Re:Number of journalists in jail reaches global high
by COGlory on Thursday December 09, 2021 @10:40AM
(#29498589)
Professional organizations are extremely effective gatekeeping mechanisms.
Re:Number of journalists in jail reaches global high
by chrisseaton on Thursday December 09, 2021 @10:39AM
(#29498576)
> people who ... comment on public affairs in any media
I mean... I do that, but I'm clearly not a journalist.
Re:Number of journalists in jail reaches global high
by CapitalistCartr on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:57PM
(#29500681)
I guess if our fact-focused essays/comments about the issues of the day sufficiently annoy someone powerful, enough to get thrown in prison, then we're a journalist. At least the powerful, annoyed person thinks so. Something to think about while we rot away in solitary.
Re:Number of journalists in jail reaches global high
by BurningFrog on Thursday December 09, 2021 @10:25AM
(#29498369)
Don't we all comment on public affairs online?
Re:Number of journalists in jail reaches global high
by boringg on Thursday December 09, 2021 @10:39AM
(#29498571)
Yeah this is the crux of the problem. As the definition of journalist becomes so broad that everyone falls into this category so to does the number of journalists going to prison.
The counter is that if there is too strict a definition of journalism - you put to many controls on the group. It almost feels like you should need some kind of standard to qualify as a journalist (again that has issues with it as well).
It's fraught either way but I don't think I am alone here when I say a lot of journalists around the world don't really qualify as journalists and are actually activists under guise (both on the right and on the left).
Re:Number of journalists in jail reaches global high
by chrisseaton on Thursday December 09, 2021 @11:21AM
(#29499257)
> The counter is that if there is too strict a definition of journalism - you put to many controls on the group.
How so? I don't think 'journalist' is any kind of privileged or protected group - so you don't lose anything by not being a journalist do you?
Re:Number of journalists in jail reaches global high
by svachalek on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:48PM
(#29501290)
To the point that governments shouldn't be putting anyone in jail just for revealing their activity, there's a truth to that. But so far as we can use metrics like "journalists in jail" as a proxy for despotism, there's a loss when despots are hand-picking the journalists.
As to privilege and protection, that depends a lot on regional laws.
"CPJ defines journalists as people who cover the news or comment on public affairs in any media, including print, photographs, radio, television, and online."
I'd say that both Murray and Assange legitimately fit into this definition.
Unfortunately in the UK you're only considered a "journalist" if you can join the cosy boys club that is the NUJ, which is a bit like saying you're not a real train driver unless you're a member of ASLEF which is clearly nonsense.