News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by kome on Thursday December 09, 2021 @04:35AM (#29495455)
It's about following the rules, instead of making the rules.

Uber tried to make the rules in Europe: they failed.

Europe has a stronger governance then in the US. And yes, it's a pro-market governance.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by jltsiren on Thursday December 09, 2021 @05:14AM (#29495725)
It's more appropriate to say that the EU is pro-competition. They don't care as much about free markets than about competition as means to an end. If there is not enough competition in the market, they often deliberately change the rules to create more.
Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by panick21_ on Thursday December 09, 2021 @08:26AM (#29497051)
Its a strange world to me where being pro-competition is a god thing when it means to deliberately hurt outsider and prop up internal alternatives that are not competitive.

And I think at least in the cases I observed it hasn't fixed the 'problem' either.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by jltsiren on Thursday December 09, 2021 @11:51AM (#29499698)
I was only explaining how things are, not whether they are good or bad.

The EU is a single market consisting of many sovereign states. Sovereign states are naturally protectionist. Each member state wants to support domestic businesses over their rivals from other member states, but a single market can't work like that. To overcome these natural tendencies, the EU set up a regulatory environment that undermines the advantages established businesses have in their home markets, in order to allow businesses from other member states successfully compete against them.

That same attitude bleeds to dealings with businesses outside the single market. EU regulators see large profits and large market shares as signs of insufficient competition, and they see insufficient competition as something inherently negative.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by sneak on Thursday December 09, 2021 @08:49AM (#29497262)
It's not really pro-competition. It's pro-competitors-who-maximize-employment-and-tax-revenue.

"We will back your participation in this "competition" only as long as your participation furthers our preconceived objectives about how the world and society and economy should work."

It stems from the idea that being an FTE at one place for a long time (and not really having any class mobility) is a good and decent thing to encourage for most of your society. Stability above upside.

It's the root cause of why the USA has a startup culture and Europe does not.

It's fine if that is your belief, but to pretend that it's "competition" when they have their thumb on the scale tilting it toward a specific social ideology is a bit disingenuous.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by malermeister on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:13PM (#29501600)
The term you're looking for is social market economy or rhine capitalism [1]

The core idea is that we see the market as a means to an end, not some end in itself. When the market is incompatible with societal good, the market needs to change, not society.

A market by itself only optimizes for maximum profits for shareholders, at the expense of everything else. Often, you want your economy to optimize for different things, so you direct the market to support your goals.

It's the root cause why inequality is so much worse in the US, why you have a much bigger housing crisis, why health care in the US is such a mess, why there's homeless people everywhere etc etc.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_market_economy

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by sneak on Thursday December 09, 2021 @05:26PM (#29503843)
> It's the root cause why inequality is so much worse in the US, why you have a much bigger housing crisis, why health care in the US is such a mess, why there's homeless people everywhere etc etc.

I don't think a single part of this claim a) logically follows from the previous paragraphs, or b) is actually true.

For just one example: the housing crisis is a lack of supply, which is the result of the exact same kind of status-quo-maintaining, market-forces-secondary-to-regulatory-aims (NIMBYism by property owners and their representatives) thing you describe as being the European norm.

To say that these philosophical differences are the root cause of failures in very complex systems is of course the popular and prevailing European narrative about the USA. (There is another, equally popular and equally false (but self-congratulatory) one in Europe about gun violence in the USA.) I just don't see much evidence to substantiate it.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by malermeister on Thursday December 09, 2021 @06:11PM (#29504378)
Counterexample to your housing crisis claim: Vienna, Austria.

44% of the housing stock is in public ownership, two thirds of the population live in public housing. Rent is affordable and housing stock is of high quality.

Market forces would not have solved this, as there is very little profit to be made with low-cost housing - so the lack of housing was fixed by state intervention and Vienna has the highest quality of life in the world [1] as a result.

[1] https://www.independent.co.uk/travel/news-and-advice/vienna-...

