Re:HP to produce one more batch of Touchpads
by ghshephard on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @07:11PM
(#2943613)
A downvote on a contributor can be, and frequently is, a vote of disagreement, regardless of how well intentioned and expressed the contributor was.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:HP to produce one more batch of Touchpads
by georgemcbay on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @07:38PM
(#2943672)
If I cared enough about the space to make a karma-based threading system, I would attempt to come up with a way to differentiate disagreement with contribution score (aka karma).
Sometimes people feel the need to register disagreement but can't be bothered to write a specific reply as to why, and while it sucks that many people do that via downvoting the contribution score, it is understandable why they do it and there is probably a better fix for it than just telling them they shouldn't do it (they won't listen).
Re:HP to produce one more batch of Touchpads
by spiralganglion on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @08:04PM
(#2943707)
Hiding a valuable contribution because you disagree with it probably isn't the intended purpose of the system. Hiding something that lessens the quality of the conversation, independent of the skew it takes, makes more sense.
It doesn't matter what the common practice is. What matters is preserving the integrity of the discussion.