News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by pezezin on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @09:13PM (#29399873)
I'm not a native English speaker either, and my guess is that the poster is using the singular they, a quite recent trend which I find confusing as hell. So in this case is just a friend of indeterminate gender.
Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by bovermyer on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @09:23PM (#29399944)
Singular "they" is not recent at all. The earliest recorded usage of this form is from 1375 C.E., according to the Oxford English Dictionary.

Further reading: https://public.oed.com/blog/a-brief-history-of-singular-they...

Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by dataflow on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @09:31PM (#29399996)
There's certainly been a recent trend due to people pushing for everyone to use it more, though, which was the parent's point.

Btw, not every usage of singular they is equally commonplace. e.g., "When someone says X, they mean Y" is a pretty typical sentence, whereas "My child told me they wanted this toy" is quite jarring in comparison. And then you have sentences like "My boss told me they preferred X" that people try to avoid in order to avoid potential ambiguity.

Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by phillc73 on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @02:46AM (#29401667)
> "My child told me they wanted this toy" is quite jarring in comparison.

Seems perfectly normal to me. I would use this form if not naming my child, usually speaking to people who didn't know me, my child or my personal life very well.

However, if the child is named, then "they" would be odd. E.g. "David told me they wanted this toy" versus "David told me he wanted this toy."

Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by maratc on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @05:26AM (#29402458)
> I would use this form if not naming my child, usually speaking to people who didn't know me, my child or my personal life very well.

There's a potential for ambiguity: we aren't sure "they" is a reference to the child.

"Early in the morning some people with toys passed by the house. My child told me they wanted this toy."

Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by Liquid_Fire on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @06:51AM (#29402859)
Same ambiguity exists with he/she. Perfectly unambiguous language is rarely practically achievable.

"Early in the morning, a man with toys passed by the house. My child told me he wanted this toy."

Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by BoxOfRain on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @05:29AM (#29402471)
I have the same distaste for moral busybodies that most on HN do, but I tend to use 'they' because the alternative expressions for when gender is unknown or irrelevant such as 's/he' or 'he/she' and similar are in my opinion a lot more jarring in written text. It's not necessarily a politically-motivated choice, I think it's often simply along the lines of 'this is the least awkward construct available to us'.
Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by ptmcc on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @10:42PM (#29400407)
All of those uses have been common in standard American English for decades if not longer. Singular they is nothing new at all.
Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by dataflow on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @10:47PM (#29400436)
> Singular they is nothing new at all.

As if I claimed it was?

Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by emodendroket on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @11:05PM (#29400535)
That is the implication of calling it a trend.
Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by pezezin on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @01:23AM (#29401249)
Let me clarify what I wanted to say with "recent trend":

Singular they to refer to a hypothetical or unspecified person is very normal, any fluent speaker of English, native or not, uses it frequently.

But singular they to refer to an specific person is not so common. I have never anybody who speaks like that, and I have met many people in my life. Maybe it has been used for decades in some dialects, but I only started to notice it this year, with all the push for non-gendered, non-binary language and the like. In my book, that's a trend.

Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by emodendroket on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @03:02AM (#29401756)
For usages like "Robert likes to clean their house" I could see this, but in an example like this with "my friend" I don't find it to be particularly modish.
Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by dataflow on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @05:57AM (#29402613)
No. Not only does "trend" not imply "new" (X rising from 10 at t = 0 to 11, 12, 13, 14, ... year-by-year is obviously a trend and clearly doesn't imply X was ever 0??) but I in fact quite explicitly said that the recent trend is "people pushing for everyone to use it more". Notice I did not say "anew", I did not say "for the first time", I said more. You're putting words in my mouth by reading it as "new". In fact the entire point of the comment was to point out that it is not new but that there has been a trend of it becoming more prevalent.
Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by WalterBright on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @02:17AM (#29401505)
Common? I've never heard any of them.
Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by BoorishBears on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @04:02AM (#29402058)
You've never heard someone use "they" in reference to a singular person?!

Sometimes you don't even know who the person referenced, so how do you refer to them?

"I don't know who's in charge but they could learn a thing or two"

"Someone is making a bunch of noise and they had better stop it"

"My friend told me his coworker was hurt. I hope they're ok"

Would you really use he or she instead of they in all of these situations? Like just pull a gender out of a hat?

Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by WalterBright on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @01:49PM (#29407549)
> You've never heard someone use "they" in reference to a singular person?!

Not until the last couple years.

I often heard "man" or "him" used in a gender neutral manner, and whether it was neutral or not came from the context. "Guy" usually referred to males, but sometimes was gender neutral, again from the context.

In the late 70s there was a move to things like "postman => postal worker", "chairman => chairwoman or chairperson", "bowman => archer", "stewardess => flight attendant", etc. But never "they" as singular.

Sometimes one saw "his or hers", "he or she", etc., but rarely as it is kinda clunky to use.

Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by SiempreViernes on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @04:27AM (#29402175)
Presumably they've only heard the variant "My friend told me his coworker was hurt. I hope he or she is ok". /sarcasm
Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by ryanmercer on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @06:41AM (#29402806)
>There's certainly been a recent trend due to people pushing for everyone to use it more, though, which was the parent's point.

I am 36, and have been using it that way my entire life?

Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by torgoguys on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @04:28PM (#29409354)
I'm in my 40s, living in Wisconsin most of the time, and all of those usages of singular they have been in use for as long as I can remember. I find none of them jarring.

This from a person who still has a hard time remembering to address a specific person as "they" when they say that's their pronoun (but I'm working on it!).

Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by torgoguys on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @05:21PM (#29409911)
>You're saying even in the previous century you frequently heard others refer to their own child as "they"? And you didn't find it jarring one bit?

Sorry, too deep to reply directly to your comment which is a sibling of this, but, that is correct. I don't recall a person referring to their own child as "they" as ever being odd if I don't know that person's child and the speaker didn't otherwise gender the child.

It would sound slightly odd if that person said "My SON went to the park before they ate lunch" but "My CHILD went to the park before they ate lunch" has always sounded normal as far as I can recall.

Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by dataflow on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @05:37PM (#29410071)
Well that's news to me. Interesting to hear, thanks!
Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by dataflow on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @05:03PM (#29409716)
> all of those usages of singular they have been in use for as long as I can remember. I find none of them jarring.

You're saying even in the previous century you frequently heard others refer to their own child as "they"? And you didn't find it jarring one bit?

Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by emodendroket on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @11:07PM (#29400544)
The other guy had a bunch of old citations but I'll say that for a native speaker singular they is so well assimilated that one has to consciously go out of one's way to avoid it altogether.
Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by gumby on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @11:28PM (#29400670)
Is the lack of distinction of number or case in second person pronouns (they are all pronounced and spelt “you”) also confusing as hell? This usage only became ubiquitous in the mid 20th century.

(Is my conservative use of spelt (not the grain) equally confusing?

Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by pezezin on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @02:10AM (#29401471)
I was sure someone would ask me abound the second person. In my opinion, the second person is less ambiguous, because in a normal phrase who is the first person and who is the second person is very obvious, even if they are plural.

Still, it seems to be confusing enough that some dialects developed their own second person plural pronouns like "y'all" or "you guys".

Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by saalweachter on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @05:51AM (#29402570)
Interestingly, the second person pronouns went the same way -- we dropped the second person singular in favor of using the second person plural exclusively.

So it's kind of amusing that people continually invent new second person plurals when, from a certain angle, that's the one we've got.

I wonder if in another hundred years we'll be arguing about "they all" versus "thall".

Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by hn_go_brrrrr on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @01:24AM (#29401253)
The lack of number on "you" can indeed be rather confusing. The lack of case is fine. Unless the sentence is specifically constructed to be ambiguous, I've never missed cases in English.
Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by pezezin on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @07:09PM (#29410853)
English pronouns definitely have case, e.g. I/me/my/mine

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_personal_pronouns#Basi...

Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by hn_go_brrrrr on Thursday December 02, 2021 @01:54AM (#29413303)
They have distinct forms for some of the cases. There are many that are indistinguishable.
Re:Overdue library book returned more than 110 years later by pezezin on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:07AM (#29414718)
That happens in any language with declensions. I mean, look at a table of Latin declensions, and depending of the declension and number, some cases have different endings, some cases don't.

Anyway, it's interesting that in the European languages that lost grammatical case, the pronouns are only words that keep them.