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by sneak on Thursday December 09, 2021 @07:20PM (#29504963)
> as there is very little profit to be made with low-cost housing

I’m fairly certain that this is not correct.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by malermeister on Thursday December 09, 2021 @08:14PM (#29505317)
How do you explain the lack of low-cost housing in most US cities then?
Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by sneak on Thursday December 16, 2021 @04:43PM (#29584368)
Prohibitions on adding supply, mostly driven and incentivized and rewarded by existing landowners who directly profit from constrained supply and high prices.
Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by panick21_ on Thursday December 09, 2021 @10:38PM (#29506137)
> The core idea is that we see the market as a means to an end, not some end in itself.

The market was never an end to itself. Literally go back and read anywhere from Smith, Hume to Hayek. That is just a straw-men argument.

> When the market is incompatible with societal good, the market needs to change, not society.

And who and how is it determined, what the social good is? Are bureaucrats loosely connected to politicians loosely connected to voters a better an more reliable form of social preference allocation then the price mechanism under the same law? Not by any existing evidence in social science.

But the core of your argument is basically the government whenever it feels like it can just intervene in the market directly and put its finger on the scale. Not by fundamentally changing the rules, just be direct intervention whenever they don't like something. Often that is a foreign competitor and some vague hard to prove claims about market power. And often it is the citizens of that country that end up having higher prices or higher taxes. French book market being a good example.

Many times it has been shown historically that the monopolies far, far, far more often are government created then market created. And laws to establish 'fair competition' are usually strongly sponsored by the very competitors who get crushed in the market, often for good fundamental reasons.

The first Anti-Trust law in the US was by local butchers to prevent centralized butchers with refrigerated rail-cars. Would it really be 'fair competition' to give money to local butchers to prevent them from this 'unfair competition'. No, its how you get a stagnate economy depended on subsidies.

Very often its just governments doing what they want for the political clients that they have. French publishers, German news organization.

A perfect example is Germany where German Newspaper have fought tooth and nails for years against 'Google News' and basically want to monetize every link to their sites. This is all done in the name of 'fair competition' while introducing laws that are really the opposite and hurt user freedom in the process.

> It's the root cause why inequality is so much worse in the US, why you have a much bigger housing crisis, why health care in the US is such a mess, why there's homeless people everywhere etc etc.

If you think housing and health care are examples of 'free market fundamentalism' then you are very badly informed.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by johnisgood on Thursday December 09, 2021 @06:36PM (#29504640)
Proponents of the free market love competition. If by changing the rules you mean government interference, that they of course oppose. Still, free market people are pro-competition as well as opposed to pro-monopoly and such.
[dead]
Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by estaseuropano on Thursday December 09, 2021 @05:44AM (#29495948)
This is obviously nonsense. EU has companies in all businesses and in many many fields the market leaders.

Two big weaknesses though: They are generally behind in the tech world (but even there it depends, see e.g. ASML) where scale really matters and scale is much easier and quicker to achieve with a single language and legal system like US and China.

Where Europe is also weaker is finance, which in the US is a barely regulated free for all compared to the EU context. This in turn reflects in market capitalization and stock prices where a US company with equal (or lower) output than an EU company will generally have a much higher valuation.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by chrisseaton on Thursday December 09, 2021 @06:19AM (#29496179)
> EU has companies in all businesses and in many many fields the market leaders.

I think this is an increasingly optimistic view.

The EU cannot even begin to compete with big US, Canadian, Chinese tech companies. It just doesn't have the drive or initiative to do so. And now that almost everything is a big tech company... the outlook looks bit worrying.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by sofixa on Thursday December 09, 2021 @07:07AM (#29496443)
There are other markets other than tech, you know? OP explicitly excluded tech ( with some exceptions like ASML).

Cars, aviation, logistics, trains, elevators, chemistry, pharmaceutical, energy, engines, turbines, defence, to name just a few sectors where there are huge EU-based companies which are market leaders worldwide.

