Way back in the days around y2k many network stacks had poor or no randomization of some parameters that produced some neat looking plots: https://lcamtuf.coredump.cx/newtcp/
After reading the post, that's what I'm going to play with next time I run into this. I suspect duplicating will be fine in almost all environments, and by picking one way way down in the preference list to duplicate, I suspect you can increase the chances that there's nothing in the chain that will even have an opportunity to error based on the duplicated cipher preference. I tried this against the website quoted in the article and it worked without problem.
I doubt that's happening today, but I suspect it will very quickly if duplicate ciphers become commonplace.
Actually reordering ciphers meanwhile definitively changes the hash, so there's nothing they can do in the general case at least, and there's a reasonably large number of acceptable non-duplicate orderings available to choose from.
Duplicating ciphers is a good technique that's definitely worth investigating too, but it has its limitations, and it's not a silver bullet.
See [1], e.g. In security, simplicity is often but not always by itself a win.
Great article, btb, really appreciated the real world examples.
If however you can predict the number, you can create a connection without being able to receive packets from the server.
So if for instance an administrator has setup their machine to accept connections to an insecure service only from a specific IP address, you can now set up such a connection without actually controlling the IP address.
A particularly useful anti-bot feature is to fingerprint TLS connections by things like cipher order and available signatures (if you're willing to switch back to TLS 1.2). This way, you can easily detect the difference between browsers and bots, even if all the request headers match . If you're fine with blocking people behind middleboxes or proxies then it can be a simple yet useful fingerprinting technique.
the only online demos of this i know of are: http://witch.valdikss.org.ru/ and https://bot.incolumitas.com
i believe the WITCH site is based on p0f (https://lcamtuf.coredump.cx/p0f3/)
i know some people have custom patches to the linux kernel to make it look like a different operating system in order to work around bot detection.