News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The College For-Profits Should Fear by SkyMarshal on Friday September 02, 2011 @03:19AM (#2953235)
The one they should really worry about is Khan Academy:

1. Free

2. Gamification of learning (aka certification)

3. Social web integrated into learning (a network to see your certifications)

4. Inverting the traditional model - do your homework in class watch vids/read at night at home.

KA is on the way toward replacing traditional degrees the same way Stackoverflow and Github are replacing traditional resumes.

Re:The College For-Profits Should Fear by dagw on Friday September 02, 2011 @03:29AM (#2953260)
Once KA starts offering courses that are at university level, perhaps. But as it stands the level of the topics covered on KA is far to superficial to threaten universities. That's not to say it won't happen, but so far I've seen no indication of it.

PS. With all that being said, I'm huge fan of KA, and rooting for their continued success. I just think they're better suited to take on high schools rather than universities.

Re:The College For-Profits Should Fear by perfmode on Friday September 02, 2011 @03:34AM (#2953269)
Fundamental? Yes. Superficial? No.
Re:The College For-Profits Should Fear by tomjen3 on Friday September 02, 2011 @06:59AM (#2953648)
I believe hé meant superficial in the way that the courses don't go into the deep end of the subject the way a university course might (which is absolutely ok, as it is not aimed at students at that level, but at the same time it means that it cannot replace a real university).
Re:The College For-Profits Should Fear by patio11 on Friday September 02, 2011 @06:37AM (#2953614)
KA will matter to for-profit universities the minute a KA score triggers your union contract to bump your salary up. (The existence of this interaction is a major reason why for-profit universities love teachers.)
Re:The College For-Profits Should Fear by tomjen3 on Friday September 02, 2011 @07:04AM (#2953657)
What is required to trigger the bumb in the salary? I ask, because I assume that the education has to be relevant.
Re:The College For-Profits Should Fear by rmc on Friday September 02, 2011 @07:38AM (#2953729)
Getting a piece of paper (i.e. degree/certification). Lots of old fashioned rules are still around that automatically promote you to a new pay grade if you suddenly have a new qualification
Re:The College For-Profits Should Fear by sologoub on Friday September 02, 2011 @11:33AM (#2954452)
Paper has to come from an accredited institution, right?

So, there is some bureaucratic stuff involved in order to be able to qualify for issuing the paper. Not sure KA meets that requirement yet.

Re:The College For-Profits Should Fear by rmc on Friday September 02, 2011 @05:16PM (#2955628)
Yes the bit of paper has to come from The Right Sort of Place. KA probably doesn't count. And that's why The Right Sort of Places aren't worried.
Re:The College For-Profits Should Fear by neovive on Friday September 02, 2011 @12:09PM (#2954566)
Many teachers are required to have degrees or a specific numbers of Graduate-level credits from an accredited university. It will likely be a long time before they accept KA certificates. KA would need to partner with some of the accredited universities in the interim that could then accept some number of KA certificates as transfer credits.
Re:The College For-Profits Should Fear by rimantas on Friday September 02, 2011 @05:46AM (#2953524)
Really? I guess I am in minotrity, but after watching a few lessons on KA I I left with impression that quality of teaching is quite poor. Educational videos may be one part of education, but they cannot replace all. Teachers are there to stay for a long long time and it has nothing todo with technology.
Re:The College For-Profits Should Fear by jeffreymcmanus on Friday September 02, 2011 @11:34AM (#2954453)
Exactly right. Khan Academy's macro effect on K-12 education at present is limited to challenging the value and application of lectures. (Gamification of education which is not an original concept at all.)

It's not even close to replacing instruction, since there are dozens of valuable things that instructors do besides lecture.

And the notion that it will replace or even put a dent in traditional higher ed in our lifetime is pretty uninformed -- that isn't the problem they're setting out to fix.

Re:The College For-Profits Should Fear by tomjen3 on Friday September 02, 2011 @07:08AM (#2953661)
I don't know about the quality of the other subjects (since I don't know enough about them to judge him) but I do know that his economy lectures were pretty good.
Re:The College For-Profits Should Fear by wiredfool on Friday September 02, 2011 @11:29AM (#2954437)
A halfway engaged HS physics teacher would do far better than the videos I sampled on basic kinematics and newtons laws.

The stuff there is just _begging_ for in person demos.

From what I've seen, KA is better than nothing, or a really indifferent teacher. But If you have a better than average teacher, they're going to far surpass KA.

Re:The College For-Profits Should Fear by michaelchisari on Friday September 02, 2011 @01:07PM (#2954775)
Reminds me of the quote, "Any teacher that can be replaced by a computer, deserves to be."

I love the quote, but of course, I am concerned that in our push to move to computer-based learning, we push out the teachers who can't be replaced by a computer.

Re:The College For-Profits Should Fear by ap22213 on Friday September 02, 2011 @06:30AM (#2953599)
Not knowing KA well enough, would anyone here hire someone with only KA credentials? Does a KA certification add much in hirability value?
Re:The College For-Profits Should Fear by tokenadult on Friday September 02, 2011 @09:06AM (#2953929)
would anyone here hire someone with only KA credentials?

I definitely would NOT hire anyone only with Khan Academy credentials in mathematics. Mathematics courses are what made Khan Academy famous, and as far as I know, Salman Khan does about as well as anyone in online mathematics lectures. (I've seen very little of his lectures, or of anyone's, as I would rather read books about mathematics than watch videos about mathematics.)

But "mathematics is not a spectator sport," in the oft-repeated phrase, and no one can get a complete education in mathematics without solving A LOT of problems.

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2760663

The Khan Academy developers are aware of this issue, and are currently rewriting the exercise engine(s) on Khan Academy to make more challenging online exercises for the Khan Academy math courses. But it will take a long time to get the delivery model of the courses unstuck from exercises and fully interweaved into problem-solving.

An organization that is much farther along in building an infrastructure of sound mathematical instruction based on problem-solving is Art of Problem Solving, which has a free online problem-solving database called Alcumus

http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Alcumus/Introduction.php

and many online courses in various levels of mathematics, supported by thoroughly written textbooks

http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Store/index.php?

and an increasing number of video lectures, as well as discussion forums.