Re:Music is a negative superstimulus for speech (2020)
by gjygj on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @02:55AM
(#29389935)
The word "huge" carefully avoid quantifying the amount of information.
Imagine a conversation with zero non-words information (a transcript).
Now one with zero words (mime game) .
Which one conveys more information?
Re:Music is a negative superstimulus for speech (2020)
by munificent on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @12:58PM
(#29395204)
If you're going to make a reductionist argument like this, then consider the byte size of a text transcript versus the byte size of an audio recording of the same speech act. The latter will be orders of magnitude larger. Thus it strictly contains much more information.
The speaker's motivation for that statement, the speaker's attitude towards the soda getter, the speaker's attitude towards soda, the implied outcome/motivation for the soda getter, the state of beverage availability and thirst in the immediate vicinity, the proximity of the store...etc
Every time someone says something we have to model what different interpretations imply about the mental state of the speaker, compare that with the recent conversational history, the tone and body language of the speaker (and other listeners), our knowledge of the speaker and the broader context. At the same time, each new statement can cause us to refine our past mental models of the speaker and reinterpret the interpretations based on those models.