News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hertz customers arrested, jailed and held at gunpoint aft... by kube-system on Sunday December 12, 2021 @09:33PM (#29535924)
That's not necessarily true. The vast majority of individual people that file chapter 7 don't give up a penny. US bankruptcy law is surprisingly progressive for the little guy -- even compared to other progressive countries.
Re:Hertz customers arrested, jailed and held at gunpoint aft... by netizen-936824 on Sunday December 12, 2021 @10:30PM (#29536299)
You but we aren't discussing bankruptcy. If you call the police and give them false information to get someone else arrested. I'll bet that when they find out, you'll be the one getting arrested. These CEOs and board members don't even get fined personally, the company usually pays
Re:Hertz customers arrested, jailed and held at gunpoint aft... by kube-system on Sunday December 12, 2021 @10:57PM (#29536443)
There is no claim that a CEO or board member made any false statements to police in this story. Furthermore, no matter who at Hertz called it in, the crime of "making false statements" generally requires that the statements be knowingly and willfully wrong.

If Hertz reports a car stolen because front desk staff made a mistake, that's simply not criminal. This also applies to you as an individual too. If you report your car stolen when you forgot where you parked it, that is also not criminal. Hertz is being treated the same as you would be.

I don't see anything in this story that describes a crime. (except for the people who may have actually stolen cars) These are descriptions of civil wrongdoings.

Re:Hertz customers arrested, jailed and held at gunpoint aft... by jfrunyon on Sunday December 12, 2021 @11:56PM (#29536774)
You're completely ignoring the point of the comment that you're responding to. Someone at Hertz is culpable for not taking steps to prevent this from happening.
Re:Hertz customers arrested, jailed and held at gunpoint aft... by kube-system on Monday December 13, 2021 @12:10AM (#29536850)
I don't understand what you think I am ignoring.

> Someone at Hertz is culpable for not taking steps to prevent this from happening.

Of course, this is what the 191 lawsuits are about. They are to determine Hertz's culpability in -- with what the article describes -- are the civil wrongdoings I mentioned in my above comment.

Re:Hertz customers arrested, jailed and held at gunpoint aft... by akomtu on Monday December 13, 2021 @03:33AM (#29537837)
Organizations are good at diffusing responsibility. Even when crime is egregious, like the pfas leak, and would be enough to sentence everyone in the organization to life in prison, justice can't find anyone who is directly liable, so nobody is punished.
Re:Hertz customers arrested, jailed and held at gunpoint aft... by glogla on Monday December 13, 2021 @04:33AM (#29538128)
Some say this diffusion of responsibility is the point of modern corporate structure.
Re:Hertz customers arrested, jailed and held at gunpoint aft... by mantaraygun on Monday December 13, 2021 @12:23AM (#29536911)
> Someone at Hertz is culpable for not taking steps to prevent this from happening.

It's far from clear that anybody at Hertz is criminally culpable, which is what was suggested upthread, with talk of people making false statements being arrested.

Re:Hertz customers arrested, jailed and held at gunpoint aft... by jfrunyon on Monday December 13, 2021 @05:35PM (#29545584)
Which is indisputably a problem with our society.
Re:Hertz customers arrested, jailed and held at gunpoint aft... by kube-system on Monday December 13, 2021 @10:36PM (#29547922)
I think, that to suggest that people should be held criminally responsible for the mistakes of others (assuming that these are mistakes), is a pretty extreme position. Over-criminalization of everything a much more problematic situation that had led to larger problems with mass incarceration that underlies many of the most significant problems that the US has.

The solution to everything isn't "lock 'em up and throw away the key". We have functional civil courts, and they are more than capable of remediating wrongs.

Re:Hertz customers arrested, jailed and held at gunpoint aft... by jfrunyon on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @05:26PM (#29558963)
No. They should be held responsible for their own mistakes. I'm not sure who else but the CEO and board you think have the ability and responsibility to make sure their company is acting appropriately.

