HN feature: A “forum” for topic threads that repeat
We often see certain topics that come around a lot. This week it seems to be variations on "paying open source developers".
Perhaps these can be marked as "forums" or "themes" and collected into a single post.
It is frustrating to watch the same idea posted every day, only to get swept away beyond post 500 or so. At best what we have now is that someone will add a comment that points to a prior post.
A simple (and therefore both controversial and wrong) solution would be to have a "link-to" button that forms a linked list (shades of lisp, eh Paul?).
(
4 comments
| 19 points
| on HN
)
Long-running threads are better suited to discussion formats with strict time ordering. I'm not sure how a vote-ordered hierarchical comments section could keep up a clean presentation of new developments in the discussion. Linking between threads doesn't look like a practical solution to me; I expect we'd still see the same exchanges rehashed in each thread.
I try to abstract the problem (as I understand it) and I see an attempt in finding a perfect system. There might be a system that does justice in treating the content of the discussion well (retrospectively) - but the human aspect of discussions ?. This reminds me of an open source project. If the participants want to treat the discussion seriously, they'd have to do serious research of what has happened until now. No room for a lighthearted quick thought, because it probably has been said earlier on. Someone would rightfully point that out, but would that lead to a healthy atmosphere and exchange of thought for all potential people? Surely in some cases and on some topics and with the right people. But in general, I'm not so sure...
I use that a lot. It's poorly implemented on Quora, but nonetheless, a lot of the time, when someone asks a technical question, it is easier and quicker to find a differently-phrased question and merge the new question with the existing one, than it is to write a comprehensive answer. This way, the person asking immediately sees multiple existing answers... and if people are discussing answers or subtleties of them, then the new asker immediately sees that discussion.
The goal would be that no matter how viral a story gets, it only ever takes up a single slot in the frontpage and new comments section. The UI would mostly remain unchanged (no new buttons or links.)