Anyway, I don't have much faith an operation ran by an old con artist and a 24-yr old actress would actually produce a valid zK-proof that covers their operations. That's the sort of thing you need a serious technical team for. So the article still stands in that regard.
Someone might be able to demonstrate to you that they have a $20k bank balance.
Audits are where you try to do a reasonable job of making sure they aren't also hiding the fact that they've got $50k in credit card debt lying around.
I do know there are many ways to get those high ROIs in DeFi.
With zero evidence suggesting they are lying about returns, the charitable guess I can make is that they are getting high DeFi returns and giving their customers slightly lower ones after taking a cut.
Not the user facing side, but the backend/underlying part that generates the returns necessary to sustain those yields.
You can earn even more if you provide liquidity for riskier assets that have a higher chance of dropping in value.
The risks are impermanent loss and that the token you're providing liquidity for drops in value.
Yearn is a decentralized automated tool to find the platform that is giving the best returns and moving all the money they manage into it.
All of this is open source and on the blockchain.
Even though these are "fees" or "loans", the purpose is strictly speculation. It's not driven by intrinsic value, but people attempting to make money via speculation.
If I take a loan for a house, I can live in it. That's intrinsic value.
So the system only works to the extent that people are willing to pay for tokens without intrinsic value. Does not seem sustainable to me
If everyone suddenly decides they don't want to trade any more, then I'll find somewhere else to invest my money.
Specific vaults strats: https://medium.com/yearn-state-of-the-vaults/the-vaults-at-y...
Links to the actual contracts: https://yearn.watch/
They basically just say "we put it in a vault and harvest the rewards".
What I'm asking is where do the rewards come from. What is the underlying mechanism that makes this model sustainable.
If you invest in a REIT, tenants earn money through their business and pay rents. If you invest in a BDC, the BDC makes loans to businesses and collects interest. Relationship and risks are quite clear here.
If you're Bernie Madoff you generated high yields for investors for decades by taking money from one investor to pay another, and ultimately was not sustainable and bankrupted many people. For example.
So are DeFi yields like a BDC, or like a Bernie Madoff?
When the explanation is too complex for anyone to really grasp or verify, realize that this is probably intentionally opaque in order to hide the fact that it is either hugely risky, built on a house of cards or it may be just outright fraud.
The sUSD yVault deposits sUSD into overcollateralized lending protocols and collects interest on loans to other users (who are presumably using Aave or CREAM as places to buy leverage to get super fucking long crypto). So the yield comes from other users paying interest to borrow sUSD.
Background/Disclaimer: I'm long crypto and have significant assets in Gemini's Earn program, a regulated variant of crypto lending that pays 8% on their stablecoin, GUSD.
I found Celsius and Yearn to be too sketchy/inscrutable to bother with[1], so I'm not going to defend anything about them, only the narrower claim that (some) DeFi liquidity pools are a non-Ponzi, sane way to earn returns in some conditions.
Liquidity pools [2] function as automatic market makers, using their assets to allow traders to trade between two cryptocurrencies. As a liquidity provider, you lock up two cryptos in return for a cut of the fees it takes from traders; your cut is proportional to how much liquidity you contributed. Those pools expose an interface to the Eth network that lets anyone put one of the cryptos in and take the other out, with a pre-determined formula for how it figures the exchange rate. Its profitability comes from the extent to which this exchange (after accounting for both pool fees and Eth network fees) gives a better deal to traders than their other alternatives (like centralized exchanges).
Like any market maker, you face the risk of "impermanent loss" from the shift in relative value of the cryptos, as market makers make standing buy/sell offers which look stupid when the market moves against them. There are also setup fees and all the usual risks associated with smartcontracts. When you consider how long you have to leave them in the pool to make a profit, and those fixed setup fees, plus the opportunity costs of lending through other providers with less volatility[4], the returns (3-100%) just about barely compensate you for the risk.
I experimented with them starting about three months ago and made a presentation, for which you're welcome to see the slides (slide 7 summarizes the downsides):
https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1BrMMbL5vOzdnkaPVj5mO...
Contra bhouston's claim [3], these LPs don't require ETH to perpetually gain value: as long as traders continue to use the pool, ETH could stay stagnant or even fall significantly and they will still pay a return, though a long-term fall would induce a big impermanent loss (in an ETH-stablecoin pool) that would take a while for fees to compensate you for. (Edit: Although I suppose you could argue that people won't keep trading between ETH and other tokens unless that speculation, in the aggregate, is merited -- but it's not a simple matter of the pools only being profitable as some kind of derivative of ETH's value.)
[1] In the case of Celsius, largely because of this: https://prohashing.com/guides/earning-interest-on-crypto
[2] I've mainly worked with Uniswap v3; some of the details may vary slightly in other protocols.