> We have functional civil courts, and they are more than capable of remediating wrongs

That's actually a good one. Thanks for the laugh.

Re:Hertz customers arrested, jailed and held at gunpoint aft... by caf on Monday December 13, 2021 @06:23AM (#29538612)
Perhaps for the first, or second, or tenth instance - but surely at some point, if certain senior people at Hertz know, or ought to know, that their system has a track record of making incorrect accusations, and they continue to use it anyway, it must rise to at least a standard of wilful indifference to whether or not the statements are correct.
Re:Hertz customers arrested, jailed and held at gunpoint aft... by kube-system on Monday December 13, 2021 @10:03AM (#29540172)
According to the statement by Hertz in the article, it seems that they believe the majority of the statements are correct.

If there’s some memo floating around that says otherwise, then maybe it’s a crime.

Re:Hertz customers arrested, jailed and held at gunpoint aft... by caf on Monday December 13, 2021 @06:48PM (#29546291)
Is an honest belief that there's a bare 51% probability that my statement is correct really good enough?
Re:Hertz customers arrested, jailed and held at gunpoint aft... by kube-system on Monday December 13, 2021 @10:55PM (#29548039)
It doesn't work like that. It's not graded on a percentage scale, it's pass/fail.

"Knowingly" and "willfully" have legally significant meanings with their own standards of the mental state that qualifies. It is then up to the court to determine whether or not your actions have met those conditions.

Re:Hertz customers arrested, jailed and held at gunpoint aft... by caf on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @05:40AM (#29550248)
I ask because "believe a majority of the statements are correct" can mean as little as "more likely to be correct that not" - it's pretty weak tea.
Re:Hertz customers arrested, jailed and held at gunpoint aft... by YZF on Monday December 13, 2021 @12:35AM (#29536974)
Why isn't not returning the rental car also a civil wrongdoing? You violated the rental contract, let Hertz process that as a civil case?
Re:Hertz customers arrested, jailed and held at gunpoint aft... by throwawayffffas on Monday December 13, 2021 @04:39AM (#29538153)
I think you are correct on this, this is indeed a civil matter, it's called voluntary parting, in other cases that made it to this site where people have tried to report to the police that the camera they rented out or something was never returned were told it's not theft. I think what happens is that they report the vehicles to the police as stolen, as they would if they found a car missing from the lot, instead of telling them someone did not return it.
Re:Hertz customers arrested, jailed and held at gunpoint aft... by kube-system on Monday December 13, 2021 @09:48AM (#29540032)
This varies. Some state laws specifically criminalize the failure to return rental cars in plain language. For example: https://law.justia.com/codes/nevada/2010/title15/chapter205/...
Re:Hertz customers arrested, jailed and held at gunpoint aft... by kube-system on Monday December 13, 2021 @12:39AM (#29536997)
I'm not 100% sure, but believe this is the case in many states.

As to why some states criminalize it... I don't know, too many years of voting for tough-on-crime politicians?

Re:Hertz customers arrested, jailed and held at gunpoint aft... by FireBeyond on Monday December 13, 2021 @01:00AM (#29537109)
I'd love to see which states consider it civil-only.

In every one I've heard of, it can (and eventually will, for varying values of 'eventually') get you arrested for grand theft auto.

Re:Hertz customers arrested, jailed and held at gunpoint aft... by kube-system on Monday December 13, 2021 @01:31AM (#29537273)
I don't disagree. Let me slightly backtrack on my previous statement: I think some states explicitly spell out penalties for failure to return a rental car, while in others, it may be up to the specific circumstances to determine whether a crime has taken place or whether it is a civil disagreement or misunderstanding on terms, etc.

I remember a recent rental car contract of mine that pointed out these specific state laws. e.g.: https://law.justia.com/codes/nevada/2010/title15/chapter205/...

Re:Hertz customers arrested, jailed and held at gunpoint aft... by jjk166 on Monday December 13, 2021 @11:15AM (#29540929)
Because then people without sufficient assets to go after would basically be unable to rent a car.