Re:Ask HN: How did you learn math notation?
by BeetleB on Thursday November 25, 2021 @12:33PM
(#29343222)
A few points:
1. You're reading a journal article. They will assume you know the notation not just of the broader discipline (e.g. physics/electrical engineering), but of the subdiscipline and at times the subsubdiscipline. Journal papers are explicitly written not to be easy to comprehend by beginners.[1] Notation will be only one problem you'll face.
2. As has been pointed out, this is not a mathematics paper. Mathematicians have their own notation, as do physicists and engineers. As I mentioned in the above bullet, they can have their own notation even in subdisciplines (e.g. circuit folks use "j" for the imaginary number, and semiconductor folks use "i"). There is a lot of overlap in notation amongst these parties, but you should never assume because you know one notation that you'll easily understand the math written by other fields.
3. Most introductory textbooks will explain the basic notation. Unfortunately, I often do find gaps where you go to higher level textbooks and they use notation that they don't explain (i.e. they assume you've seen it before), but is not covered in the prior textbooks.
4. Finally, sorry to say this, but "delta" (the triangle) for representing change is used in almost all sciences and engineering. It was heavily used in my high school as well. If you're struggling with this you really need to read some introductory textbooks in, say, physics.
[1] I'm not kidding. I've spent time in academia and I've complained how obtuse some articles are, and almost universally the response is "We write for other experts, not for new graduate students". One professor took pride at the fact that in his field, one can comprehend only about one page of a paper per day - and this coming from someone who is an expert. These people have issues.
1. You're reading a journal article. They will assume you know the notation not just of the broader discipline (e.g. physics/electrical engineering), but of the subdiscipline and at times the subsubdiscipline. Journal papers are explicitly written not to be easy to comprehend by beginners.[1] Notation will be only one problem you'll face.
2. As has been pointed out, this is not a mathematics paper. Mathematicians have their own notation, as do physicists and engineers. As I mentioned in the above bullet, they can have their own notation even in subdisciplines (e.g. circuit folks use "j" for the imaginary number, and semiconductor folks use "i"). There is a lot of overlap in notation amongst these parties, but you should never assume because you know one notation that you'll easily understand the math written by other fields.
3. Most introductory textbooks will explain the basic notation. Unfortunately, I often do find gaps where you go to higher level textbooks and they use notation that they don't explain (i.e. they assume you've seen it before), but is not covered in the prior textbooks.
4. Finally, sorry to say this, but "delta" (the triangle) for representing change is used in almost all sciences and engineering. It was heavily used in my high school as well. If you're struggling with this you really need to read some introductory textbooks in, say, physics.
[1] I'm not kidding. I've spent time in academia and I've complained how obtuse some articles are, and almost universally the response is "We write for other experts, not for new graduate students". One professor took pride at the fact that in his field, one can comprehend only about one page of a paper per day - and this coming from someone who is an expert. These people have issues.