And there are lots of tech companies, most are just focusing on their local and sometimes neighbouring markets - Back Market, Doctolib, N26, Revolut (to name a few i know and have used in France), and are thus smaller than their American counterparts. It has nothing to do with drive or initiative.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by chrisseaton on Thursday December 09, 2021 @07:28AM (#29496597)
My point was that other markets are being eaten by tech.

Cars are a great example - Tesla for example operates as a tech company. Logistics another great example - being eaten by Amazon. Bio is probably next with all the tech funded work being done in Boston now. Etc etc.

And focusing on local markets… we’ll yeah that is a lack or drive and initiative. While you’re focusing on your local market US tech is coming for you.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by sofixa on Thursday December 09, 2021 @08:18AM (#29496984)
Tesla are operating as a tech company, and it shows - they have pretty bad quality control issues. They still remain a small manufacturer, and don't have much technological advantage, giants such as VW, Stellantis(PSA+FCA) and Renault having catched up.

Some sectors are moving to tech-first approaches, like fintech, and there are plenty of european ones. Same goes for Bio ( BioNTech?).

Trying to expand before you have a stable local market is stupidly risky. Furthermore, some concepts aren't easy to export, or require significant legal and translation work. EU-based startups have plenty of drive and initiative, try to conquer their local and neighbouring markets ( e.g. Ornikar is a driving license online tutoring startup, who started in France, are expanding in Spain and will probably add more; but each new market is basically redoing almost everything from scratch). Those markets are smaller than the US and China, who are very protective, so the resulting companies are smaller. So what? Not everything is about infinite growth and trillion dollar companies.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by chrisseaton on Thursday December 09, 2021 @08:20AM (#29497004)
> having catched up

That’s the point - why are we always playing catch-up? Why don’t we come up with anything ourselves? Legacy companies just about managing to keep pace doesn’t make me comfortable.

> basically redoing almost everything from scratch

Well yeah that’s part of the problem. Europe needs to get over being so beaurocratic and stubborn.

> stupidly risky

I just think US people would think the risk was worth it, while we wouldn’t… and well just look at the results.

Not everything is about trillion dollar companies but I worry the European tech sector will get entirely eaten by the US if it stays happy to be small and inoffensive. Ideally we’d be able to compete with the US globally. If we aren’t that worries me for our ability for self-determination.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by panick21_ on Thursday December 09, 2021 @08:32AM (#29497104)
Are you seriously suggesting Stellantis is catching up? You must be joking.

And Tesla sells by far the most BEV, literally 100% more. VW is catching up relatively but globally they are still far behind. And other car makers like Stellantis are basically nowhere. The CEO of Stellantis literally just commented on that.

And Tesla is really not so small anymore and they are growing very fast.

> but each new market is basically redoing almost everything from scratch

This is very true being in that situation. Getting a German bank to buy even a Swiss product is very difficult.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by nix23 on Thursday December 09, 2021 @09:48AM (#29497888)
Funny that everyone says ASML....because it's one of the only company's in the whole tech-industry where europe is leading.
Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by mijamo on Thursday December 09, 2021 @05:40AM (#29495914)
The US is much more protectionist than the EU, there are lots of sectors where entering the market is nearly impossible in the US. And saying that Europe has no competing counterpart is ridiculous, just look at Amazon total market share in the different European countries and compare to the US.
Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by nix23 on Thursday December 09, 2021 @07:37AM (#29496672)
>just look at Amazon total market share in the different European countries and compare to the US.

Since when is Amazon a European company?

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by cdirkx on Thursday December 09, 2021 @09:53AM (#29497967)
The parent probably meant that Amazons market share is much higher in the US than in the EU [1], meaning that in the EU there is thus more competition.

[1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/1183515/amazon-market-sh...

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by nix23 on Thursday December 09, 2021 @05:02PM (#29503572)
It's because cloud-act and that many company's are not allowed to have their customers data in a US cloud. However Europe has nothing like AWS or Alibaba, Europe and especially Germany is a shitshow par exelance in that regard.
Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by MagnumOpus on Thursday December 09, 2021 @06:05AM (#29496082)
Bull. If they wanted to kill competition from the outside, they could just block FANG from doing business there like Russia and China are doing with massive success.