[3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29498814
[4] For example, Gemini will lend out your GRT tokens at 6.4%, so that's your minimal return for this to be a good idea.
These aren't loans that are made to acquire some intrinsic value, like buying a house, investing into growing a business and so on. People use this liquidity or take crypto loans to try to make more money elsewhere in crypto.
Is that right? Is there a tie to the real world in there?
To me, this appears quite unsustainable and prone to failure if a risk off event comes. How would crypto have performed during the GFC? It's fallen 80% before even in times where economy has been perfectly fine. The whole ecosystem is ripe to implode due to 0 intrinsic value to owning the tokens that would otherwise cushion a fall in value.
Even in a severe recession, cashflowing businesses have value, rental properties have value. Crypto has none that I can tell.
>Even though these are "fees" or "loans", the purpose is speculation. The whole web of connections in the flow of the money is rooted by people speculating to make money.
LPs don't have "fees", they just have regular fees, no need for scare quotes.
>These aren't loans that are made to acquire some intrinsic value, like buying a house, investing into growing a business and so on. People use this liquidity or take crypto loans to try to make more money elsewhere in crypto.
I don't have an special expertise on what the crypto loans on Gemini/Celsius are for, beyond what their literature says. However, everything you've said there applies just as well to (secured) margin loans that brokerages make. Do you have the same objections to those?
I guess the charitable explanation for them raising capital as expensively as possible from randoms on the internet is they're feeling charitable themselves. I seem to remember that was how all the pre-crypto HYIP "investments" explained the generosity of their compounding daily return offers
The crux of the OP’s argument to me is that The company and others in this space position the yields as being “in kind” to savings account yields despite it very much being a different risk ballgame. See the frequent hacks on https://rekt.news/ for example.
Do sites like Celsius explicitly claim to be as safe as insured savings banks? No of course not but they play a similar linguistic game of association to Tesla’s “autopilot” nomenclature.
As with most things do your own research and don’t risk what you can’t lose.
What's the ROI on staking ETH right now? Is it anywhere near the rate that they claim?
>selling covered calls
you're taking on risk when doing that. It works well until you get assigned, in which case you take a massive loss and unable to pay back your investors.
Selling naked calls has a lot more risk, see the blowup of optionsellers.com on naked natural gas options
The loss comes from the opportunity cost of what you could have sold the underlying asset for. That might or might not be "massive", but the potential is definitely there. At the end of the day you're picking up pennies in front of a steamroller. Maybe it even has expected value greater or equal to the advertised APY, but failing to disclose that and/or pretending like it's guaranteed is deceptive. I'd be pissed if I put my money into some sort of "savings account" with 8% APY, then get wiped out next time there's a spike/dip, because it turned out that they were using it to write covered calls.
Tether feels like the most likely POF based purely on the attention they're getting now, but nobody knows exactly how it will bust.
I keep seeing this for DeFi.
- So you put 1 fiat into the magic box, and 2 fiat comes out. Where did the 1 fiat profit come from?
- DeFi collateralized staking algorithms hash protocol incentives!
- Yeah whatever but no really, it's a closed system so all inputs and outputs need to sum up, where did the new fiat come from?
- YoU dOnT uNdErStAnD cRYpTo!!1!!
1. You put $1 of ETH into a new protocol, let’s say a new Decentralized Exchange on Ethereum that is paying a high amount of interest in order to attract liquidity to their protocol. The high interest is perhaps paid in ETH or maybe in a new token for the protocol.
2. Users flock to this new DEX, and actually use it, generating trading fees for the DEX, which drains activity from CEXs like Coinbase. If in step 1, the payment was made with a new token, perhaps that new token either earns a cut of trading fees, or gets governance rights over the DEX.
3. You either earned another $1 of ETH, or of the new token.
In the above example, it’s not a closed system anymore than the US economy is. A new company was created, which created real value by creating a better exchange which attracted users over CEXs. The company has value now it can payout because it generates trading fees and the equity/governance of the company is valuable. It bootstrapped that with protocol incentives.
That and unlike stablecoins the Fed doesn't pretend it's fully backed.
Is this not the very definition of a ponzi scheme? The returns coming from "incentives" of these protocols and "speculation" in those native assets sounds very ponzi-like to me.
Of course hedge funds don't have steady 10% yields, they lose money when their risky bets don't pan out.
You will only ever make more money if somebody buys in after you.
Unlike stocks where owning a share entitles you to profit stream of the company (intrinsic value)
Like, if I set up a business "investing" in worthless penny stocks and somehow manage to generate returns, I'm not running a Ponzi. Maybe I'm pumping and dumping those penny stocks. It's still a scheme, it's just not a Ponzi- I am actually earning money for my investors! I'm defrauding other people, but I'm not defrauding my investors.
