The people who make these decisions don't view these sorts of things from the same perspective as you do but from a geopolitical lense of military might. In the simplest case it could be information gathering or even just a distraction. One can say this is an immoral self-perpetuating cycle, but that is how it is today.
This article, Space Command Hints at New Capabilities to Counter China, Russia, from Aug 21, 2020 may help shed light on that. [1] This article is from the same month but an Indian perspective [2]
[1] https://www.nationaldefensemagazine.org/articles/2020/8/21/u...
[2] https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/defence/china-atte...
Edit: I have looked at your comment history, and you appear to be very defensive of CCP in every comment you make. I'm not sure your question here was asked in good faith.
For an interesting read on this effect, I'd recommend Lionel Fatton's 2016 article “The impotence of conventional arms control: why do international regimes fail when they are most needed?”[0] (if you can access it).
[0] https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/13523260.2016.11...
I would say off the top of my head that if the US had a well developed moon base, then it could effectively attack most satellites in earth orbit and rockets attempting to reach orbit. No other strategic point in near earth space can provide a base for manufacturing, storage, launch , refuelling, etc of earth orbit superiority.
Right now the military has a rare window: if Starship enables a 10x payload advantage, that is a 10x throughput advantage for getting moon base up and running.
Of course owning the moon would mean even more dominance of the rest of the solar system. You can launch Orion pulse nuclear craft from the Moon pretty easily for practical planetary ships of very very large size (1 million tons)
> then it could effectively attack most satellites in earth orbit and rockets attempting to reach orbit
This is the High Ground thesis, dating back to the 1950s (see https://thespacereview.com/article/396/1 and http://spaceflighthistory.blogspot.com/2015/08/he-who-contro... ).
It takes a couple of days to get from the Moon to the Earth. A Moon base could not prevent rockets from reaching orbit.
I'm pretty sure the US, and likely also Russia, can already effectively attack most satellites in earth orbit, so if that's the goal, a Moon base seems needless.
The shore in this case is the moon.
In the case of rocket interception from the moon, you put a big laser on the moon, not complicated. Could you do that from the Earth? Atmosphere, etc.
As for historical precedent for military dominance presaging development, it isn't really a good example, but it's the period of colonialism in Europe. Countries in europe raced to build economic exploitation empires elsewhere in the world, let by advanced militarization of the seas.
Unlike the age of sail, modern warfare doesn't use simply bigger weapons. We've got all the megatons of nukes anyone would want.
The USS Hornet was much less powerful than the land-based airfields of Hawai'i. Guess which one was able to bomb Japan first.
Obvious complication with a Moon-based laser system: beam divergence. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beam_divergence . What Moon-based laser system is able to deliver enough power 380,000 km away to a rocket able to take multiple g's and handle the aerodynamic stress of supersonic travel?
Another complication: The power and accuracy loss of the atmosphere makes it hard to target rockets during launch phase. And if you wait until it's out of the atmosphere, how do you track it once its engines are off?
A third complication: Not only is it relatively small and hard to target from 380,000km away, but the round-trip speed-of-light delay is 2.5 seconds. Add some jinking to the rocket's trajectory and it will be quite hard to hit. (How wide do you think the rocket-damaging part of the beam will be?)
A fourth complication: what if the launch is on the other side of the Earth from the Moon?
Given all of these complications, orbital battle satellites are the obvious equivalent to the Hornet, able to be on station in a way that more powerful land-based systems cannot. And these can be supplied from the ground.
Or, if it's truly "not complicated", what are your solutions?
> to build economic exploitation
Which is a euphemism for "use force to extract labor and resources from other people." Look at all that British architecture built on the broken backs of black slaves in the sugar trade. Leopold II certainly managed to 'economically exploit' the Congo Free State. And of course the delightful opium trade with China.
Maybe, just perhaps, it's possible we can do without a repeat of that?
[metaphor warning]It's like VCs[/metaphor warning] to use HN mindthink, who will fund the trillions to get a functional space civs? Oh and they'll just [metaphor warning]kumbaya[/metaphor warning] and write off their massive investments with no controlling interest?
As for the [metaphor warning]British Empire[/metaphor warning] or any other colonialism METAPHOR, at least there aren't [metaphor warning]indiginous tribes[/metaphor warning] that will be displaced, exploited, and exterminated.
