News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by dumbfoundded on Monday December 06, 2021 @02:15AM (#29457072)
Additionally the taxes create operational overhead to stay compliant. Every product follows a chain of custody similar to pharmaceuticals. Even the scales used must be of the same spec used for gold weighing and cost roughly $1,500 each. It's not just the dispensaries but the wholesalers, processors, and cultivators need to buy these scales and register them once a year with the state for $100. Furthermore the batches sizes are too small for the cultivators and processors. In Oregon, it was 15lbs each. An outdoor harvest may bring 1,500lbs an acre. Each test costs roughly $50 plus the labor for a human measuring it. Even if it was all going to biomass processing (think isolates and distillates used for edibles and vapes), the same process applies.

Part of the reason to justify all of this regulation was to ensure that the blackmarket would update accordingly. Instead, rich investors took control of the cannabis market and the underground market thrived without enforcement pressures. Poor people who actually suffered the consequences of prohibition received none of the benefits of legalization. This issue is certainly economic and racial.

Now the legal cannabis market wants to expand but can't. Now it has to compete with a market thriving due to enforcement evaporating. One way is to reduce taxes. This would make it more profitable for the already rich existing investors in cannabis to make more money. Taxes are extreme and certainly need to be reduced but the real issue is supply chain and access to market.

It's really difficult to sell weed legally if you want to. More importantly, it's expensive. We should make it cheap to sell weed. You should be able to sell weed like alcohol. Alcohol licenses are much cheaper and with much larger quotas. Additionally alcohol is more standardized than cannabis while facing less supply chain inspections & requirements. There should be strong exceptions to small producers. Also, interstate sales should be allowed. Illicit markets serving out of state customers won't go legit if they can't ship across state lines. Especially to adjacent states with legalized cannabis. Isn't it crazy you can't ship weed from Oregon to Washington?

Lowering the barrier to market would have the additional benefit of enabling smaller market participants like the people who did it before it was legal. I actually have no problem with very high taxes on the larger companies. Maybe it'll fund building schools and hospitals in the places ravaged by the drug war. It's a great disgrace that our laws have prevented any reasonable path for going legit while demonizing them in the process.

Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by aww_dang on Monday December 06, 2021 @02:41AM (#29457210)
If people can sell pies, vegetables, dairy and sometimes cider at informal farmers markets, cannabis should be the same.

Moldy cannabis is self-apparent in most cases.

Toxic distilled alcohol isn't. Some claim you can use a flame test to detect poisonous liquor.

Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by bryans on Monday December 06, 2021 @03:38AM (#29457563)
Some states did initially allow co-op markets where farmers got to sell directly to consumers, and only needed to test large batches to meet requirements. The prices were very low because there were no extra middlemen to get taxed, and because each farmer was its own vendor, you could buy very large quantities in one location -- and I think the concept eventually got shut down for that reason.
Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by OneTimePetes on Monday December 06, 2021 @05:10AM (#29457982)
The middle-man feared to be cut out and replaced by new humbler middle-man and lobbied for safety regulations to kill the emerging competition?
Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by throwaway0a5e on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:30AM (#29460119)
And the regulators obliged because they got to take a cut and control how it gets spent and they get to pick winners by exerting influence over the myriad of licensing and compliance stuff that legitimate business in this day and age. Win-win, so long as you don't care about the outcome for the peasants.
Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by pibechorro on Monday December 06, 2021 @07:05AM (#29458703)
Ding ding ding.
Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by boibombeiro on Monday December 06, 2021 @05:35AM (#29458107)
> Toxic distilled alcohol isn't.

Do you realize this ideia of poison alcohol was propaganda done by the government during prohibition, right?

We know how to distill from millenniums, and selling poisonous alcohol isn't a very sustainable business model...

I remember reading an article about the success of this campaign (was one of the first of this kinda). I'm mobile, but I'm sure someone can find a post a link.

Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by donatj on Monday December 06, 2021 @07:10AM (#29458745)
> Do you realize this ideia of poison alcohol was propaganda done by the government

Methanol poisoning is a VERY real thing. Methanol is easily accidentally produced when using a poorly calibrated still and not throwing out enough of the early product, particularly while processing alcohol made from corn where pectin helps create methanol. It’s very real and very dangerous.

The problem is ethanol (the good alcohol) laced with a small amount of methanol won’t immediately cause obvious health issues, they tend to creep up over time especially given continued consumption.

The government did however also purposely release horribly adulterated alcohol into the black market during prohibition and literally kill people, which is probably where your belief of it all being propaganda comes from.

- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Methanol_toxicity

- https://sciencing.com/test-alcohol-methanol-8714279.html

- https://slate.com/technology/2010/02/the-little-told-story-o...

Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by throwaway0a5e on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:32AM (#29460150)
>Methanol is easily accidentally produced when using a poorly calibrated still and not throwing out enough of the early product,

Easily? Yes.

Easily done unintentionally? No way in hell.

You don't even need to calibrate anything, just throw out the first bunch of stuff that comes out of the still. There's a ~10deg hop after the methanol is done boiling during which the still almost stops producing. You just throw out everything that comes before (and during) that reduced flow.

Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by ZeroGravitas on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:10AM (#29459891)
I think you might be referring to this legislative attempt to workaround tax avoidance with sometimes fatal consequences.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denatured_alcohol

> Denatured alcohol (also called methylated spirits, in Australia, Canada, Ireland, New Zealand, South Africa, and the United Kingdom; wood spirit; and denatured rectified spirit)[1] is ethanol that has additives to make it poisonous, bad-tasting, foul-smelling, or nauseating to discourage its recreational consumption. It is sometimes dyed so that it can be identified visually. Pyridine and methanol,[2] each and together, make denatured alcohol poisonous; and denatonium makes it bitter.

> In many countries, sales of alcoholic beverages are heavily taxed for revenue and public health policy purposes (see Pigovian tax). In order to avoid paying beverage taxes on alcohol that is not meant to be consumed, the alcohol must be "denatured", or treated with added chemicals to make it unpalatable. Its composition is tightly defined by government regulations in countries that tax alcoholic beverages.

Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by nicoburns on Monday December 06, 2021 @05:40AM (#29458134)
> Do you realize this ideia of poison alcohol was propaganda from the government, right?

Eh, I'm not sure about that. There are stories in the newspaper every few years about a corner stop selling cheap bootleg alcohol that has caused someone to go blind (or die) because it contained too much methanol. I for one am quite glad that alcohol production is well regulated.

Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by seanwilson on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:50AM (#29460350)
> There are stories in the newspaper every few years about a corner stop selling cheap bootleg alcohol that has caused someone to go blind (or die) because it contained too much methanol. I for one am quite glad that alcohol production is well regulated.

Can you find a case of methanol poisoning for beer or wine brewing where the maker hasn't deliberately added in something extra that contains methanol (e.g. from fluids sold for industrial use)?

I find when the news reports stories like this, they bury in the story where the methanol poisoning came from so the general public are led to believe that all alcohol brewing is incredibly dangerous, including making non-distilled drinks yourself.

For example, the first link from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_methanol_poisoning_inc... is https://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-06-06/grappa-poison-william...:

"Man pleads not guilty to manslaughter and grievous bodily harm following home brew tragedy...Mr Meredith said Lynam bought methanol to use as industrial weed killer and confused it with ethanol when the home brew was made."

Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by nicoburns on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:21AM (#29460759)
I haven't researched this, but all the cases I remember were vodka or a similar spirit. It may well have been because someone was adding something containing methanol.
Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by lowkey on Monday December 06, 2021 @08:22AM (#29459373)
> Do you realize this idea of poison alcohol was propaganda from the government, right?

Do you realize that:

> During prohibition, the US Govt added poison to industrial alcohol to discourage consumption. People continued to drink it, so the government added more and they killed 10,000 people.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prohibition_in_the_United_Stat...

Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by GordonS on Monday December 06, 2021 @06:14AM (#29458317)
Purely anecdotal, but my brother has a small (illicit) still and has walked me through the process - it's fairly simple, and neither of us can figure out how these methanol poisoning cases could happen by accident.

Simply, the "heads" (which are high in methanol) come out of the still first, so it's easy to remove them.

In addition, methanol test strips are cheap and easy to use.

Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by nicoburns on Monday December 06, 2021 @06:19AM (#29458338)
I think it's probably as simple as people not caring and being careless.
Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by a2tech on Monday December 06, 2021 @11:12AM (#29461515)
Discarding the heads is obviously best practices, but from discussions with serious scientifically minded distillers (ie chemists that enjoy brewing gin and artisanal vodka at home) the amount of methanol contained in the heads of your home distillation is hardly enough to harm you. In the worst cases if you consumed a significant volume it might give you a harsh headache (and this would be a truly large amount). If you were to collect the heads from several batches and drank that all in one go, you could probably make yourself sick.