If anything, the EU's fairness is a massive giveway to US tech firms who could hoover up any fledgling EU competitors.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by nix23 on Thursday December 09, 2021 @07:38AM (#29496687)
>Bull

No Europe would have no search-engine to replace.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by pmontra on Thursday December 09, 2021 @08:56AM (#29497325)
If the EU blocks Google today there will be a decent search engine in a few days (I think I used a German one until it shut down a few months ago,) a good one in a few months and a Google level one maybe never.

The real problems are: almost everyone use gmail and most people have an Android phone. There will be a 90s like fragmentation for email, maybe by ISP. Not bad at all IMHO. Bigger problem with Android: maps, driving directions, apps delivery and updates. Somebody will provide a plugin replacement for the Play Store, there are alternative map services but it's going to be an interesting season or two.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by nix23 on Thursday December 09, 2021 @09:43AM (#29497826)
>If the EU blocks Google today there will be a decent search engine in a few days

Ah yes we just buy yandex or baidu.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by pmontra on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:23PM (#29514297)
I was using Cliqz. You can read their announcement from when they closed the service https://cliqz.com/announcement.html

"It became clear to us in the last weeks, that all political initiatives to create an independent European digital infrastructure have been stalled or postponed for years."

If there where no competitors from outside the EU them or others would create a reasonable search engine.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by nix23 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @04:44AM (#29519738)
>It became clear to us in the last weeks, that all political initiatives to create an independent European digital infrastructure have been stalled or postponed for years.

But that's exactly my critique about europe.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by intellirogue on Thursday December 09, 2021 @08:24AM (#29497037)
Qwant.
Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by nix23 on Thursday December 09, 2021 @05:04PM (#29503583)
C'mon be real...
Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by nickpp on Thursday December 09, 2021 @05:27AM (#29495807)
You can't create competition through regulation. Free markets allow competition and entrepreneurship creates it. You need both.

Regulations reduce competition by raising the bar to entry and the unforeseen consequences of compliance.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by Isinlor on Thursday December 09, 2021 @05:41AM (#29495920)
Actually the opposite is true. Only trough regulation you can create nonviolent free market competition. Otherwise, you end up with military competition as the easiest way to win is to dominate and subjugate opponents trough raw force. Slavery and colonization are this types of free market distortions when unrestricted by regulation.

So, regulations are necessary part of free markets. The question is what regulations are good and what regulations are bad.

There are empirical and game theoretical examples where regulations create better outcomes than nonviolent free market competition. There are games where the tragedy of the commons occur i.e. Nash equilibrium creates bad outcome [0]. This is also true in the real world e.g. collapse of the Atlantic northwest cod fishery.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wNj9hOIt9g

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collapse_of_the_Atlantic_north...

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by nickpp on Thursday December 09, 2021 @08:18AM (#29496983)
Having a rule of law is not a regulation, is the most basic fundamental prerequisite to having a functioning modern, democratic society. Free markets are built on top of that and regulations come on top of free markets.

And free markets imply free people - slavery is the opposite of that.

Taxing externalities is also necessary, and it's tax, not a regulation. But that is something we're still working on, with little success it seems. See the carbon/pollution international issues with China, Russia, Australia.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by Isinlor on Thursday December 09, 2021 @10:04AM (#29498101)
You are bending words like regulation and tax to fit your preconceptions in way that disagrees with how other people understand them.

Also, a simple tax can not solve the tragedy of the commons for fisheries as long as fishing will remain profitable. Nash equilibrium involving full exploitation remains as long as there is a profit. Fish are not an externality that can be reduced to avoid taxation, but the objective. While cap on fishing will work.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by jltsiren on Thursday December 09, 2021 @05:46AM (#29495968)
Of course you can. Competition and free markets are orthogonal concepts. Competition is a process that exists within any regulatory framework, while free markets refer to the extent and stability of the regulations.

