News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Professional maintainers: a wake-up call by saghm on Saturday December 11, 2021 @07:26PM (#29525716)
I think the point is that while it would be awesome to just have everyone pay open source maintainers what they can afford to when they use their project, in practice relying on people's (or worse, companies') good will is a losing strategy. It seem wildly unrealistic to just expect that everyone will just naturally give back to open source in a meaningful way absent any actual incentives or requirements, and even if it did start happening there would be nothing the situation from returning to the way it was before. I think most of the arguments you'll see against the idea of "just give back to open source maintainers even though you aren't required to" aren't skeptical of the idea that people should be compensated for their work, but just skeptical that peer pressure is the only thing needed to turn the current open source model into one where all maintainers are fairly compensated.
Re:Professional maintainers: a wake-up call by mbrodersen on Saturday December 11, 2021 @08:27PM (#29526170)
You are absolutely right. The naivety of most open source developers when it comes to understanding how people/companies/markets work is jaw dropping. If you ask people to pay $0 for your work then that is exactly what they will pay. Wishing for things to be different is a waste of time. Accept how the world works and act accordingly.
Re:Professional maintainers: a wake-up call by wpietri on Saturday December 11, 2021 @09:57PM (#29526717)
That isn't "the world". It's a relatively small set of people in a relatively small chunk of history that see themselves as entitled to make endless profit without ever worrying about where that comes from or who it hurts. It's not a sustainable mindset, so it never lasts.

Look at the shift in attitudes toward the environment in the last 100 years as an example. There was a point where executives thought it absolutely fine to pollute wildly. That consequences were for the little people. Through a mix of culture change and improved regulation, that has changed, and it continues to change.

A more recent example is the trend toward corporate social responsibility, which looks at a broad set of problems and devotes corporate resources toward fixing them: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_social_responsibilit...

Do they put in enough money? Surely not. But it's indicative of the kind of culture shift we can push for here.

Re:Professional maintainers: a wake-up call by Aeolun on Saturday December 11, 2021 @10:48PM (#29526953)
> It's a relatively small set of people in a relatively small chunk of history

I think it’s a fairly large chunk of history (e.g. all the time humans were a thing) that this applies to. The fact that it weren’t executives but kings, queens and nobles thinking this way doesn’t really change much.

It’s not even necessarily malicious, but you really don’t want to think about the fact your life is so comfortable at the expense of other people.

Re:Professional maintainers: a wake-up call by gilleain on Sunday December 12, 2021 @06:35AM (#29528781)
I agree with your general point, but Kings and Queens absolutely had to consider other people.

Specifically, most rulers had some kind of patronage network where they gave out 'gifts' like land, or the right to collect taxes, in return for loyalty. Princes did not generally just sit on a huge pile of money, like a dragon. If they wanted to go to war or build a palace, they had raise taxes, which meant concessions to their power.

Anyway, slightly off-topic! Still, the analogy holds - you don't get to be a prince of the internet without the work of a lot of minor nobles.

Re:Professional maintainers: a wake-up call by wpietri on Sunday December 12, 2021 @10:02AM (#29530143)
So what's your evidence here besides some hazy gesturing at "kings, queens and nobles"?

Because when you look at actual history, you see long-running mutual relationships. E.g. the English Commons system: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_land

Or you could look at the Mexican ejido system: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ejido

Which descends from the Aztec capulli system: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calpulli

Historically, leadership was tightly bound to productive land, because that's what everybody needed to survive. Your "nobles" could in the long term only be as successful as the people they ruled over, and the feedback loops there weren't long ones. Were there sometimes bad nobles and bad kings? Sure. But overall, the badness was limited because harming the "infrastructure" of the day, land and people, was felt quickly by people higher up the hierarchy. Sustainability was a must.

That's distinct from modern capitalism in the age of industry and information technology, because the portability of wealth and the long feedback loops mean executives can get quite rich in unsustainable situations. The elevation of an IGMFY ideology to become the dominant view of the moneyed was only recently possible because for most of history one couldn't escape the consequences like people can now.

Re:Professional maintainers: a wake-up call by cxr on Sunday December 12, 2021 @07:46PM (#29535326)
You haven't worked enough shit jobs if you think that un-"moneyed" plebs aren't similarly willing to fuck someone else over if it means they have the opportunity to three-quarters-ass their work and leave the rest to a coworker who they are on a first-name basis with and is otherwise friendly to them.

