News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Qubes OS or just separate VMs for separating work... by 99112000 on Monday December 13, 2021 @05:47AM (#29538437)
I have something to say about this as I have ran both setups:

* Qubes for 5 years

* Windows with VMs (1 year)

Long story short I would go with Qubes unless you require Mac OS virtualization, then I would go with a DIY VMs on KVM.

Things I hate about both setups:

* Screensharing, you can only share whatever is in the VM

* Overhead, you need more RAM than you would expect to keep things running smooth, every VM loads it's own kernel. Even in Qubes I typically just run HVMs to keep it simple, installing software in template VMs is kinda annoying

Qubes Pros:

* You get to learn about Xen

* Proper hardware separation easily

* Super easy disk encryption

* UX feels better as you can easily mix windows of different VMs

* Expanding storage is relatively easy and backing up as well

Qubes Cons:

* You get to learn about Xen

* Takes time to setup, audio, camera, mic, video ports not always working as expected

* no way to virtualize Mac OS natively

* No secure boot

I would recommend Qubes, yes it's a pain to setup, but you will learn new things. It will be a more secure environment if done properly.

Re:Ask HN: Qubes OS or just separate VMs for separating work... by samuell on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @01:51PM (#29555659)
Many thanks for this detailed feedback!