Imagine someone showing up to your office building pretending to have an interview , walking into the office waiting room, then walking out saying “oh, just an experiment!”
“It’s just an email” the ease of the mode of communication here is not super relevant to the action, right?
I'm not aware of the details, but maybe there's an actual Victor Coutant from Nice on the research team. If not, what does it change? The point is precisely to study how a random person trying to defend their rights to privacy will be received/treated by hosts. You can't study that if you sign your emails with "Princeton privacy researcher".
> the mode of communication here is not super relevant to the action, right?
Exactly. Researchers will declare themselves as such before conducting interviews, but they'll rarely hesitate to take notes or ask a simple question as part of a field study.
I mean if you're not happy this researcher is doing their job to investigate how corporate America mistreats people's data privacy rights, i'd be happy to be the person sending tons of pseudonymous automated emails and handing them over to a researcher. Would that change something for you?!
There was a Twitter thread of a number of in-house forwarding to external council which costs time and money. This study incurred monetary damages.
"Answer my questions within 45 days or I will sue you." That seems to read like a demand for a specific action.
Totally different. Obviously. /s
Maybe in your Silicon Valley culture where lawsuits are more easily triggered than private data requests things are different, though. The point is, if the author acknowledged they're running a study in the original email (not the follow-up) they would have skewed their data because corporate assholes don't treat college researchers and common people the same.
The message said:
> I look forward to your reply without undue delay and at most within 45 days of this email, as required by Section 1798.130 of the California Civil Code.
This is clearly a threat of legal action. Your experiences with CNIL might be misleading. There are few risks of getting bankrupt because of a frivolous lawsuit in Europe, but this is a very real risk in the US. Even if you are in the right and did nothing wrong.
The underlying ethos is that researchers should respect the people who are participating in their studies. People should know that you are conducting a study, the aims of the study, and choose whether or not they want to participate.