Re:An alarming trend in K-12 math education: a guest post an...
by akomtu on Friday December 03, 2021 @05:54PM
(#29436647)
What are those "geometric proofs"? I've never seen this term before. Geometry is really just numbers in disguise, e.g. a circle is really numbers that define its center and its radius, and sometimes those numbers are defined implicitly, e.g. when its a highly complex curve that's not reducible to simple circles and lines. In this sense, all proofs are about symbols and numbers, geometry is only there to guide our intuition.
Re:An alarming trend in K-12 math education: a guest post an...
by jacobmartin on Friday December 03, 2021 @08:13PM
(#29437698)
High school students are frequently taught a highly routinized form of proof in Geometry class in the US: https://www.cuemath.com/geometry/geometrical-proofs/
That is what it seems the parent was referring to and what I was referring to.
Though admittedly I only got an SB in Math, I think geometric proofs were an okay introduction to the idea of the proof and of logic. Of course they are not representative of professional math. There are many things we learn as an introduction which don't turn out to bear that much resemblance to the more advanced form. I don't write 5-paragraph essays with clear thesis sentences anymore either. But it helped me to learn to write that way as a way of clarifying that I was stating my arguments effectively.
Sometimes, for my homework, I tried to state very explicitly in my proofs which axiomata I was using, both as an intellectual exercise and to see, e.g., where I might have gotten my logic backwards or where I used the axiom of choice (which constantly surprised me). I wouldn't turn these overexplicit proofs, but it helped to clarify that I was doing things correctly. If anything, when I was in college, the trend was away from 'informal' language. When I took, e.g., Discrete Math, for more complicated proofs, we were encouraged to write out a DAG for the dependencies of the proofs/lemmata so that it was exceedingly clear what depended on what and that we had in fact proven what we set out to prove.