News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by silent_cal on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @09:12AM (#29484869)
No they should not make recommendations to the public, because they aren't a public agency - they have a conflict of interest. It's like a hedge fund manager giving public advice on stock picks.
Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by yvdriess on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @09:21AM (#29484984)
Not the same.

They are not giving advice or recommendations, they are reporting the results of a study.

That's the beauty of a good scientific study: you do not have to trust the author. In fact don't, the more people try to find errors the better.

Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by gentleman11 on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @10:22AM (#29485802)
Part of being a good scientific study is having unbiased experimental scientists run the study with no conflicts of interest. The pressure on that team will be incredible
Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by tremon on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @10:36AM (#29486004)
No, part of being a good scientific study is being upfront about any (even potential) conflicts of interest. Most studies aren't interest-free, do you think e.g. CERN doesn't have a vested interest when it publishes studies about the LHC experiments?
Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by gentleman11 on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @04:46PM (#29490960)
There have been a lot of scandals in the news lately about low quality research due to these conflicts of interest in the past

https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/09/13/493739074...

https://blogs.bmj.com/bmj/2021/07/05/time-to-assume-that-hea...

Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by macinjosh on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @09:56AM (#29485437)
General Mills had studies showing sugary cereals are a part of a healthy diet.
Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by yvdriess on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @02:30PM (#29489263)
Did they publish the study under their own name, being up front about their conflict of interest, or did they pay someone else for the study (and desired outcome)?
[dead]
Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by silent_cal on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @09:40AM (#29485213)
Alex Berenson, unlike Pfizer, has nothing to gain from taking the journalistic stance he holds. In fact he was banned from Twitter for it.

In your mind, an independent/skeptical/critical journalist is a propagandist, and Pfizer is a neutral public health authority? Time to wake up.

Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by acdha on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @10:02AM (#29485540)
Alex Berenson relies on attention to sell his books (remember when he was telling parents that cannabis causes psychosis and violence? Great way to get on TV telling people about your book.) and his COVID denial sells ads on his substack and almost turned into a Fox show.

Pfizer also has a potential conflict of interest, which is why people are talking about what they've done going through the scientific process. That's very different from where Berenson makes up something outrageous, hits send, and then complains about being “canceled” if he gets criticized by real journalists or scientists because Pfizer employees people who are experts in the field, runs studies following standard methodology, publishes their data and analysis and it's critically examined by independent experts. That doesn't mean it's perfect but it's a completely different level of rigor than a self-published screed.

Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by snovv_crash on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @09:59AM (#29485491)
Well, there are also a bunch of people who are by default untrusting of authority who will latch onto and give YouTube ad revenue to anybody who puts out material that matches their confirmation bias.

If Alex Berenson was saying we should all get the vaccine he would never have gathered the following he did. So don't pretend populist journalists don't have a monetary incentive to propound the material they show, either.

Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by bildung on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @09:59AM (#29485485)
Berenson apparently was already caught earning money with false information about cannabis effects, and has zero medical background.
Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by altacc on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @09:18AM (#29484935)
So you're saying no company ever should undertake any promotion of the benefits of their products? The advertising industry wants a word with you!
Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by silent_cal on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @09:19AM (#29484959)
That's exactly the point I'm trying to make - it's just advertising, and you're all acting like it's an announcement from a public health authority.
Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by unclebucknasty on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @09:25AM (#29485043)
>you're all acting like it's an announcement from a public health authority.

I think people are "acting like" it's scientific data about a vaccine of interest to the public.

Are you suggesting the data is unreliable or falsified? If so, and you have a basis for that, please cite.

Otherwise, it's difficult to understand why you're implying people shouldn't be interested in this information.

Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by bellyfullofbac on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @09:32AM (#29485128)
TBH, this feels like a libertarian mindset of "Everyone will try to lie and cheat you!".

Why should they lie? If their data had something different to their press release, lying and then getting caught (e.g. by a whistleblower) would damage their reputation. If their data shows it's bad, as responsible scientists why shouldn't they come out with the truth to protect the general public, and say "We'll continue work on the Omicron-specific vaccine.".

Unless you think their main motive is to boost their stock price in the short term. That kind of thinking should be reserved for people dealing with the blockhain-ponzi schemes.

Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by chronofar on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @11:17AM (#29486569)
"Lie" is the wrong term. "Mislead" or "misrepresent" would be the more appropriate way to phrase it. On a topic as politicized as this with as little scientific literacy as the general public has you don't think they'd have anything to gain by fudging things a bit in their favor (ignoring a confounding variable here, drawing a misleading conclusion there) to distribute more shots? And you think it would just be clear cut that the general public would be able to discern such mistakes over the long term and hold them accountable? And you don't think companies often take measures just to boost their short term earnings/stock price even if it has obvious long-term deleterious effects? I'd say these viewpoints would be naive in the extreme.