Size does matter with gravity wells. If you don't want to concede that, then you're arguing against very basic physics. The moon allows the instant deployment of a far larger force of weapons on demand than from Earth's surface.
If you had a moon base, you could launch an army of battle satellites on short notice. It's basically drone warfare in space. Right now you have to predeploy your satellite flotilla and then the enemy just needs to deploy tracking H/K units. The moon has superior gravity well position to deploy a satellite and satellite killer army without launch windows, rocket and payload preparation, etc. Your deployments are very easily tracked, from launch to payload deployment, to orbit, with bounds on where that satellite will travel and how much delta-v it can have.
The point is there is currently no political [metaphor warning]horse [/metaphor warning] to [metaphor warning]carry the water[/metaphor warning] of putting a functional economic base in space. Military supremacy is a very tantalizing motivation to provide a trillion dollars of funding, and there basically isn't any others [metaphor warning]on the table[/metaphor warning].
As for laser focusing, you are thinking like a small satellite designer would think who is constrained by launch capability. Moon military systems could have VERY LARGE lasers. Hell you could do simple space mirrors to achieve the desired effect, light delays be damned.
I'll argue by metaphor if I want to.
Antarctica isn't militarized, and it also has "difficult resource constraints".
Guess they must have been passing around some good weed back then in the UN building.
> you could launch an army of battle satellites on short notice
You've changed the topic. I objected to your claim that a "moon base ... could effectively attack ... rockets attempting to reach orbit".
It CANNOT. Those battle satellites would take two days to reach the Earth, giving plenty of time for rockets to reach orbit.
> Moon military systems could have VERY LARGE lasers
Looks like you got some of that good weed too.
Your "could" requires magic pixie dust. If you're going to break the laws of physics, might as well have transporter beams too.
A moon based laser CANNOT prevent a rocket reaching orbit if only because the rocket can launch from the other side of the planet.
You are of course free to argue by metaphor. The metaphor of comparing modern military tactics to the age of sail, back when more powerful cannon made for a more powerful ship, is still fundamentally flawed.
Unless you are convinced that NATO are the good guys and CCP are the bad guys so they must be silenced, but I'd tell you that's the propaganda doing the thinking for you.
"Widespread propaganda that the entire world believes except for the select few that live in a tightly controlled bubble where anybody who speaks out is violently silenced" has a lot of common properties with "things that are true".
The very point and raison d'être of propaganda is to repeat an idea so often that people start to believe it, even if it has no basis in reality.
But then again, plenty of books and philosopher-hours have been spent on the topic of "truth", which honestly becomes a semantic rabbit hole I'm not interested in diving in.
There is a pretty clear pattern that does who don't use censorship end up killed and those that do survive much longer.
That is a hot take!
Satellites harassing with close passes, blocking antennas, maybe even poking each other. "Damn ye Russian satellites!" The politicians bellow as they shake their fists at the cosmos.
This question is hard to understand. You don't know why competing militaries would behave this way?
The OP doesn't discuss trust; it informs you about such activity and the US militaries desire to counter it. Should they do nothing? Do you think China and Russia will stop if the US never acts in its own defense? Putin and Xi will suddenly decide we are all friends?
Russia and China behave the same way with many countries. Russia even controls parts of Ukraine and Georgia, and threatens Ukraine with invasion at the moment. China does it with Japan, the Philippines, and India, off the top of my head.
The US never does it with their neighbors, and in fact many other countries welcome the US military to operate from their territory. The idea of Russia and China as innocent victims is quite a stretch!
The proposed treaty is called the PAROS treaty and was proposed by Russia in 2008 officially as a draft. The US never gave it any suit and was actively hostile to the subject. https://www.nti.org/education-center/treaties-and-regimes/pr...
China is not threatening the invasion of India, the Philippines, or Japan. There are relatively small disputes of uninhabited territory, with the exception of Tawang with a population of 11 000 in India. You may as well say that the US is threatening to invade Canada because of disputes in the Arctic. I'm exaggerating, but only slightly.
