Re:Hex-rays is moving to a subscription model
by z2 on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @01:44PM
(#29555541)
I've heard that IDA explicitly allows licensed users to decompile IDA itself. What's stopping someone from reverse engineering it transparently and making a competitor?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Hex-rays is moving to a subscription model
by dragontamer on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @01:58PM
(#29555789)
> What's stopping someone from reverse engineering it transparently and making a competitor?
Mostly that Ghidra is open source and no one would be willing to go through the hassle of reverse engineering IDA when Ghidra is just sitting right there...
Re:Hex-rays is moving to a subscription model
by rene77 on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @03:45PM
(#29557388)
Decompilation isn't exactly a rocket science: just about anyone capable of hacking on clang or gcc can write a simple decompiler. The entire point of IDA was that they've done that, and also a lot of tedious, boring work on providing support for lots and lots of different CPUs. There's just no secret sauce recipe for SREs to steal - even their FLIRT tech is documented on their site.
Re:Hex-rays is moving to a subscription model
by dymk on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @01:51PM
(#29555642)
Probably patent law, unless it’s a black-box reverse engineering, in which case you can’t use a disassembler to peek at how it works
Re:Hex-rays is moving to a subscription model
by olliej on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @10:44PM
(#29561834)
Copyright law is what you're after.
Patent law doesn't care about how you get to the same thing - independent invention does not work as a defense.
IANAL, I'm a random on HN, if you take this as legal advice I don't know what to tell you :D
Re:Hex-rays is moving to a subscription model
by unbanned on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @01:50PM
(#29555639)
No it doesn't, it also has a level of protection built in to stop decompiling itself
Re:Hex-rays is moving to a subscription model
by marcodiego on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @01:53PM
(#29555687)
Because reverse engineered code is usually a mess, unmaintainable and takes a lot of effort to make even small improvements. Also, you run the risk of being accused of copyright infringement.
Re:Hex-rays is moving to a subscription model
by thaumasiotes on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @02:10PM
(#29555951)
You mean decompiled code? Reverse engineered code is just code that someone wrote to match the existing functionality of something else.
Re:Hex-rays is moving to a subscription model
by marcodiego on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @02:14PM
(#29555989)
Yeah, right. I mixed up things. Clean-room reverse engineering is, AFAIK, legal.