Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says
by superkuh on Sunday November 28, 2021 @03:52PM
(#29372896)
No. Most of the piracy sites that are public and well known are super scummy. That is because only that kind of scummy income can protect and justify the exposure. Semi-private and private piracy sites are really nice, safe, and have better organization and UI than most big money for profit sites that attempt to distribute the same types of media. What.cd was way less scummy than any large commercial media distribution company.
Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says
by kmeisthax on Sunday November 28, 2021 @05:34PM
(#29373821)
Yes, but there's no guarantee that What.cd[0] remains a charismatic defendant in any scenario where they don't get shut down. Nor should the law be written around protecting charismatic defendants.
The argument against copyright maximalism should not be made on the basis that "nice" pirate sites can exist - in fact, you should advocate for copyright reform or reduction on the basis of the least tolerable, most scummy site that should be allowed to exist.
[0] insert any other non-scummy pirate site here
Re:“The Pirate Bay can’t be stopped,” co-founder says
by raxxorrax on Monday November 29, 2021 @06:12AM
(#29378467)
True, but the industry has shown that it need the constant threat of piracy. Ebooks and music are already in a bad state again. I guess with VPN becoming more popular due to increased surveillance it can lead to a renaissance of file sharing.
Look at Kim Dotcom / Mega Upload for an example of who the big winners are in the piracy space. Some of it is big business, so it's easy to see the lawyers' side. I'd still consider myself pro piracy because it creates a floor in terms of how bad big companies can treat us, but there are some participants that deserve to be chased by lawyers.