Yes, Russia is threatening Ukraine with invasion. But this is not coming in a vacuum. Russia, in a vacuum, has nothing to gain from invading Ukraine, far from it. The reason why Russia has designs for Russia is because:
A) Ukraine has a border with Russia B) Ukraine discussed joining NATO C) NATO is attempting to encircle Russia D) Russia is very weak strategically on the Ukrainian and Georgian border E) NATO accession is impossible if there is a current conflict
Therefore, Russia will be threatening Ukraine as long as Ukraine has ambitions of joining NATO. It's not because Russia wants Ukrainian resources, it's fundamentally because Russia is afraid of being flanked by a hostile foreign alliance. From their point of view this is perfectly rational, you see the US withdrawing from the ABM treaty and building dozens of weapons systems to try to disable nuclear deterrence, trying as much as possible to deny air defenses and gain the capability to strike deep within Russia, and setting up all these systems that threaten the balance of power right next to Russia, then trying to creep up to the most vulnerable positions of Russia. It's completely logical to seek a neutral buffer state, and if that's impossible, to create a natural obstacle.
Throwing morals out of the window, it would be stupid to expect anything else. Russia never threatened Ukraine with invasion as long as Ukraine did not threaten to join NATO. If we want Russia to stop threatening Ukraine, then we have to stop the NATO threat of invading or blockading or otherwise crippling Russia militarily. The West would actually be pretty happy with more Russian adventures in Ukraine, it weakens their economy and scares off more countries into the EU camp, while giving excuses for sanctions and allows the US to take over some sectors.
The point is, no one is an innocent victim. Russia and China are happy to de-escalate and avoid arms races, as is made evident by the low military spending in China and the efforts to pursue asymmetric competition in Russia. It's just that the United States doesn't want to avoid an arms race. The US wants an arms race in space, because Russia is poor and will struggle competing, and China is trying to avoid spending too much on their military right now. So this is a domain where the US is seeking to buildup a commanding lead, and because of this the US is very happy with an arms race. That is, so long as the Chinese and Russians do not exceed US expectations, which they have a nasty habit of doing right now, and that the US military budget is constantly increasing, which is the purpose of this headline.
I think that the foreign policy you read is simply very biased towards the US and far from neutral. If you haven't heard about the 30 years of constant proposals by Russia to demilitarize space, I really don't know what to tell you. It's a massive oversight. The US loves arms races in space, always has, and this is not the first rodeo of the US avoiding armament treaties or withdrawing and trying to cause arms races. It's in the interest of the US so far.
- To assess what the satellite is capable of doing
- To geolocate where signals from Earth are originating
- To analyse patterns of multi-spot beam steering and bandwidth re-allocation
- Test denial of service attacks
- Test attacks where signals (or return signals) from Earth are manipulated (e.g. radar signatures faked)
- Test attacks where signals (or return signals) from the satellite are manipulated
- Eavesdrop on unprotected communications
- To waste fuel on the target satellite as it maneuvers to avoid any of the above (even if nothing is attempted)
- To make the other party second guess their technology for no good reason, lowering their confidence in its accuracy or usefulness
I'm sure there are plenty of other possible explanations which could be added to this list.
For military satellites, proximity avoidance is fully autonomous. Therefore, you can design a satellite to chase other satellites to fuel exhaustion. I’ve been told this is an actual thing.
Also, military technology is probably one of the coolest, tech-savvy things we will ever have.
Now I have a toddler, and I think it's appalling that kids books include this machinery amongst the same pages as firetrucks, ambulances, passenger jets, and cruise ships.
It's completely fucked up how we normalize weapons of war and indoctrinate our children into thinking they're cool.
Look, I'm not naïve. There are parts of the world in active military conflict. If you are in Ukraine or South Korea, you have a very legitimate reason to be preparing to take up arms in a military conflict. But just because it might be "necessary", doesn't mean it's "cool".
War means death. Unnecessary human death. Military technology are tools for maximizing unnecessary human death. As a secular humanist who believes we all have only one finite life to live, every unnecessary death is an unforgivable tragedy.
Did anyone in the US seriously feel that they were in danger of losing something in America to Saddam?
Does anyone actually think today that China is going to invade and occupy the US?
Not saying NOBODY in the world has to feel this way. Taiwan surely does. Ukraine surely does. South Korea. A dozen other places in the world.
Now I am in my mid fifties and the accumulated assaults on my person have given me an immense amount of combat experience. It makes me sad that you are so unable to come to terms with the intense violence that is pervasive in your society. Perhaps you can work out your anger toward preparedness by throwing rocks at people.
Besides you cant rush globalisation, cultural differences take time to evolve over generations, we haven't had the internet and other forms of communication for that many years in the scheme of things and there are still many people on this planet who have not even used or regularly use the internet.
Whose culture is right? What is right in the eyes of the law?
