Re:Uncomfortable Truths in Software Engineering
by fossuser on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @09:44AM
(#29566578)
Imo this is related to value provided. It’s why an excellent tutor can make serious money and be hired by wealthy families to teach kids. Good teaching is a scarce resource.
Many (most?) teachers are bad and the existing incentives don’t require them to be good. It’s hard to fire them and public schools have issues which limit selection and competition.
Perhaps harsh, but some of the dimmest people I knew in highschool became teachers and some of the meanest adults I’ve ever interacted with were teachers too. Obviously great outliers exist, but I’m skeptical they’re the norm.
Most jobs that have high demand, real evaluation of skill, and limited supply of people that can do it well (for whatever reason) pay well in capitalist markets.
The exception I can think of would be something like social work, where demand is high, costs are high and it’s mostly government funded.
Re:Uncomfortable Truths in Software Engineering
by pc86 on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @10:23AM
(#29567123)
I don't think that's an exception, as government funding and capitalist market are more-or-less mutually exclusive, even in capitalist countries. Nobody in a state government makes more than the governor, nobody in the federal government makes more than the President, etc. And for social work specifically, "real evaluation of skill" is going to raise more than a few eyebrows.
Re:Uncomfortable Truths in Software Engineering
by fossuser on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @10:35AM
(#29567325)
Yeah, I think these are all fair points.
Re:Uncomfortable Truths in Software Engineering
by Oregon893 on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:44AM
(#29568347)
I think you forgot what has been the single largest driver of salaries for most Europeans, unions and legistlation.
Re:Uncomfortable Truths in Software Engineering
by pc86 on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:52AM
(#29568456)
I'd rather be a software developer in the US than a teacher in Europe.
Re:Uncomfortable Truths in Software Engineering
by seoaeu on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @12:52PM
(#29569265)
Sure. And I'd rather win the lottery than have socialized healthcare. Obviously it is better to be the beneficiary of income inequality in a country with large disparities of income than it is to work a "normal" job in a more equal society.
Re:Uncomfortable Truths in Software Engineering
by cm2012 on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @09:43AM
(#29566555)
For most non stem teachers, teaching is the best paid job they could possibly get once you account for pension, etc
Re:Uncomfortable Truths in Software Engineering
by pc86 on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:57AM
(#29568538)
Yes even in US public schools, and even for relatively new hires, the benefits can be pretty great. Time off, retirement, etc. And it's still possible to get into administration and make what an entry-level SWE makes. Hell, when I was in HS in the very early 00's there was a big scandal in my area because we found out the district superintendent was making $200k/yr. For context, most of my friends' parents worked blue collar and manual labor jobs. Teachers averaged $44k/yr or so back then.
Anyone can be a teacher. The certification requirements are low. The academic requirements aren't anything more than most kids are getting anyway (a degree in anything will qualify you in most US states). Most teachers need to work so their BATNA is "work someplace else doing the exact same thing for roughly the exact same amount of money." What's more (and I didn't really mention it above) is that you can't tie teaching directly to income. Not that you should be able to, but if you're a quant at an HFT shop you can probably draw a line with a pen from your code to tens of millions of dollars in profit that's there this year that wasn't there last year. Do that year over year and it's hard to argue against you getting paid $800k-1M/yr in cash and bonuses. Helping one of your students read a little better, or finally understand linear algebra, isn't going to increase your personal bottom line at all.