News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Retaining Walls Collapse by cf100clunk on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @12:28PM (#29475471)
The Proctor Compaction Test and its related procedures are absolutely vital to understanding retaining wall capabilities. The article oddly seems to miss such an essential cornerstone of geotechnical engineering. Does an amateur need to know about the Proctor when doing a low retaining wall at home? No, of course not. Does a website called "Practical Engineering" get to miss out on such a fundamental design prerequisite? Not IMHO. Great article and video, nonetheless.
Re:Why Retaining Walls Collapse by idealmedtech on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:11PM (#29476061)
I think the point of this blog and YouTube channel is to make these concepts approachable to the lay person, and introducing lots of technical jargon (relevant though it may be to actual geotechnical engineers) is not the best way to accomplish that.
Re:Why Retaining Walls Collapse by cf100clunk on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @02:41PM (#29477252)
Time to rename it from "Practical Engineering" to "Popular Engineering"? To me, the Practical handle is significant, so taking a few seconds to explain why soil compaction tests are vital makes practical sense.
Re:Why Retaining Walls Collapse by dsshakey on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @03:43PM (#29477973)
The practical in his videos probably refer to the fact that he always explains things in physical models. It's very rare to just be theory. Thus, practical engineering demonstrations.
Re:Why Retaining Walls Collapse by SECProto on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:41PM (#29476480)
I think they are vital to calculating retaining wall capabilities. But not vital to understanding them. Source: have spent many a day doing proctors.
Re:Why Retaining Walls Collapse by cf100clunk on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @02:50PM (#29477351)
> have spent many a day doing proctors.

I salute you. My late father-in-law was a slide rule wrangler of a pipeline engineer who often did the same. By the time I got started in geotech computing support (Unix, Apollo Domain, VMS) we had the numbers stuff readily available on a CRT screen for guys like him.

Re:Why Retaining Walls Collapse by mitchdoogle on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @02:55PM (#29477392)
Hopefully nobody is watching the video as part of their training for building an actual retaining wall. It's just information for the curious.
Re:Why Retaining Walls Collapse by gerdesj on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @07:27PM (#29479996)
"The Proctor Compaction Test establishes the maximum unit weight that a particular type of soil can be compacted to using a controlled compactive force at an optimum water content."

That looks like geotechnics to me (UK). It's also not too useful here.

Compacting soil is for certain parts of paths and roads construction, not retaining walls.

Re:Why Retaining Walls Collapse by throwaway0a5e on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:17PM (#29476133)
For thousands of years retaining walls were successfully constructed without more than a cursory understanding of soil compaction and they didn't have rebar or geotextile to help them.

Nobody needs to understand soil compaction if they're willing to move and expend way more material than the bare minimum in order to solve the the problem. This is true in a lot of subject areas. You don't need to understand a lot of things if you're willing to copy what is tried and true and can tolerate some inefficiency.

For almost all personal and commercial projects the material is going to be cheaper than paying a real engineer to poke the soil with a calibrated poker and plugging the numbers into a spreadsheet that has some formulas.

Re:Why Retaining Walls Collapse by pixl97 on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @04:08PM (#29478246)
And for thousands of years they've either been massively over engineered, hence the expense made them out of reach for most people and applications.

Inefficiency doesnt work in packed urban environments that require to fit in a budget.