Not to say they did commit any such errors here. Perhaps all such studies conducted by Pfizer are truly earnest and valid/replicable, I certainly hope they are. But it's perfectly reasonable to be skeptical of an organization publishing new science when that organization stands to profit greatly from the results. You may call that libertarian (though I'm frankly not sure how), I'd call it just due diligence.

Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by ccn0p on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @09:59AM (#29485492)
Given the amount spent on lobbying [1], the Pharmaceutical industries track record of deceptive tactics [2], and the profits they have made and stand to make [3], it's not unreasonable to question the underlying motives, intentions, and biases of stuff like this.

[1] https://www.opensecrets.org/federal-lobbying/industries/summ...

[2] https://projects.propublica.org/graphics/bigpharma

[3] https://www.forbes.com/sites/giacomotognini/2021/04/06/meet-...

Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by Gwarzo on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @11:01AM (#29486361)
Phizer is immune to bad reputation and they know it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_pharmaceutical...

Phizer holds single largest criminal fine in human history at 1.3$ Billion USD (to my knowledge). They have many reasons to lie; while I'm not suggesting they are (I have no idea how I would determine truth from falsehood in the realm of scientific information) it's quite ignorant to make the statement "Why would they lie". They would lie because it's something innate to humans and Phizer is no exception. They stand to make ludicrous amounts of money if boosters become mandated - now boosters may ultimately be the best option for the protection of human life! But this doesn't mean we shouldn't be incredibly skeptical of every word that comes from this organization.

While I am fully vaccinated (ironically with 2x Phizer), I am and will remain hesitant at accepting information provided by pharmaceutical companies at face value until the day I'm dead.

Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by salawat on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @09:42AM (#29485240)
The advertising industry wants a word with everyone, because that's what advertisers exist to do. Getting people to pay attention to what people are willing to pay them to signal boost.

Whether or not that's better off for the person on the receiving end is often entirely orthogonal to the entire arrangement.

See: The Tobacco Industry The Dairy Industry pre-FDA The Sugar Industry The Media Industry Some corners of the Supplement industry

Also see: Lobbying and Psychological anchoring

You, in fact, picked the absolute group of people to prove the virtue of taking someone at their word. Go look for the old Thalidomide adverts, then go read the rest of the history of it.

Point being: always consider the source, and incentives. There is always an angle.

Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by podgaj on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @10:24AM (#29485839)
The vaccine is just a product? Like a pair of Nike's? Are you kidding me? I wonder how many phishing emails you fall for every month...

We have (some) laws regulating what advertisers can say. Putting out a press releases like this is, in effect, an advertisement. It sways public opinion and will effect their profits.

And did you know the US is the only country where it is legal for pharmaceutical companies to advertise their medications to the public?

And did you know the pharmaceutical companies are the main source of revenue for the FDA, the agency that approves their drugs?

Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by giarc on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @09:16AM (#29484916)
>It's like a hedge fund manager giving public advice on stock picks.

Why not? Stock picking is their job. Given that logic, a teacher shouldn't tell people how to teach their kid to read, and a plumber shouldn't tell people how to change a faucet.

Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by salawat on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @09:30AM (#29485092)
Your hedge fund manager can also knowingly give bad info to improve the actual portfolio they are or agenda they are running.

Yes, that's technically fraud/market manipulation. That@s why most hedge fund managers won@t give financial advice until after they've been paid, and are, at best, either selling the money management angle with all the right regulatory and compliance check marks ticked, or they're selling you fast access to market actors + quantitative fiscal analysis results.

Either way, I wouldn't advise necessarily blindly taking one's advice. Just because you "do it as your job" doesn't mean you're necessarily terribly good at it. Never mind the whole "completely punting on your own responsibility as a capital allocator" thing.

Remember, everybody punting to hedge funds and such is the reason the economy overtime has trended toward centralization. Once everybody knows the guy managing everyone else's money, it's only a matter of time til the information engineering starts.

Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by Gwarzo on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @11:12AM (#29486503)
This is a hilariously uninformed take - it's clear you don't understand how this works so I will just be direct and not make fun of you.

The hedge fund manager has access to billions in managed capital. If he can advertise positions to the public, and the public takes his advice; he can manipulate his billions of dollars vs the known positions he gives out to hedge his own positions.

This is a 5 years olds description of how this works.

Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by giarc on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @01:09PM (#29488211)
I was referring more to "giving public" advice like advice to his friends. But I'll accept I'm wrong on this though.
Re:Pfizer and Biontech provide update on Omicron variant by silent_cal on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @09:18AM (#29484943)
Are you serious?