Are other satellites from other countries also coming under attack and they are not talking about it publicly, making the US seem a victim when many countries are victims but also aggressors?
We are rarely in complete possession of the facts with any govt or big business or anyone else for that matter! C'est la vie
On your point about something being unsustainable, when it comes to nukes, there is more to this than meets the eye, namely energy density. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density#List_of_materia...
So whilst Project Fear keeps populations in awe and fear with a big dangerous firework aka a nuke, its nothing near, religions have been putting the fear of god into people claiming things like thunderstorms and lightening are acts of God!
Sometimes its best to view the news as what are they trying to change here or get out of people.
Still interesting none the less.
Perhaps I’m the only one who feels this way based on the number of pro-China posts, but a Chinese hegemony would likely be a world of censorship and social credit. Compared to a flawed US democracy I’ll take the US democracy every time.
And as you say, it's good to be at the top.
It would be irrational of China's leadership to seek anything else.
To be the hegemon, you need to have a clear advantage over everyone else. China will never have that over the US+Europe. And by the time the US and Europe seriously decline, China will start declining too.
China's leadership would be foolish to seek hegemony. It's just not feasible short of the US going into a civil war, and if you come at the king, you best not miss. Becoming a second king yourself instead of trying to take his place is much less risky and has most of the same rewards.
Another way to look at it is that China will never have the same advantage over the US as the US gained over the UK before taking the lead. The US passed the British in economy and population much before it became the hegemon. You need more than an advantage in prosperity.
You're also missing the long game of China. Probably on our lifetimes the economic focus of the world is going to move to Asia and Africa based on opportunity of growth and demographics, looking from this perspective why would they care about conquering the west when they can just position themselves very well for the long term and have a nice view watching the decline of the west society?
The economic focus in the world moved to the US for about 70 years before the US gained hegemony.
You can be number one without being the hegemon.
"never" is a strong word here.
Tech and military wise they're catching up really fast. They have a much fitter and controlled population. Their economy is doing real good, they're spreading their influence over Africa, &c.
The US is crumbling on virtually every aspect, Europe isn't doing much better, if China and the US stays on their respective courses your "never" will be more like "in 50-100 years".
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cultural_Revolution
> China is not interested in controlling or imposing beliefs
China is extremely interested in controlling and imposing the beliefs that the CCP is the best and should never be opposed and never makes mistakes, and demonstrates this daily within the great firewall and through threat of sanction against international media companies, nevermind the regular disappearance of high-profile individuals that cause "problems"...you know, to have a nice months-long chat with them that isn't about controlling or imposing beliefs.
> China has not had the imperial history
There are a number of formerly, currently, and soon-to-be-no-longer sovereign countries that don't want to be part of China, but China pretends they're not occupying/colonizing them by insisting they have always been part of China.
maybe you're right, depending on how you define citizens - though taking a page from the British empire, maybe everyone's a citizen!
>China is culturally an ancient agrarian society focused more on defending farmland
is nonsense just like all the Chinese netizens who keep saying that "We Descendants of Yanhuang have 5000 years of history". Non-sense, PRC happened in 1949, and before that, it's a History of ethnicities from all over the land Conquer, Massacre, Annex and Integrate each other.
EDIT:
> China is not interested in controlling or imposing beliefs
There are 56 ethnic groups in China, they may have different culture even religion, what do you think how China managed to make sure all 55 other then Han stay under control?
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Han_Chinese
Is that incorrect?
And this is off-topic. The idea is simple: "China is culturally an ancient agrarian society focused more on defending farmland than conquering nation" does not stand. Conquering happens a lot on that land way before PRC is a thing.
It reminds me of this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3nxqDHHORqg LOL
I fear China in peace.
Trust goes both ways, and it takes effort from both parties to build trust. This kind of actions will only been seen as aggressive and ill intent by the other party, and when there is lack of trust between two parties, the other will come up with defensive and offensive counter measure to protect themselves. And that doesn't help when one party has got an active military branch named space force.
Looks like the space arms race and militarization of space will only escalate in the future. I hope people will realize, like the nuclear arms race before, this kind of wild west arms race is unsustainable for everyone involved, and for humanity as a whole. I hope leaders from all countries involved to have the courage and consideration for all of humanity and our collective peaceful use of space, to put geopolitics aside, to come up rules of responsible use and engagement in space.
https://breakingdefense.com/2021/10/us-china-russia-test-new...