Re:Number of journalists in jail reaches global high
by chrisseaton on Thursday December 09, 2021 @11:21AM
(#29499257)
> The counter is that if there is too strict a definition of journalism - you put to many controls on the group.
How so? I don't think 'journalist' is any kind of privileged or protected group - so you don't lose anything by not being a journalist do you?
Re:Number of journalists in jail reaches global high
by svachalek on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:48PM
(#29501290)
To the point that governments shouldn't be putting anyone in jail just for revealing their activity, there's a truth to that. But so far as we can use metrics like "journalists in jail" as a proxy for despotism, there's a loss when despots are hand-picking the journalists.
As to privilege and protection, that depends a lot on regional laws.
The counter is that if there is too strict a definition of journalism - you put to many controls on the group. It almost feels like you should need some kind of standard to qualify as a journalist (again that has issues with it as well).
It's fraught either way but I don't think I am alone here when I say a lot of journalists around the world don't really qualify as journalists and are actually activists under guise (both on the right and on the left).