News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by mattzito on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:10PM (#29423464)
Sure, but we can make the virus largely irrelevant in terms of its impact on peoples lives. We can reduce the number of people who suffer long term consequences, the number of deaths, and the load on hospitals. We can make it harder for new, more dangerous, variants to arise.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by EricE on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:13PM (#29424267)
How can you do that by only vaccinating humans. You do know COVID is carried by animals too, right?

https://www.cnn.com/2021/11/17/health/covid-deer-animals/ind...

You going to vaccinate all the animals too?

Or just dogmatically stick to the "unvaccinated people are selfish" because it best fits your political world view - damn the science?

Want to make this virus irrelevant? If Omicron is as mild as the doctors in South Africa are reporting then here is our path to herd immunity. Which is going to happen no matter what governments fuss and fume about. Even New Zealand finally gave up on their ridiculous quarantine strategy.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by mattzito on Thursday December 02, 2021 @07:43PM (#29425171)
I’m just confused about the argument you are making here - that if our options are:

A) let’s all get a couple of shots to reduce our risk of death, serious illness, and make it less likely that other people get sick, not to mention making it less likely that new variants will emerge by making transmission harder

or

B) let’s have no vaccinations and let the virus sort it out, like we did with, say, the 1918 flu? Or polio, measles, or smallpox?

or

C) let people get vaccinated or not, it’s their business, but putting societal pressure on them is overbearing and eventually pointless

That of those options we should choose either B or C? Because B is how we dealt with illnesses until we had vaccinations to make them harder to get and less deadly. Then we started…vaccinating people. And now measles is still a thing, but no one worries about it, except that cases are going up because people aren’t getting vaccinated. So B seems like a bad plan, because we tried that and it sucked, and then we did A with measles and things got a lot better.

C is certainly a lot more personal liberty-oriented, which I get the appeal of, but society is fundamentally about giving up some amount of individual liberty in exchange for shared and communal benefits. C is actually what is happening in some places with measles vaccinations, where individuals say, “I don’t need to be vaccinated because herd immunity will save me”, which not only means that (despite claiming personal liberty) those people are relying on the vaccinated people to protect them, but that they’re willing to put others at risk (because vaccines aren’t perfect) in exchange for their individual liberty. This seems like C is a pretty raw deal for the liberty and rights of the people who would rather not get infected by, say, measles. Or Covid.

B and C both seem like bad plans. A seems pretty good, but I realize you’re not going to be convinced of that. B is pretty indefensible, I don’t think anyone would argue we should just let Covid run through the world and kill millions and millions more people. Or maybe you do, I don’t know. Seems bad.

But with C, the only way you can argue it’s not selfish to look after your own preferences is if you believe that the outcomes of option A, B, and C are the same. That it doesn’t matter - the same amount of people will die, and the same amount of people will get infected, and the same amount of people will permanently lose their sense of taste or smell, and the same amount of people will end up in the hospital. That fundamentally the outcomes of all three scenarios are identical. But there’s no way that’s the case, right? It just doesn’t make sense.

So if there IS a difference, then A is everyone doing as much as reasonably possible to make things better, B is everyone giving up and accepting whatever happens, and C is valuing your interests above the opportunity to help others. That’s the definition of selfishness.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by aakresearch on Thursday December 02, 2021 @11:06PM (#29426511)
> but putting societal pressure on them is overbearing and eventually pointless

> ...

> and C is valuing your interests above the opportunity to help others. That’s the definition of selfishness.

This, I think, highlights the fundamental blind spot in reasoning of many who pushes the vax or other measures to 100% "uptake". What do the people think will happen once somebody submits to the pressure? Masked and vaxed and fine and dandy? Quite the opposite, I believe. The resistance in the remaining population is not at the rational level, it is very visceral, primal, fight-or-flight feeling. Even though, I think, it was largely provoked by the initial torrent of equally irrational measures, it is not something that is going to change. Submitting to pressure doesn't mean forgetting or forgiving. The solid foundation is being laid for a very broken society for a generation to come. The internal trust in society is as shaken as never before. Society with 5-10% of people broken, bitter and vengeful is not healthy. The fallout is going to be very bad, in unexpected way. Cruel and unusual.

