News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An alarming trend in K-12 math education: a guest post an... by threatofrain on Friday December 03, 2021 @02:48PM (#29434413)
Talking about "testing out" and "gifted" programs is a complete distraction here, since very few students "test out", and taking Algebra in middle school is not considered a "gifted" program. With regards to math in California, gifted programs are largely not a story.

A pillar of Equitable Math is that all students should be at the same level up until the last year of high school.¹ The re-arrangement of subjects is not the hotspot of contention, and neither is the disagreement over "deepness".

The contention is over whether or not there ought to exist a faster track which, for example, permits students to take Algebra in middle school. This has been specifically derided as a sustainer of white supremacy under the Equitable Math discussion.

A return to gifted programs as the way to deal with students with differences in math preparation and ambition would be a return to administrative opacity. A failure to specify tracks which allow students to take Algebra in middle school would be a solid win for private schools and after-school programs like RSM.

Under Equitable Math, the last year in high school is the only year of differentiation.

[1]: https://equitablemath.org

Re:An alarming trend in K-12 math education: a guest post an... by naasking on Friday December 03, 2021 @04:40PM (#29435938)
> A return to gifted programs as the way to deal with students with differences in math preparation and ambition would be a return to administrative opacity.

I mean, if they're going to eliminate gifted programs for an advanced academic students, then they should eliminate sports teams for advanced athletic students by parity of reasoning. Isn't the star quarterback just as unfairly advantaged by family and genetics as the smart math geek?

Re:An alarming trend in K-12 math education: a guest post an... by threatofrain on Saturday December 04, 2021 @04:47AM (#29439821)
Again, gifted programs are largely not a story in CA math. Students taking Algebra in middle school are not in a separate gifted and talented program, they are just in one of many pathways as specified by the Common Core. For example, in some nice school districts, about half of the students in middle school are on track for Algebra by 8th grade.

These don't apply to any special program, there is no lottery, and they aren't hand-picked by teachers or administrators.