Now say you're a shady corner store owner and you take some denatured alcohol or other spirits and dump it into some cheap vodka and sell it under the table as 'moonshine' or something else to make a quick buck...yeah you're going to hurt people. And not just a little. You could easily kill someone that way, or permanently damage them. But at home with your own still? You're way more likely to start a fire than you are to kill someone with your distillate. Unless you start cutting your output with other not-for-consumption spirits.

Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by GordonS on Monday December 06, 2021 @02:26PM (#29464382)
Aside from removing the heads to avoid death and blindness, it's also done for flavour and aroma - they have a nasty, "chemical/solvent" smell (and I'd assume taste).
Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by Swannie on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:48PM (#29468631)
Right, it's not only the methanol that you want to discard, there's acetone, and other nasties too.
Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by thathndude on Monday December 06, 2021 @06:14AM (#29458315)
But you could also simply not partake right?

If I’m very sensitive to food borne illness concerns, maybe I make the choice to go to a grocery store with vacuum sealed product, versus buying at a farmers market?

Similarly, folks who want “safe” booze can buy the bottled stuff from the big boys, not the corner store swill.

Of course, the weakness in this position is that the corner store swill is often substantially cheaper, and thus disproportionately affects low income communities.

No good answers. I’m not a smoker. So I have no dog in this fight. But I can’t help but read this article with a degree of schaddenfreude and frustration. The gov’t is so poor at executing sometimes, it’s astounding.

Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by beerandt on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:22PM (#29476194)
Not just the idea/ propaganda, but the govt mandate that methanol be added to ethanol to make denatured spirits, aka the "poison alcohol".

It was literally a government created problem, with the same government claiming to be the only layer of security protecting John Q Public from this super dangerous product.

Prohibition is a case study in so many different ways of how to badly govern with the best intentions.

Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by pmarreck on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:15AM (#29459948)
> this ideia of poison alcohol was propaganda done by the government during prohibition

imagine believing propaganda about propaganda.

congrats, man, you've come full-circle. methanol poisoning is very real, and methanol is definitely present in the "heads" of distillations (speaking as someone who's done this), and since there isn't a clear delineation between what is the "head" and what is the "body", it's entirely too easy (especially if you don't want to waste any of the good stuff) to accidentally include too much methanol in your distillation... which is exactly why alcohol is regulated

Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by throwaway0a5e on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:36AM (#29460191)
> and since there isn't a clear delineation between what is the "head" and what is the "body"

At any appreciable scale you get a reduced flow/pause in output as the mixture finishes boiling off the methanol and has to increase in temp before boiling the ethanol. It's a 10+ degree temp change so it's not instant. You need to be creating a small batch on a heat source that's way overkill to not have a defined difference.

Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by bigbillheck on Monday December 06, 2021 @08:45AM (#29459628)
> We know how to distill from millenniums,

Only in the sense that we've had computers for millennia (i.e. the one before 2000 and the one after).

Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by gbronner on Monday December 06, 2021 @06:15AM (#29458321)
Jamaica Ginger and the Jake Walk. A lot of people were crippled by bad booze adulterated with other bad things
Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by yebyen on Monday December 06, 2021 @06:10AM (#29458289)
> We know how to distill from millenniums

I'm reminded of that XKCD where every day, 10000 people are learning for the first time something that everybody knows...

No person alive today has known how to distill alcohol safe for human consumption for longer than about 100 years. The median experience among current distillers will be substantially lower than that age.

Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by namibj on Monday December 06, 2021 @02:44AM (#29457228)
Well, a flame test is suitable (at least against liquor that isn't deliberately trying to kill you), but the naked eye isn't sophisticated enough to analyze the spectrum.
Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by OneTimePetes on Monday December 06, 2021 @05:11AM (#29457994)
sodium dichromate ?
Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by Justsignedup on Monday December 06, 2021 @09:12AM (#29459909)
As enforcement is winding down, weed dispensaries are competing against near slave wage labor.

That's the problem. Illegal weed is basically being created outside the US with labor who barely gets paid, of course the cost will be higher.

Because it's being imported via illegal channels this is now a customs problem.

My bet is that the way to solve this would be to create a legal weed import policy, letting it sit there for a decade, then when illegal weed channels don't exist, add on a tariff. Then things will balance out.

Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by buildsjets on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:35AM (#29460989)
Lol! Weed is barely imported anymore. Seizures at the border have been on a continuous downward trend since 2000. Imports are now close to miniscule. It’s illegally grown domestically, whether that be guerrilla grows in the national forest, or massive warehouses in plain sight.

https://www.princetonpolicy.com/ppa-blog/2018/5/15/we-are-wi...

https://sgp.fas.org/crs/misc/R45812.pdf

https://abcnews.go.com/US/wireStory/oregon-state-police-seiz...

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/marijuana-seized-california-bil...

Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by boringg on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:12AM (#29460634)
Um, its being grown in Humboldt county in the middle of the forest. It is essentially incredibly cheap forced labor - but input costs are pretty low.

There is also pot being imported but a lot of it is grown in the state/national forests.

Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by pengaru on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:23AM (#29460793)
Judging from news reports, a good chunk is grown in the desert region as well:

https://z1077fm.com/tag/marijuana/

Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by boringg on Monday December 06, 2021 @10:54AM (#29461229)
Seems like both mexican and asian gangs based on those arrested. Desert seems like a bold place to grow even in the shade structures... All you need to do is run an algorithm over the satellite data for any new structures on a weekly basis then have PD check it out for illegal grow op...
Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by pengaru on Monday December 06, 2021 @12:19PM (#29462589)
The consequences for the perps are basically nil, it's apparently a land use violation as far as CA is concerned. Literally a county code enforcement/permitting office problem of agriculture in a non-agriculture zone. At least until they find illegal weapons or evidence of other crimes.

There's been rumblings of changing the laws to increase the penalties, but I haven't followed the issue closely. The large grows are problematic for the region's water security/quality, since the region is dependent on finite groundwater aquifers full of ancient water that isn't being recharged anywhere near the rate of consumption AIUI. There are reasons it's not zoned for agriculture.

Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by dumbfoundded on Monday December 06, 2021 @01:20PM (#29463520)
A lot wrong with your statement. Weed isn't imported. It's grown domestically. Here was a billion dollar field in California that got caught (1). There are many more.

The next part of slave labor is just false. Trimmers I met were earning $500 to $1,000 a day. $100 per lb trimmed was pretty common. If anything, creating an import model will guarantee we use slaves. Columbia exports cannabis legally to Europe already with a lot less worker protections than in the US.

(1) https://www.nbclosangeles.com/news/local/la-county-sheriff-m...

Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by curryst on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @10:54AM (#29473836)
> Trimmers I met were earning $500 to $1,000 a day. $100 per lb trimmed was pretty common.

I don't believe this, the numbers don't line up. If it's wet, doing 5 pounds in a day is reasonable, but nobody's going to pay you $100/pound for it. 5 pounds of wet is a little over a pound dried, so $500 is around a quarter of the total sale price. I just don't believe anyone is paying that much for something a child with safety scissors could do (albeit much worse). I also don't believe that growers wouldn't simply buy automatic bud trimmers. They're not as good, but I would be willing to bet that consumers would be happy to not pay the apparent 25% trimmer markup in exchange for slightly less pretty buds.

If that's dry bud, the price is reasonable, but there's no way in hell anyone is trimming 5-10 pounds of dry bud a day. That's like a rolling curbside garbage bin full of weed.

I don't think they're using slave labor, but given the number of people I've heard wanting to do it so they can work with weed, I'd be surprised if they're paying significantly more than minimum wage. I'd wager it's very close to $15/hour + perks, where "perks" mostly means "all the free weed you can smoke".

Re:SF suspends cannabis tax to help dispensaries compete wit... by beerandt on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:48PM (#29476570)
>similar to pharmaceuticals.

It is a pharmaceutical. Using any given drug without doctor or pharmacist oversight isn't a great argument for less regulation. Even if you're overall against most regulation and govt overreach.

>Even the scales used must be of the same spec used for gold weighing and cost roughly $1,500 each. It's not just the dispensaries but the wholesalers, processors, and cultivators need to buy these scales and register them once a year with the state for $100.

Every scale or other measuring device involved in commerce has to be inspected and stamped yearly, in most states. That's why the scale at your grocery checkout and gas pumps have the same stickers on them.

Other than the banking issue, none of the common complaints are really specific to the cannibas market.

More likely this market has just attracted a disproportionate number of people with little or no business experience, who are oblivious to the risks, regulatory hurdles, and associated costs that all types of businesses deal with.

>Lowering the barrier to market would have the additional benefit of enabling smaller market participants...

>It's a great disgrace that our laws have prevented any reasonable path for going legit while demonizing them in the process.

Spoken like someone starting to understand some of those crazy right-winger, free-market, pro-business, small-government arguments.