News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Music is a negative superstimulus for speech (2020) by munificent on Monday November 29, 2021 @05:31PM (#29386143)
This is a pretty interesting theory.

1. The listener determines the meaning of what the speaker said.

2. The listener determines the emotional significance of the meaning of what the speaker said.

3. The listener determines whether of not the speaker's speech is spontaneous.

4. The listener determines their belief about the truth of what the speaker said, but, the amount of effort put into this determination is proportional to the perceived level of spontaneity in the speaker's speech.

5. The listener responds to the speaker, where their response includes an indication of their belief about the truth of what the speaker said.

I think the truth-value part of this might be off track. Here's a slightly different hypothesis:

Speech carries two separate signals: information and emotion. The former is world-state data, and the latter is signal about the emotional state of the speaker. In a social species like humans, both are critical.

We might process those two channels of data with different parts of our brain even though the source signal has them merged together into one single sound. Imagine an audio processing pipeline that strips the literal informational content out and shunts it one way and takes the emotional affect another way.

The informational content needs to be processed actively with full attention from our frontal cortex. We have to pay attention to it. We don't seem to absorb detailed information "in the background" well. I don't know anyone who can, say, read a book and listen to a non-fiction podcast at the same time.

Emotional content doesn't need our active attention. It's something we can absorb passively. We use words like "feel", "vibe", "mood", and "ambience" to describe it.

OK, so you've got a speech-like sound that contains information and emotion. How do you decide how much attention to pay to it? Information is more likely to be useful if it's fresh, so sounding spontaneous is a positive signal for information content.

As the author supposes, music is a negative superstimulus for that. It's audio that contains no informational content and only emotion, which it telegraphs by sounding extremely rehearsed (repetitive rhythm, wide melodic swings). That lets our brain know that we don't have to pay active, logical attention to it. That's pleasant because it frees us to think about what we like while absorbing the music emotionally in the background.

This helps explain why some like me do like listening to music while programming, but not music with lyrics. Non-lyrical music helps me focus my attention on code because it sends a signal that I don't have to pay attention to it.

This may also explain why religions, cults, and demogogues use such sing-song like speaking styles: it encourages the audience to mentally switch off and not think as critically about what they are hearing as they might otherwise.

Re:Music is a negative superstimulus for speech (2020) by shkkmo on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @12:59AM (#29389406)
This theory seems naive, simplistic and flat out wrong.

1) This hand waves away a key part conversations, the process of establishing sufficient shared meaning to pass information. This process is most obvious in its absence from comedic conversations where two characters talk past eachother (e.g. who's on first.)

4) The percieved "spontaneity" of a statement does not have any fixed relationship with the effort we put into verifying the truth of that statement. It's effects are minimal compared to our perception of the intent of the speaker in making the statement.

5) This is a mandatory part of conversations? I extremely rarely see people respond to statements is such manner.

Conversations are diverse and conversationalists follow many different models, sometimes even within a conversation.

As far as I can tell, the Author is so set on the "music is a super stimulus of speech" that they have post-hoc invented an unrealistic model to make their hypothesis work.

In reality, music, like most art, exploits a wide variety of perceptual and cognitive quirks while referencing a shared set of cultural experiences. Trying to boil this down to "music is a super stimulus of conversational speech" is simplistic and boring.

This is just bad pseudo-psychology from someone who wrote a whole "science" book on the topic without actually doing any actual science.

Re:Music is a negative superstimulus for speech (2020) by mym1990 on Monday November 29, 2021 @07:28PM (#29387244)
Wouldn't your hypothesis undermine research that suggests the important pieces of communication are non-verbal(7% words, 38% tone, 55% body language...roughly depending on which research you use).

Also, I don't see a way to actively separate information and emotion while someone is communicating to you while still being able to fully understand...that would just mean you are not paying attention to at least one of the signals...but maybe that IS what is happening when people pay more attention to body language and tone over the actual content.

Re:Music is a negative superstimulus for speech (2020) by munificent on Monday November 29, 2021 @07:45PM (#29387394)
We don't have good words for talking about this stuff (ironically), but I didn't intend to imply that the emotional aspect was less important than informational. Maybe "logical" would have been a better word for the latter. It's all information.

Perhaps a better way to think of the split is that some of the audio content needs to be processed deliberately and sequentially—it has grammatical structure, words that need to be decoded, semantics, etc. It requires processing from the part of our brain that needs to deliberately pay attention to things. It's like reading or doing math.