I'm not an expert in Celsius, perhaps it's structured a bit differently. But any system that relies on new investors paying out the old is structured akin to a Ponzi scheme, if there's no intrinsic value element to the speculation.
If AAPL pays a 10% dividend, huge numbers of people would buy it for the yield. The yield comes from their underlying business, not from investor money. This puts a floor on the price.
When your yield only comes from newer investors, that's not intrinsic value or sustainable
Explain how pump and dumping penny stocks doesn't apply? I agree that it's a bit different in nature than most Ponzi Schemes due to lack of central entity orchestrating it, but the net effect is the same in the end.
You get in early, you win, you get in late, you lose.
Even if we call it something else, it's clear the underlying mechanism and unsustainability of returns is the same.
Stocks that don't pay a dividend have promise of paying one in the future as their cash flows grow. That's the fundamental basis to all stock valuation. It's why people talk about P to FCF, PE, PS ratios. For growth stocks, hypothetically, how much in dividends could I get 30 years from now?
It's true that many investors don't consider what the fair value actually is, but that's how you end up in a bubble and the price disconnecting from the fundamentals never lasts forever.
Real estate more obvious and direct via rents.
But yeah, pump and dump kind of stocks where they far exceed their fundamental value are similar.
We can argue semantics and what defines a Ponzi scheme, all I'm saying is that crypto largely has no intrinsic value. Any value that's explained is always self referential in terms of other crypto.
Bitcoin has some small intrinsic value for illicit payments, or hedging inflation in countries without capital markets. You could argue the net intrinsic value is negative due to the environmental costs though. But outside of edge/fringe cases, all valuation relies on a greater fool effectively.
Even gold is still majority used for industrial purposes, despite also being seen as an investment vehicle.
That's just market manipulation. Going on Twitter and saying "BTC to the moon!" isn't a Ponzi. It requires an actor (like Charles Ponzi) to take new investors' money and pay it to old. Bitconnect was Ponzi scheme, not in some abstract sense.
> You get in early, you win, you get in late, you lose.
So vague it applies to everything that pays interest...
If I buy a stock or a bond, I get the dividend payment regardless of when I get in. It doesn't require you to be early, just to accept what the current value proposition is.
You'll make more money if you time it right, but you get some intrinsic value from it even if no future investors ever come along.
Or more obviously, buying rental property. Cap rates change over time, but you always get some real return.
And "pump and dump" implies a coordinated scheme. Usually they'll create groups/networks and call for everybody to buy in. But they tend to frontrun the group. We can call that something other than Ponzi, but at the end of the day, the later buyers are paying off the earlier buyers, and it's zero sum.. the underlying relationship is the same
In a Ponzi, you can't satisfy all your investors- you literally don't have the money you say you do. Eventually it will collapse and piss off most of your investors. But if you are really good at pumping and dumping you could in theory just keep doing that until you can't make money anymore, and then close up shop with a tidy profit for you and your investors.
They're both frauds, but they're different.
What is more likely that they figured out a way to "hack" the financial system to make such returns in a very safe fashion or that they are doing things behind the scenes which may be a little bit sketchy?
10% safe annual returns is a bit high if one thinks that the APY is reflection of how risky the investment is.
The promise of DeFi is that it's supposed to reduce risk for lenders by letting them see the assets of borrowers in real time. If the risk to lenders is lower but interest rates are higher then how can it not be a Ponzi scheme? There's literally no other possible explanation.
As someone new to DeFi, I found the article sparked new questions, even though as you said it wasn't deeply researched.
If Celcius is basically reinvesting into a bunch of other assets, it's possible, or even likely, that the high yield assets are too good to be true. That's where my concern would be. Is BadgerDAO rock solid? Compound? I would be curious to see expert analysis of these. Celcius is simply built on top.
I don't know of a single reputable bank, hedge fund or publicly traded company that does that.
A huge number of places do have high returns from time to time. But any reputable firm points out that past returns do not guarantee future results. No reputable firm guarantees returns that high in the future.
The key is the guarantee.
Anyone who GUARANTEES returns that high in the future is suspect, and therefore must be more transparent than usual in order to clear the bar. The article indicates that Celsius was less transparent than usual in describing exactly how they made their high returns.
https://celsius.network/static/risk-disclosure.pdf
Which is a bit odd- there's no chance you might lose money? How are they making money without risking that the return might drop below 0?
The author pretty much failed to do any research on DeFi investments (point 3 in the OP). Compound and Aave are just 2 of many places investors place their assets, and are definitely near the lower end of APYs. Badger, which Celsius has already said they used, offers much higher returns. So do other projects like e.g. Convex Finance.
Where do these high APYs come from? Well a lot of it is coming from incentives of these protocols and speculation in those native assets. But the author doesn't even know that, so I won't bother steelmanning his argument