Sure, you may say it is selfishness. It is not rational selfishness though. As I said, it is a visceral reaction which is very hard to explain, to put into words, therefore all you hear is "we don't want it". It is sort of a mental condition, and pushing through to the end won't cure that condition, only make it worse. Such condition is nothing to be proud of, but punitive correctional measures aren't known to work against diseases, mental included. Even criminals are not prosecuted if suspected to be in acute mental condition.

I would hope the nature of the resistance is properly recognised and not vilified. After all, we've complied with all the past vaccine "soft-mandates" for our children and ourselves, but always thought that generous exemption provisions were very good! Letting people make choices without pushing them into the corner is beneficial for society. I always thought the society's capacity for compassion was bigger than my own. Unfortunately, it is not what transpired.

At this moment I'd be ok with increased insurance premiums, testing regime for travel and high-risk settings, tax surcharge or even mandatory community service as alternative to vax. Something we can rationally discuss. "Bodily autonomy" - face masks included - is simply not something I can engage with rationally.

But what is the end game?

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by mattzito on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:04AM (#29427108)
I’m not arguing that everyone should be forced to get vaccinated - I’m saying that people who choose not to are selfish. And they shouldn’t be immune to some level of personal impact, lots of people make personal choices that have negative impact. I once turned down an incredibly lucrative opportunity because I disagreed with the products I’d be working on. The father of a friend of mine was a professional pilot who never got above flying for a regional airline because his cigarette addiction meant he struggled to go more than three hours between cigarettes. Personal choices have impacts.

The argument that you make is odd, though, which seems to be that people have been so pushed around by these horrible, unreasonable asks that they have a “visceral fight-or-flight” response and hence have a “mental condition” that prevents them from adapting - and not accepting that demonstrates a lack of compassion.

That argument, for what it’s worth, has been trotted out to justify everything from segregation, to fighting gay rights, to objecting to seat belts. Just because people don’t like something they find objectionable doesn’t make them irrational. Saying they are robs them of their agency as humans, and also conveniently obviates them of their responsibility to their community.

“But what is the end game?”

To get to where almost everyone is vaccinated, which is where we are with measles, mumps, rubella, diphtheria, typhoid, etc. It’s not that complicated.

“ I always thought the society's capacity for compassion was bigger than my own.”

Man, me too. If you had asked me in 2019 if there would be a controversy about adding one more vaccination to the roster of vaccines we give almost everyone (and invest billions in encouraging and distributing), I would have said, “no way - in most of the world, most people see vaccines as something that’s important to help themselves and their community “. In 1947 there was a smallpox outbreak in NYC and millions of people showed up to get vaccinated because it was the right thing to do to protect their community. Their compassion was for others.

To be clear, I don’t think people who don’t want to get vaccinated are monsters or evil. They don’t need to be vilified. No, they’re more in the realm of the person in the community who once in a while has a drink too many and drives home when they shouldnt - probably nothing bad will happen, but it shows a real lack of personal responsibility for their impact on others.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by aakresearch on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:50AM (#29427344)
Thank you for the civil answer. I found enough in it to agree with and upvote.

> That argument, for what it’s worth, has been trotted out to justify everything ...

It may be a tired argument, but it doesn't make it false. Sometimes people really do have deep convictions they cannot be rationalized from. Looks like I do, and I'm not happy about it. Only it was never a problem before covid. I was brought up in the spirit of never asking for help or claiming any deficiency until you absolutely, positively, completely unable to handle the situation on your own. Also you must be sure that who you ask is able and willing to provide such help. I thought society progressed enough to tolerate conscientious objection of sorts. Turns out I was wrong. I struggled to keep up and cried for help, first time in my life - and received a good lesson to never ask for compassion again.

> Personal choices have impacts.

They certainly do. I just disagree that it is purely personal. The other side absolves itself from any consequences of the choice pushed upon individual, while being very happy to trump on them if the "natural" impact of "inferior" choice is not bad enough.

> people have been so pushed around by these horrible, unreasonable asks

I haven't said that. Some may very well be reasonable, but it is very hard to see in the pile of punitive-only measures.

Well, at least I have tried to explain how some people, myself included, see and feel in the situation. I'm getting more hints of my inability to communicate this, and nobody in a position to influence the measures gives any consideration to it. This is why I stand with my belief that the side-effect of "where almost everyone is vaccinated" will be not what these people are expecting, in a cruel and unusual way.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by mattzito on Sunday December 05, 2021 @11:36AM (#29450503)
“ it is very hard to see in the pile of punitive-only measures.”

