Re:Casting pig iron at the Iroquois smelter
by kodah on Saturday November 27, 2021 @11:22AM
(#29361258)
Evil feels like the wrong word and oddly placed at that.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Casting pig iron at the Iroquois smelter
by DenisM on Saturday November 27, 2021 @07:02PM
(#29364862)
It's a direct reference to the essay called "Photographing Evil" that is discussed in the next paragraph. If you want to bridge the gap from your article to someone else's it helps to use the same terminology.
It's a bit awkward, though, and I would use the word sinister myself as a compromise, but I certainly see why they did what they did.
Re:Casting pig iron at the Iroquois smelter
by kodah on Saturday November 27, 2021 @09:43PM
(#29365724)
I guess the summary fails to explain why this qualifies as evil as opposed to early industry or lack of knowledge. I tried to look up whether the industry knew whether these were harmful fumes and whether there were reasonable alternatives to iron production back then but couldn't find anything.
Re:Casting pig iron at the Iroquois smelter
by DenisM on Sunday November 28, 2021 @02:54AM
(#29367045)
You seem to believe that evil requires a priori knowledge or intent. I think there is enough wiggle room in that word to allow otherwise.
Merriam Webster offers causing harm or injury to someone which would fit the article.
Re:Casting pig iron at the Iroquois smelter
by kodah on Sunday November 28, 2021 @12:28PM
(#29370808)
That definition is a bit dated. Evil as a result does not relate to evil with intent, and using it in that context is odd in modern times.
To make my example a bit more concise, if your financial planner lost you money on the market would you ever tell them, "You did an evil thing"? Of course not, but it did result in harm to you, regardless of their intent.
Re:Casting pig iron at the Iroquois smelter
by ivanech on Saturday November 27, 2021 @11:42PM
(#29366213)
To clarify, it's "evil" as in the problem of evil [1] – not necessarily malicious but instead anything involving suffering. This is also how "evil" is used in the essay Photographing Evil by Robert Adams.
Re:Casting pig iron at the Iroquois smelter
by mmazing on Saturday November 27, 2021 @06:43PM
(#29364752)
I felt the substance of the message more than the details.
Does it really detract from the essence of it? Sometimes just the realization of the underlying meaning is all that is needed to be beautiful, even if the words aren't perfect.
Re:Casting pig iron at the Iroquois smelter
by afandian on Saturday November 27, 2021 @04:57PM
(#29363984)
Seems like a direct reference to William Blake's 'satanic mills'.
Re:Casting pig iron at the Iroquois smelter
by randallsquared on Saturday November 27, 2021 @02:06PM
(#29362514)
Many people equate "evil" and "harmful" implicitly.