News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by boomboomsubban on Sunday November 28, 2021 @12:18PM (#29370706)
>The piece doesn’t go deep into detail but it shows that the entertainment industry lawyer doesn’t regret going after the site and its founders, despite the mixed result.

That lawyer is probably the person who has made the most money off of TPB. Of course they don't regret it.

Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by filmgirlcw on Sunday November 28, 2021 @02:28PM (#29372059)
I was at a Grammy luncheon a number of years ago and I somehow wound up seated with all of the entertainment attorneys for the labels/recording industry/whatever and it was a very interesting/bizarre conversation. I’ve spent much of my adult life (and even pre-adult life), speaking out and writing about the idiocy of those various campaigns to shut down P2P, DRM, etc., and then I was at this industry luncheon with some very nice people who believe the exact opposite of me. Interesting and civil discussions ensued (I was the odd-woman out, both for my position and because I didn’t drive to the Beverly Hills Hotel in a $200,000 car), but I got the sense that as misguided as I personally think they are, many of the lawyers honestly think they are doing the right thing to try to protect against so-called infringement the ways that they do. I’m sure the money is definitely part of it (again, I took an Uber to the luncheon. They had valet service for their $200,000 cars), but I don’t think that’s most of it to be honest.

It was helpful for me to meet and talk with people who have the opposite opinion and perspective of me. Not because we changed each other’s minds (my mind wasn’t changed), but because I saw that these were people who really thought they were protecting and fighting for the rights and protections of artists and creators. As I said, it didn’t change my opinion about how misguided and ultimately harmful those fights have been (especially towards the parties they want to protect), but I did at least see that not all of them are evil boogeyman who just want to get money.

Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by akudha on Sunday November 28, 2021 @03:09PM (#29372449)
I personally think they are, many of the lawyers honestly think they are doing the right thing

They have tons of money, they’re highly educated, well connected individuals, are they not? All they have to do is spend one Saturday reading up. With the money they have, they can even hire researchers to do some original research for them. My guess is that they don’t want to know. Money has a way of suppressing one’s good side.

I am having a hard time sympathizing with these lawyers. They go after students, poor people for downloading a song or two. They’re the reason for the sorry state of copyright laws

Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by filmgirlcw on Sunday November 28, 2021 @03:23PM (#29372603)
I don’t disagree, but having pressed some of them on those exact issues (not all at that luncheon), it really is similar to talking to district attorneys who often prosecute low-level drug crimes (which I personally find even more egregious). These are people who really are convinced they are doing the right thing. As I said, this doesn’t change my opinion, but it does make having a conversation more productive.
Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by kf6nux on Sunday November 28, 2021 @03:44PM (#29372804)
The people in the USA practicing eugenics thought they were doing the right thing. The people in the USA creating concentration camps for the Japanese (a.k.a. internment camps) thought they were doing the right thing.

Belief in yourself and your cause is irrelevant. Most people have that regardless of what they do.

Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by akudha on Sunday November 28, 2021 @04:13PM (#29373096)
I can sympathize with someone who isn’t educated or living in a rural area (cut off from the world) or raised in a cult etc. I really can’t believe the lawyers who went to Ivy League colleges are that naive. They’re much smarter than an average guy like me.

Doesn’t mean they are evil, just that they’re paid enough to set aside any moral concerns they have.

Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by kmeisthax on Sunday November 28, 2021 @05:29PM (#29373769)
The legal profession self-selects for people who think this way, for a number of various reasons.

1. If you disagree with the base assumptions of copyright, you are going to misunderstand the law and fail your LSAT/bar exam/etc. You will be blinded by "it's just to keep big companies afloat" to notice the actual rules of things like fair use.

2. If you get a law license but disagree with the base assumptions of the law, you are going to be at a financial disadvantage by refusing to represent clients whose politics disagrees with yours.[0]

3. If you choose to represent copyright defendants, you can only do so to the extent that there is a legal argument that they can make. It is illegal for a lawyer to aid a client in the commission of a crime... and if your legal career is based around the idea that something shouldn't be a crime, then you will need to hold your tongue and pick your battles a lot.

4. If you somehow jump through those hoops and competently represent clients... you probably have sacrificed on your "abolish copyright" ideology a fair bit.

[0] Remember that at this point you are probably deep in student debt - your legal career is predicated on you paying back your loans by charging your clients lots of money.

Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by formerbanker453 on Sunday November 28, 2021 @07:24PM (#29374828)
I think you may be right.

I used to work as a software developer for a banking startup, and a lot of emphasis was placed on things like KYC, AML and "compliance", whatever that is.

Fundamentally, I hated all those things with passion (including how they force everyone to use a bank to transact - and here I am working for a bank), because I don't believe they any institution or government should be forcibly gatekeeping and spying upon anyone's transactions.

It's really hard to work at a place that contradicts your own convictions. When I was fired, it was a relief.

Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by notriddle on Sunday November 28, 2021 @07:56PM (#29375061)
Rich, well-connected anarchists don't become lawyers.
Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by Qub3d on Sunday November 28, 2021 @03:45PM (#29372817)
“It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it.” - Upton Sinclair

Maybe a bit of a truism, but it is a popular quote for a reason

Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by dane-pgp on Sunday November 28, 2021 @03:21PM (#29372573)
> They’re the reason for the sorry state of copyright laws

Blaming lawyers for the state of copyright laws is doing a huge service to the legislators that pass them and the lobbyists who write them.

Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by jessaustin on Sunday November 28, 2021 @03:53PM (#29372911)
...90% of whom are lawyers.
Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by goodpoint on Sunday November 28, 2021 @03:32PM (#29372688)
> They had valet service for their $200,000 cars

> the lawyers honestly think they are doing the right thing

Reminds me of:

“It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it.” - Upton Sinclair

Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by donmcronald on Sunday November 28, 2021 @03:15PM (#29372515)
Most of the piracy sites are super scummy. I can see the appeal in trying to shut them down. I've always wondered how the economics of those setups that push you through a half dozen link shorteners / ad pages with captchas all over the place work. I bet there's ad fraud going on with the captchas being solved for bots that are doing less than respectable things.

Look at Kim Dotcom / Mega Upload for an example of who the big winners are in the piracy space. Some of it is big business, so it's easy to see the lawyers' side. I'd still consider myself pro piracy because it creates a floor in terms of how bad big companies can treat us, but there are some participants that deserve to be chased by lawyers.

Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by superkuh on Sunday November 28, 2021 @03:52PM (#29372896)
No. Most of the piracy sites that are public and well known are super scummy. That is because only that kind of scummy income can protect and justify the exposure. Semi-private and private piracy sites are really nice, safe, and have better organization and UI than most big money for profit sites that attempt to distribute the same types of media. What.cd was way less scummy than any large commercial media distribution company.
Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by kmeisthax on Sunday November 28, 2021 @05:34PM (#29373821)
Yes, but there's no guarantee that What.cd[0] remains a charismatic defendant in any scenario where they don't get shut down. Nor should the law be written around protecting charismatic defendants.

The argument against copyright maximalism should not be made on the basis that "nice" pirate sites can exist - in fact, you should advocate for copyright reform or reduction on the basis of the least tolerable, most scummy site that should be allowed to exist.

[0] insert any other non-scummy pirate site here

Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by raxxorrax on Monday November 29, 2021 @06:12AM (#29378467)
True, but the industry has shown that it need the constant threat of piracy. Ebooks and music are already in a bad state again. I guess with VPN becoming more popular due to increased surveillance it can lead to a renaissance of file sharing.
Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by tokai on Sunday November 28, 2021 @04:48PM (#29373378)
People work very hard to not see themselves as a villain - especially when they are just that.
Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by mandmandam on Sunday November 28, 2021 @03:05PM (#29372397)
If their actions are indistinguishable from the actions of evil bogeymen, I do wonder what the real difference is.

I think the truly worst people alive right now are really, really fucking charming and 'nice' to have dinner with in a fancy hotel - they get plenty of practice - but if kindly confronted with undeniable evidence of their harms they would immediately rationalize their actions with bullshit, and get as far from you as possible.

Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by adjkant on Sunday November 28, 2021 @04:36PM (#29373279)
I think the issue here is with the conception of "evil". The one shown in most media is incredibly flawed, and it is why the best villians are the ones that can actually argue their point, make you understand where they are coming from, and potentially even come to their side. People are not evil, they are simply acting as all humans do most of the time: in self preservation of some form. What makes a person appear "evil" is simply the situations they have ended up in and the accompanying beliefs and knowledge.

> but if kindly confronted with undeniable evidence of their harms they would immediately rationalize their actions with bullshit, and get as far from you as possible.

This is not meant to excuse that response, but I do want to point out that it is the rational and "easy" path of response. When people make ideas the core of their personality and survival, threats to those ideas are now personal threats. The path of coming to challenge and change those ideas is a hard road in most cases. It takes a very strong and brave person to change their mind on a core belief.

The better way IMO to approach it is to ensure people don't get caught in the position in the first place. Don't make beliefs the center of yourself, make values the center, and choose them carefully and with nuance. It allows you to change course on beliefs or ideas with much less pain and personal internal sacrifice. That needs to start early though, way before anyone at that table sat down for their meal. It's an education issue, an early one at that.

Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by arthurcolle on Sunday November 28, 2021 @01:48PM (#29371637)
this would be a funny youtube video, have all the RIAA lawyers, this lawyer, then all the haxxor TPB coders, passing around a blunt discussing the state of the industry
Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by emj on Sunday November 28, 2021 @03:12PM (#29372481)
You "don't do drugs" in Sweden so that won't happen, publicly almost everyone is against pot. This might be changing but not in the near future.
Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by Maursault on Sunday November 28, 2021 @05:32PM (#29373798)
FWIW, pot, or cannabis, is not a drug, no more than nutmeg. They're vegetables. Alcohol, on the other hand, is indeed a drug. So, no drinkers in Sweden? It always sounded like a pretty nice place to me, and now it sounds even more so.
Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by 1_player on Sunday November 28, 2021 @07:47PM (#29375007)
As someone that has smoked most of his 20s away, your comment is absolute misinformed bollocks.
Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by Maursault on Monday November 29, 2021 @03:54PM (#29385162)
Accurate, you mean, though one could say delta-9-tetrahydrocannabinol is a drug. Also, wine and beer? Beverages, not alcohol, though they usually contain alcohol. It seems unimportant, but getting things right is critical.

I mentioned nutmeg intentionally. 10g of nutmeg will cause quite like LSD states, and I'm not sure why, but no one anywhere considers nutmeg a drug. I'm also not sure how this was discovered as consuming even half a gram of nutmeg would be a pretty amazing feat.

Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says by boomboomsubban on Monday November 29, 2021 @06:07PM (#29386536)
From Wikipedia

>A drug is any chemical substance that causes a change in an organism's physiology or psychology when consumed.

So yes, both nutmeg and pot are plants and drugs when consumed with the right dosage. Nobody considers nutmeg a drug as it's rarely used as one in their presence.

And it was probably discovered when nutmeg was used for food preservation.