman on Sunday December 19, 2021 @04:52AM (#29612664)
Most universities require all social science research to go through IRB. https://sociology.unc.edu/graduate-program/graduate-research...

I've been seeing this a few times now. Extremely ignorant computer scientists and STEM folks skipping IRB and claiming "theyve never even heard of getting approval for social research". Pretty gross in my view honestly.

Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by mbesto on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @04:21PM (#29655410)
> The formal ethics of research on humans requires informed consent of participants.

How do you explain research on placebos then?

Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by albedoa on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @10:26PM (#29658327)
Participants are informed about and agree to the chance of a placebo.
Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by malwarebytess on Sunday December 19, 2021 @03:55AM (#29612446)
it's not research on humans as such. it was intended to be research on organizations, websites large enough to be subject to the law.
Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by kstrauser on Sunday December 19, 2021 @11:39AM (#29615348)
I got one of these letters, and the website in question has $0.00 revenue, and an order of magnitude fewer total users than would invoke the users. The linked story here is about someone who got a letter to their personal blog.

The researchers did no (or very poor) screening.

Re:I was part of a human subject research study without my c... by malwarebytess on Sunday December 19, 2021 @05:32PM (#29619154)
That I agree with. Their collection methodology was clearly inadequate. They should have been more careful who they mailed, even though they did try to be careful it wasn't enough.