Meanwhile, some of it can be processed more intuitively. It's where we pick up tone and emotional intent. We will absorb that even if we don't deliberately focus on it—you can tell that someone is angry when they speak even if you don't know their language.

Of course, understanding both of those requires integrating them together. The lexical content of their speech might tell you why they feel a certain way or what they feel that way about.

But one way to look at music is that it's a sound artifact designed to deliberately convey "I'm almost all non-grammatical, it's OK to not focus on me."

Again, of course, this is all pure conjecture.

Re:Music is a negative superstimulus for speech (2020) by gjygj on Monday November 29, 2021 @07:56PM (#29387459)
> important pieces of communication are non-verbal

That can't possibly be true for actual information (in the Shannon sense).

When you say to someone "go to the grocery store and buy a soda", these words can't be just 7% of the total information. Or put another way, what exactly do you communicate in the other 93% (13 times more information)

Re:Music is a negative superstimulus for speech (2020) by mym1990 on Monday November 29, 2021 @09:23PM (#29388102)
I guess the short answer is: it depends. What if there are 5 people in the room and it’s not clear who the command is to? What if the person asking for the soda is crying? Surely you wouldn’t just get the soda and walk away…

In a sense, there is information to be had, whether or not you want or need to have it is totally up to you and perhaps the situation. Low stakes situations it probably matters less, negotiating with something big on the line would be a different story.

I think if humans always told the truth or could always express themselves fully in words, then yes, verbal communication would be a bigger chunk. But the truth is that humans can hide behind words or not know quite the right way to express themselves, but it’s much harder to do with tone and body movements.

Re:Music is a negative superstimulus for speech (2020) by sseagull on Monday November 29, 2021 @08:04PM (#29387510)
Hard to quantify, but how that sentence is said and the corresponding body language dramatically changes the meaning.

Is the person smiling? Yelling? Pointing angrily? Making a motion like they are thirsty? Making puppy eyes? Laughing like it is an inside joke?

It can change from a mere friendly request to a demand possibly backed up by violence.

Re:Music is a negative superstimulus for speech (2020) by gjygj on Monday November 29, 2021 @08:14PM (#29387579)
Sure, but how many bits of information are in those modifiers you mentioned? Maybe you can modulate it in 200 different ways?

Surely way less than in the actual sentence, since you have millions of different posibilities for the words: go/store/soda

Re:Music is a negative superstimulus for speech (2020) by mym1990 on Monday November 29, 2021 @09:28PM (#29388154)
I think you’re missing out on the almost infinite possibilities of how body language and tone can give off different moods or intentions of a person. But these cues aren’t often processed in a literal sense, our brain can pick things up without us knowing exactly why something is wrong or different, it just is. It’s very intuitive based I think.
Re:Music is a negative superstimulus for speech (2020) by gjygj on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @02:50AM (#29389915)
In that case a transcript of a conversation would be almost worthless since it's depriving us of the body language or the tone.
Re:Music is a negative superstimulus for speech (2020) by mym1990 on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @01:34PM (#29395679)
Yes, I would say if you gave me a random transcript of a conversation, it would be pretty worthless without any additional context. We are talking about active communication here, not a record of communication happening at some point in time.
Re:Music is a negative superstimulus for speech (2020) by shkkmo on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @01:15AM (#29389479)
There is a huge amount of nonverbal information that would be accompanying that statement.

The speaker's motivation for that statement, the speaker's attitude towards the soda getter, the speaker's attitude towards soda, the implied outcome/motivation for the soda getter, the state of beverage availability and thirst in the immediate vicinity, the proximity of the store...etc

Every time someone says something we have to model what different interpretations imply about the mental state of the speaker, compare that with the recent conversational history, the tone and body language of the speaker (and other listeners), our knowledge of the speaker and the broader context. At the same time, each new statement can cause us to refine our past mental models of the speaker and reinterpret the interpretations based on those models.

Re:Music is a negative superstimulus for speech (2020) by gjygj on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @02:55AM (#29389935)
The word "huge" carefully avoid quantifying the amount of information.

Imagine a conversation with zero non-words information (a transcript).

Now one with zero words (mime game) .

Which one conveys more information?

Re:Music is a negative superstimulus for speech (2020) by munificent on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @12:58PM (#29395204)
If you're going to make a reductionist argument like this, then consider the byte size of a text transcript versus the byte size of an audio recording of the same speech act. The latter will be orders of magnitude larger. Thus it strictly contains much more information.
Re:Music is a negative superstimulus for speech (2020) by shkkmo on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @10:04AM (#29392860)
That depends on the conversations.

Sometimes you can say far more with a single look than you can with mere words.