Aka unreasonable. Which sort of makes the point. But also - it’s tough for me to be civil when your argument is, “why isn’t anyone taking my feelings into account?”, when that has literally never been the standard for anything related to a common good. I don’t care how you feel about being allowed to drive drunk, because it’s dangerous to others. I don’t care if you don’t want to allow minorities to live in your neighborhood, they have the right to live wherever they want. And I don’t care if you don’t want to get one more vaccination on top of the 5+ we require for work and/or school, it is part of participating in a functional society.

If no one hears you “crying out for help”, think of how the people whose lives have been affected by this disease feel, knowing that there are people who COULD be helping but don’t want to.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by aakresearch on Sunday December 05, 2021 @06:56PM (#29454592)
Sorry, I seem to have mistook passive-aggressive for civil.

My point is not that anyone should care how I feel, in particular. I only give it out here, on a semi-anonymous forum, never IRL.

The point is, quite the sizeable proportion of people feel like that, and it is a pain for them which they won't forget or forgive, even if they choose to submit to demands. In fact, many voluntarily vaccinated people feel exactly the same, for them cooperation with any future government initiatives is out of question now. It doesn't invalidate the pain of those catching or dying from the disease, it just another pain in it's own right.

"Common good" cannot be built on pain, history is littered with unsuccessful attempts. Governments all around the world are choosing to ignore this (proving them incompetent) for some reason, and in doing so they may find themselves very unpleasantly surprised. Unless this is the end game they are looking for (proving them evil), but that would be too much of a conspiracy to suggest.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by ajsnigrutin on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:51PM (#29423942)
We could do that for smoking too, but since smoking is a choice, we let people smoke and die. Why not do the same with the vaccines? As with smoking, the unvaccinated are taking all the risks.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by mattzito on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:03PM (#29424111)
Except that the resources that are going to care for the unvaccinated might block someone who is vaccinated from needed medical care. It also increases the amount of exposure someone who IS vaccinated needs to contend with, and as is mentioned over and over again, vaccines are imperfect. A colleague of mine has an elderly father who is vaccinated and in the ICU with Covid. The odds are much higher that he was infected by an unvaccinated person.

Also smoking is a terrible example - we tax cigarettes highly to discourage smoking because it’s a drag on our medical system. We ban the act of smoking in a wide variety of locations because it has an impact on other peoples health. Some buildings even disallow people to smoke in their private homes, and some cities disallow smoking in offices. We put restrictions on almost every aspect of smoking because it doesn’t only affect the smoker.

[dead]
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by lxgr on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:53PM (#29424725)
Surely you can‘t be comparing administering a vaccine (which has much fewer adverse effects than the disease of which it prevents severe outcomes) to euthanasia?
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by mattzito on Thursday December 02, 2021 @07:18PM (#29424950)
Aside from the absurdity of comparing recommended vaccination as a responsible social welfare act to the murder of children, the comparison isn’t even apt. My point was about short-term and critical healthcare resources, and the eugenics argument was about long term waste of societal resources. If anything, the smoking comparison is a little more apt because smokers ARE long term drains on societal resources. But still no one is arguing about killing smokers.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by Root_Denied on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:20PM (#29424351)
It has been happening for smoking, at least in some places. Speaking from experience in the US:

Smoking sections in restaurants have all but disappeared, taxes have increased on cigarettes dramatically, warning labels have been placed on boxes/cartons, and so on.

The process has been to try and remove second-hand smoke from those areas where it might affect non-smokers. Traveling abroad to China and Hong Kong a couple years ago it was almost unbearable dealing with people smoking everywhere.

Similar to how as a non-smoker my health risk is non-negligible being exposed to second-hand smoke, so too is my health at risk by unvaccinated individuals running around with higher viral loads increasing the chance and rate of breakthrough infections, and also increased risk of future mutations that could potentially bring about another pandemic.

Very clearly with smoking we've been moving towards a system where you can make whatever health choices you want as long as you aren't impacting the health of others - why should it be any different for vaccines of any kind?

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:39PM (#29424576)
<<Very clearly with smoking we've been moving towards a system where you can make whatever health choices you want as long as you aren't impacting the health of others - why should it be any different for vaccines of any kind?