"IDGAF, it's not me" and "ask for forgiveness, not permission" is not in any sense a minority viewpoint. Even people who insist they don't follow those creeds have the issue of being, more often than not, unreliable narrators of their own actions—not to mention: economically irrational in ways that extend to the economics of non-monetary, give-and-take systems.

Re:Professional maintainers: a wake-up call by mbrodersen on Sunday December 12, 2021 @12:41AM (#29527434)
Which world are you talking about? History is full of people exploiting other people. Mention any period of history where people were not trying their damn hardest to exploit other people?
Re:Professional maintainers: a wake-up call by wpietri on Sunday December 12, 2021 @10:03AM (#29530152)
You've the one making a positive claim. Let's see your evidence that this was the dominant mode of thought in all places and all times.
Re:Professional maintainers: a wake-up call by mbrodersen on Sunday December 12, 2021 @06:24PM (#29534771)
What are you talking about? You are the one that's making the following claim:

> That isn't "the world". It's a relatively small set of people in a relatively small chunk of history that see themselves as entitled to make endless profit ...

Which is a claim that can't be proven either way since you are talking about how people in all of history was thinking. In other words, you are making a claim that is just wishful thinking.

Re:Professional maintainers: a wake-up call by wpietri on Sunday December 12, 2021 @07:30PM (#29535234)
You have made a claim about "how the world works". Where's your backing for it?
Re:Professional maintainers: a wake-up call by mbrodersen on Monday December 13, 2021 @03:31AM (#29537824)
You made the opposite claim. Where is your evidence for it?
Re:Professional maintainers: a wake-up call by DarylZero on Monday December 13, 2021 @09:54AM (#29540091)
Seems we're at an impasse.
Re:Professional maintainers: a wake-up call by donw on Saturday December 11, 2021 @07:44PM (#29525888)
You're largely correct, but I'm not speaking about peer pressure.

'Tis the season, so we've been listening to a lot of Christmas carols.

One of my favorites is Good King Wenceslas, which concludes with the verse: "Therefore, Christian men, be sure, wealth or rank possessing, Ye who now will bless the poor, shall yourselves find blessing."

Charity used to be a behavioral expectation in the West. Charity is not "giving money to somebody else so they can do charity on your behalf" nor is it "paying taxes to fund social programs". Charity is you, directly, investing your resources in your community, with no expectation of return.

Today, this assumption no longer holds. The result is the current state of open source, which needs to figure out a license that extracts value from players big enough to pay it, without punishing upstarts into oblivion (and thus forming a protective moat for existing large players).

Some percentage of net revenue share strikes me as the right sort of license, with sensible caps and/or some sort of shared pooling mechanism.

Re:Professional maintainers: a wake-up call by perl4ever on Saturday December 11, 2021 @09:43PM (#29526641)
>Charity is not "giving money to somebody else so they can do charity on your behalf" nor is it "paying taxes to fund social programs". Charity is you, directly, investing your resources in your community, with no expectation of return.

Can you give some concrete examples? Because I can't tell what distinction you are trying to define, at all.

In which bucket would you put:

   1) Giving money to a local hospital
   2) Volunteering with a non-profit organization
   3) Giving cash to a wandering schizophrenic
   4) Buying lunch for someone who's been holding up a cardboard sign at an off-ramp
   5) Giving money to the United Way through paycheck deductions.
   6) Giving money to an organization that funds research into a disease
   7) Giving money to a local organization that gives grants and loans to disadvantaged people to start small businesses.
   8) *Lending* money to a local non-profit that gives loans to disadvantaged people to start small businesses.
   9) Giving money to a local food bank.
   10) Donating blood to the Red Cross
   11) Giving money to the Red Cross
Re:Professional maintainers: a wake-up call by pabs3 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @09:34PM (#29526595)
Such a license doesn't seem likely to fit the Open Source Definition.
Re:Professional maintainers: a wake-up call by meribold on Sunday December 12, 2021 @01:30AM (#29527604)
Some projects use a copyleft license like the GPL or AGPL by default but also sell their product under another license to parties that want to avoid copyleft. This way the product is FOSS but companies that want to use it in their proprietary software have to pay.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multi-licensing#Business_model...