Infrastructure is the usual example. If your company owns something like a cellular network or a local power grid, the EU requires that you let other businesses use it for a fair price to sell their services to customers. This regulation creates more competition and lowers the prices for customers, while simultaneously making businesses more efficient and less profitable.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday December 09, 2021 @06:50AM (#29496351)
"Competition and free markets are orthogonal concepts."

Surely a marjet without competition, i.e. monopolised, is no longer free? Or what does 'free' mean?

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by kome on Thursday December 09, 2021 @07:36AM (#29496655)
> Or what does 'free' mean?

it depends to whom you ask.

in the US, for a long time, anti-trust was kinda cozy with monopolies - they were accepted as the natural outcome of a free market: the most efficient solution.

In the EU there is more emphasis on market competition, and big monopolists are seen as problematic.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday December 09, 2021 @06:13PM (#29504398)
"natural outcome of a free market: the most efficient solution."

The same argument that justifies monopoly also justifies soviet-style central planning. It just changed the 'monopolist' in charge.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by nickpp on Thursday December 09, 2021 @08:28AM (#29497063)
EU had to add regulation to allow startups using other's infrastructure because of the existing regulation that makes laying said infrastructure so difficult.

Do not confuse regulations made to fix even worse regulation with an actual healthy, competitive free market.

In Eastern Europe, after the fall of communism, people would lay Ethernet wire between apartment buildings to create ad-hoc communication networks. There were dozens of them. Today that is illegal and we only have a single Internet provider per city block.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday December 09, 2021 @06:48AM (#29496342)
"Regulations reduce competition by raising the bar to entry"

This is literally wrong. OpenBanking only applies to the biggest banks and not little guys, and it allows little guys to access data stored in huge banks.

How does thay reduce competition? It reduces bar to entry

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by nickpp on Thursday December 09, 2021 @08:22AM (#29497018)
Banking is one of the most heavily regulated and lacking competitions domains I know. This is why we have innovation in fin-tech startups but banking-startups only in crypto, where regulation is yet fairly light.
Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday December 09, 2021 @06:17PM (#29504437)
"this is why we have innovation in fin-tech startups but banking-startups only in crypto"

I can think of 10 startup banks like monzo and starling and have accounts in 4 of them, where is this lack of competition?

Is it also regulator's fault there is no competition in running water and sewer providers? In your world there is no such thing as capital requirements, barriers to entry, natural monopoly, all issues are summed as 'regulation = bad"

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by kome on Thursday December 09, 2021 @05:43AM (#29495934)
> You can't create competition through regulation.

real world experience suggests the contrary is true.

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by nickpp on Thursday December 09, 2021 @08:19AM (#29496991)
Some examples would help, I am not aware of any.
Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by skywal_l on Thursday December 09, 2021 @09:08AM (#29497475)
Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by nickpp on Thursday December 09, 2021 @10:08AM (#29498144)
Bells's monopoly was instituted by the government. Using regulation to fix your own previous bad regulation does not suddenly make you a free market savior.
Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by skywal_l on Thursday December 09, 2021 @11:05AM (#29499008)
> Bells's monopoly was instituted by the government

What actions the US government took to "institute" Bell's monopoly?

Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by nickpp on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:26PM (#29501032)
Oh, the usual: patents and regulations. The end result it was that you weren't allowed to create a competing network or even use a non-approved telephone on Bell's network.
Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by est31 on Thursday December 09, 2021 @05:09AM (#29495684)
It's not about strong vs weak governance. It's just that the US government represents the 401ks invested in the FAANGs, as well as the FAANG employees, and the european governments represent the people that the FAANGs offer services for.
Re:Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market domin... by thomasz on Thursday December 09, 2021 @05:11AM (#29495708)
Exactly. For a counterpoint, compare what VW had to pay in the US to what they had to pay in Germany.