I think we have long established that just me existing is not something people are willing to tolerate. Hell, just my presence impacts the life of others; sometimes even in a negative way. There is even a system to deal with issues like that. It is called civil law.

But why do we stop at smoking? Why aren't we going after farts and methane. After all, did you know that methane gas poisoning can cause death? Surely, if we researched it a little more, we would maybe find out that it causes cancer of something.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by Brybry on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:20PM (#29424360)
In Louisiana we don't let people smoke in lots of places.

No smoking in schools, no smoking in restaurants, no smoking in workplaces, no smoking in public buildings.

Is that not similar to Germany disallowing unvaccinated (and not naturally immune) from non-essential indoor shopping/leisure activities? Or requiring testing for employees who are not vaccinated/naturally immune?

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by kelnos on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:18PM (#29424325)
Aside from the dangers of secondhand smoke (which we have laws to limit the impact of), you can't "catch" smoking from someone else. Unless they force-feed you cigarettes until you get addicted, anyway.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by rafaelero on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:11PM (#29424219)
I guess the main difference is that covid patients can clog UIT very quickly and there isn't a lot that can be done beforehand. Smokers come in a more predictable and easier to manage way.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by rixed on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:32PM (#29424491)
> the unvaccinated are taking all the risks.

Not if they saturate the health system and you need it for something else.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by inkblotuniverse on Thursday December 02, 2021 @07:13PM (#29424903)
What are you going to do about the 50%+ of americans who are oversaturated with fat and sugar, and the massive drain they put on the health system?
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by rixed on Thursday December 02, 2021 @08:05PM (#29425357)
Obesity is costly and deadly, no doubt about that. But it is not saturating the health system as in filling up all available life support equipments.

Also, obesity "epidemic" is slow, therefore easy to manage, compared to the covid epidemic that is governed by power laws.

Finally, there is no vaccine against obesity.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by ajsnigrutin on Friday December 03, 2021 @05:14AM (#29428422)
This is only true, because we've built enough rooms and trained and hired enough teams of people to take care of fat people. In my country, nurses are still paid more working as store clerks than in hospitals, so yeah...

And if many countries can mandate curfews, lockdowns, mandatory quarantenes etc., why not ban sugary foods, sugary drinks, fast food, etc.?

I mean.. I'm against any sort of bans, but generally, more people die from being fat than from covid itself.... if every life matters, why no theirs?

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by rixed on Friday December 03, 2021 @11:20AM (#29431687)
My best guess is that the power law governing covid epidemics growth poses a greater threat (in terms of costs and casualties) than slow evolving obesity crisis.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by mattzito on Thursday December 02, 2021 @07:55PM (#29425266)
I guess we are pretty lucky that we don’t all have heart attacks simultaneously or it could be a real drag on the hospitals. But yes, the risks and concerns are absolutely equal between those two scenarios.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by poszlem on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:51PM (#29424697)
What do you need your health system for other than treating the sick?
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by MauranKilom on Thursday December 02, 2021 @07:20PM (#29424974)
...are you trying to say that unvaccinated people who catch covid are literally the only people that ever get sick of anything? I'm at a loss here...
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by poszlem on Thursday December 02, 2021 @07:43PM (#29425173)
That's because you apparently can't read. The only thing I said was that treating sick people is why we have the healthcare system. If you think treating COVID patients is too much just triage differently and lower the priority, treat more important things instead. Don't force me to get a medical procedure against my will for the sake of the government healthcare infrastructure.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by MauranKilom on Thursday December 02, 2021 @07:53PM (#29425254)
I can read words, but not minds. You asked a rhethorical question that didn't illustrate your position in the slightest. If you wanted to say "let people with COVID die on the streets so I can remain unvaccinated" then please just say that.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by runarberg on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:29PM (#29423686)
I do think it is important to use the correct terminology here. This disease and the vaccines are already a huge spread of misinformation, so lets expand on the “sure” bit from this sentence a little. It is saying quite a lot:

I don’t think any expert nor any public health department is working with the goal of eradication in mind. So we should acknowledge the fact that these vaccines will probably not eradicate COVID. We will have people getting sick from COVID and we will have more COVID variants for the foreseeable future. Even after most people have been thoroughly vaccinated. And given the slow global spread of vaccines we will also probably see more lockdown measures to slow the spread of the virus beyond the current vaccine capabilities.

