Re:NYT R&D Lab uses Kinect to make 'magic mirror' for bathro...
by roc on Friday September 02, 2011 @09:31AM
(#2954003)
I could see a mirror computer for showing things like weather, appointments, pill reminders and maybe some quick news clips or a news scroll.
And of course, there's an opportunity for interactive apps, such as the 'tooth brush watcher/timer' that ensures you're getting good coverage over each section of your teeth for a decent amount of time. And similarly for flossing.
(Though they'd need to do better work in fog-free mirrors than has been done thus far. Because every one I've owned has had its coating lose effectiveness in a few months.)
But what this really begs for, is a continuous computing environment: a whole-house computer that can take your session with you from the bathroom mirror to the bedroom mirror, to the surface-style kitchen table and so on, with speakers and microphones throughout the home so that you can interact with it even without a screen.
In that situation, the value of a bathroom mirror computer isn't judged in the context of "will I be in front of this mirror long enough for it to be useful", but instead in the context of "would I like my whole-house computer to be able to provide me services here too."
Re:NYT R&D Lab uses Kinect to make 'magic mirror' for bathro...
by asolove on Friday September 02, 2011 @09:42AM
(#2954044)
Idea: mount a Kinect on a robotic arm, then hooked up the servos to the Kinect's human movement detection so that the Kinect can follow you moving through a large space.
Re:NYT R&D Lab uses Kinect to make 'magic mirror' for bathro...
by wccrawford on Friday September 02, 2011 @08:15AM
(#2953811)
It's cute, but...
"On average we spend an hour in the bathroom every day"
And only about 3-5 minutes of that is spent in front of a mirror. And even less is spent looking at said mirror. Why would I slow down brushing my teeth to play which-tie-should-I-wear with my mirror? The closet is right around the corner.
Re:NYT R&D Lab uses Kinect to make 'magic mirror' for bathro...
by erikb on Friday September 02, 2011 @08:50AM
(#2953890)
Even if your statics are correct the time spent in a place changes when you can do different things there. In the past people only sat on the toilet to take a shit, but these days you have books, ebooks, netbooks, smartphones. I bet people spend a lot more time there. And this technology can also be used for other mirrors in your house.
AND don't forget people have big, big mirrors in their bedrooms for a reason and then remember the slogan "sex sells" and that the possibilities only stop, where creativity ends.
Re:NYT R&D Lab uses Kinect to make 'magic mirror' for bathro...
by jachreja on Friday September 02, 2011 @08:46AM
(#2953876)
Hopefully someone should get a kick out of my story: Over memorial weekend of this year, my new 360 250gig Slim and entire 360 collection was stolen out of my home.
What they did not take: My kinect and small collection of 2-3 kinect games. Perhaps "Dance Central" Scared them off.
Seeing hacks like this for the kinect has given me something to do with it while I waited for an appropriate deal/time to purchase a new system, but honestly it's a little bit creepy.
I do not think the average consumer would be okay with a camera/internet connected device with a camera in their bathroom. That being said, coolest hack since the head tracking.
Re:NYT R&D Lab uses Kinect to make 'magic mirror' for bathro...
by msutherl on Friday September 02, 2011 @08:43AM
(#2953870)
My friends at Supertouch (also in NYC) who have been doing work with 'interactive mirrors' for years won't be happy about this article: http://www.supertou.ch/
Re:NYT R&D Lab uses Kinect to make 'magic mirror' for bathro...
by 198d on Friday September 02, 2011 @01:00PM
(#2954743)
Sarcasm aside, the fact that this sort of thing is being developed at what, I'm pretty sure, most people would consider a newspaper company is pretty fascinating in and of itself.
Re:NYT R&D Lab uses Kinect to make 'magic mirror' for bathro...
by par on Friday September 02, 2011 @11:18AM
(#2954393)
This looks pretty cool and futuristic, just not sure how extremely useful it is. But anything that brings us closer to our inevitable, dystopian, blade runner-esque world, I am all for.
Re:NYT R&D Lab uses Kinect to make 'magic mirror' for bathro...
by th0ma5 on Friday September 02, 2011 @03:17PM
(#2955254)
i'm kind of sick of NYT co-opting a lot of things that the whole experimental media community is doing, and not contributing back code, nor even citing sources.
And of course, there's an opportunity for interactive apps, such as the 'tooth brush watcher/timer' that ensures you're getting good coverage over each section of your teeth for a decent amount of time. And similarly for flossing.
(Though they'd need to do better work in fog-free mirrors than has been done thus far. Because every one I've owned has had its coating lose effectiveness in a few months.)
But what this really begs for, is a continuous computing environment: a whole-house computer that can take your session with you from the bathroom mirror to the bedroom mirror, to the surface-style kitchen table and so on, with speakers and microphones throughout the home so that you can interact with it even without a screen.
In that situation, the value of a bathroom mirror computer isn't judged in the context of "will I be in front of this mirror long enough for it to be useful", but instead in the context of "would I like my whole-house computer to be able to provide me services here too."
And I think that's a much more compelling case.
Hmm, what could I do with that?
http://wiredcontroller.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/196903...
"On average we spend an hour in the bathroom every day"
And only about 3-5 minutes of that is spent in front of a mirror. And even less is spent looking at said mirror. Why would I slow down brushing my teeth to play which-tie-should-I-wear with my mirror? The closet is right around the corner.
Honestly, that statistic doesn't even pass the smell test.
AND don't forget people have big, big mirrors in their bedrooms for a reason and then remember the slogan "sex sells" and that the possibilities only stop, where creativity ends.
What they did not take: My kinect and small collection of 2-3 kinect games. Perhaps "Dance Central" Scared them off.
Seeing hacks like this for the kinect has given me something to do with it while I waited for an appropriate deal/time to purchase a new system, but honestly it's a little bit creepy.
I do not think the average consumer would be okay with a camera/internet connected device with a camera in their bathroom. That being said, coolest hack since the head tracking.
Seriously though - it's a great tech, but their focus on ad revenue at the prototyping phase is disturbing.