Now that said, remember that with the vaccines:

> we can make the virus largely irrelevant in terms of its impact on peoples lives. We can reduce the number of people who suffer long term consequences, the number of deaths, and the load on hospitals. We can make it harder for new, more dangerous, variants to arise.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by VoodooJuJu on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:55PM (#29424001)
>I don’t think any expert nor any public health department is working with the goal of eradication in mind

I believe I speak for many when I say, "I have no idea what the experts' have in mind" (and that's not a good thing).

So they're trying hard to get everyone vaccinated - a noble goal, perhaps, as our current roster of vaccines diminish symptoms and greatly reduce hospitalization and fatality rates. But..."Stop the spread, get vaccinated"...what? Like the parent said, all of the currently-approved intramuscular Covid-19 vaccines have proven to have a negligible effect on transmission rate.

Early on, experts probably made an educated guess or wish that these vaccines would be sterilizing and started information campaigns on this premise. When this turned out to be not true, their "Stop the spread, get vaccinated" became "You unvaccinated are the problem, you are holding us back, and you will be locked down immediately". Rather than address their mistake, rather than open up transparently, they doubled down on the lie. Not a good way to build trust.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by tchalla on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:35PM (#29424530)
> Like the parent said, all of the currently-approved intramuscular Covid-19 vaccines have proven to have a negligible effect on transmission rate.

Multiple studies show that vaccinated people have lower transmission than unvaccinated.

> In studies conducted before the emergence of the Delta variant, data from multiple studies in different countries suggested that people vaccinated with mRNA COVID-19 vaccines who develop COVID-19 generally have a lower viral load than unvaccinated people.(157, 165-169) This observation may indicate reduced transmissibility, as viral load has been identified as a key driver of transmission.(170) Studies from multiple countries found significantly reduced likelihood of transmission to household contacts from people infected with SARS-CoV-2 who were previously vaccinated for COVID-19.(171-176) For the Delta variant, early data indicate vaccinated and unvaccinated persons infected with Delta have similar levels of viral RNA and culturable virus detected, indicating that some vaccinated people infected with the Delta variant of SARS-CoV-2 may be able to transmit the virus to others.(163, 164, 177-180) However, other studies have shown a more rapid decline in viral RNA and culturable virus in fully vaccinated people (96, 177, 180-182). One study observed that Delta infection in fully vaccinated persons was associated with significantly less transmission to contacts than persons who were unvaccinated or partially vaccinated.(181) Together, these studies suggest that vaccinated people who become infected with Delta have potential to be less infectious than infected unvaccinated people.

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/science/science-br...

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by PicassoCTs on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:01PM (#29424086)
We have no real studies, but if covid does "irreversible" small damage, even in vaccinated and that accumulates, it could lead to a life-expectancy drop of 30 years.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-95565-8

We could all dance the Darth Vader after 20 years of Covid even with vaccination. But we certainly will without.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by kelnos on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:20PM (#29424357)
> We could all dance the Darth Vader

Er... what now?

[dead]
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by crooked-v on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:39PM (#29423808)
Obese people don't take up literally the entirety of ICU capacity in heavily-affected areas[1], nor does obesity spread exponentially in a matter of months.

[1]: https://www.newsweek.com/indiana-covid-boy-cancer-treatment-...

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by remarkEon on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:20PM (#29424365)
But obese and overweight people are the strain on the system. That's it, to the tune of 78% of hospitalizations as of March '21[1]. I sincerely doubt the numbers have changed much since then and I'm not going to bother to look for a follow-up study. If people in the United States weren't outrageously unhealthy, this pandemic would not have caused the awfully high number of deaths that it did.

You are totally correct that obesity doesn't spread exponentially, but it exponentially increases your risk of having a bad time with this disease. This will sound harsh, but I'm not really a fan of locking down young healthy people and forcing them to put their lives on pause because so much of America can't go for a run or get in the squat rack. The conversation no one wants to have right now, because were so steeped in arguing over what vaccines - mandated or not - can or cannot do, is one about how we actually get Americans to shed some weight and eat better.

Ironically, closing the gyms "because covid" will make this problem worse.

[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2021/03/08/covid-cdc-study-finds-roughl...