News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by josh2600 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:56PM (#29321704)
Ok normally I’d just let something like this go but I just have to pull my hair out when I see a comment like this.

The attack surface of software as complicated as a modern operating system (iOS or MacOS, etc.) is simply too large to lockdown without dramatically hurting the user experience (assuming you could actually achieve a lockdown in the first place!!).

Let’s, just for a second, propose that apple went full Monty and locked the whole shebang down with the kind of tech they’d need to resist NSO. That’s more custom silicon, signed binaries everywhere, even fewer per app permissions, literally treating any piece of software running on the device as a potential threat vector even more than they already do. What would this get you?

The BoM cost would go up, a lot. The cost of writing software would go up, a lot. And perhaps worst of all: it would only raise the cost of a chain of exploits, not eradicate it.

Right now a chain of exploits is ~$5M on iOS. What if it was $50M? Would that actually stop a nation state?

I’m sorry but there’s no world where Apple can make perfect security.

Finally, the cost of this lawsuit is a drop in the ocean compared to what they already spend trying to secure the software and hardware in iOS devices.

Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by snowwrestler on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:14PM (#29321951)
You’re not wrong about the impossibility of perfect security.

But Apple is praising and promising to support independent security research in this press release. Meanwhile they have a reputation among independent security researchers for being standoffish, opaque, slow to respond, and even outright hostile in suing Corellium. They settled that suit but the reputation remains.

Apple is the most valuable company in the world. They do not appear to have the best security program in the world. Whatever Citizen Lab can do, Apple should be able to do better; they have a lot more resources and expertise.

I’m not doubting that Apple puts a lot of effort into securing their products. But it seems like they still have significant room for improvement.

Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by concinds on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:55PM (#29322512)
Seconded. There are many, many low hanging fruits that would substantially improve Apple users' security that Apple has not yet implemented, for example delivering Safari updates independently from macOS updates and having a seamless auto-update mechanism equivalent to every other modern browser. Apple repeatedly claims that most malware targets Android, which is true, but it includes Play Store adware and side-loaded malware; if you only take RCE exploits, which are the relevant class of malware here, one could argue Android is as secure, or more secure than iOS. I would argue the latter, given that Safari and iMessage (as well as integrated WebKit webviews, like Apple Music) seem like the primary attack vectors, and the ones used by NSO; and that security updates to those components, unlike the Android equivalents, are delayed to match Apple's preferred iOS release schedule, instead of being autoupdated separately and transparently to the user.
Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by nicce on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @05:50PM (#29324555)
One could also argue, that as Apple is commonly branded as "secure" alternative, and therefore high profile targets are potentially using their products. This might mean that interest is much higher for attackers on that side. They might not care so much about Android. Increased interest and effort means that more likely something is found.

Also, Apple's sandboxing settings and permission managing makes the most malware pretty useless with App store policies (no sideloading), so only RCE exploits are kinda useful.

What it comes to iMessages, that is the most interesting channel with Safari to deliver exploits, iMessage without user interaction and Safari with some. All you need to know is that target is using iPhone. Other non-default applications as target introduces new challenges. iMessage and Safaring being part of OS updates might indicate, that they are handled differently compared to other apps - is security policy same, worse or better? Is there larger attack interface to system by using these apps?

Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by miohtama on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:05PM (#29322633)
Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by jolux on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:23PM (#29323723)
> They do not appear to have the best security program in the world.

By what measure? That they don’t find all the security bugs? Have you seen what iOS exploit chains look like these days? They’re not exactly simple. I think there is literally no amount of money that could be spent that would eliminate all the security bugs in iOS, or Apple would be figuring out how to spend that much right now. So yes, you can always argue that they should spend more, and I’m sure they do spend more every time something like Pegasus happens, but it’s not some grand revelation. This is just how things are.

> Whatever Citizen Lab can do, Apple should be able to do better; they have a lot more resources and expertise.

At the tail, this doesn’t matter. Other people find bugs because there are always more bugs to be found. There will never be a situation where only Apple can find more bugs in its operating system.

Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by rStar on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:11PM (#29321915)
> I’m sorry but there’s no world where Apple can make perfect security

i think everyone knows that perfect security is not possible, the operative word being ‘perfect’. i think what we want is for apple to ‘actually try’ to provide security, in some way that results in security order of magnitudes better than we enjoy today, which would still be miles and miles away from ‘perfect’, vulnerable to nation state actors etc etc etc

Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by josh2600 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:59PM (#29322570)
Can you point to a single instance of a cellphone vendor who takes security more seriously than Apple?

Put a different way, is there any device with a high monthly active user count that has a higher cost to purchase a black market exploit than the iPhone?

Apple can always do better. It should also scare the living hell out of us that they’re currently the best in the world.

My point is that if Apple can’t secure your phones, who can? It’s enough to make one think about security through obscurity.

Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by ccouzens on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:46PM (#29323265)
> Put a different way, is there any device with a high monthly active user count that has a higher cost to purchase a black market exploit than the iPhone?

I'm going to answer about operating system rather than device.

The selling price of an Android full chain with persistence zero click is up to $2.5 million. The selling price of an iOS full chain with persistence zero click is up to $2 million.

https://zerodium.com/program.html

Both are better than any desktop operating system.

Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by LogonType10 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:32PM (#29323842)
This isn't the benchmark of how secure those systems are, just a benchmark of how valuable exploiting them is. Hypothetically speaking, iOS could be more secure, but an Android exploit could be valued more if high valued targets tend to use Android. Keep in mind that phone OS usage varies quite a bit by country and wealth.
Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by ccouzens on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:53PM (#29324047)
I was responding to a specific comment about prices.

You're right that the price doesn't fully correlate with security. It will reflect supply (security and interest of researchers) and demand (how much there is to be gained by breaking into each platform).

Android is more widely used, but I gather more money is spent in the app store than the play store. I don't know the market share of "interesting" users.

My analysis would be that the number shows they're not that far apart. I'd be skeptical of anyone (IE apple's press release) saying that either platform is more secure. Security is too nuanced to be expressed as a total order.

Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by LogonType10 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:56PM (#29324066)
Agreed! Thank you for posting that Zerodium link. It's always great to bring substantive data into a security discussion.
Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by josh2600 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @10:38PM (#29326710)
100%, thank you. I had spoken to someone at Apple who said Apple was $5M and Android was $2M, but I hadn’t bothered to check. Thanks for posting data!!
Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by fsflover on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:12PM (#29322754)
> is there any device with a high monthly active user count that has a higher cost to purchase a black market exploit than the iPhone?

This is unfair, because there is a duopoly and the only alternative on mass market is Android. Of course in such circumstances the exploits will be expensive, even if security is awful.

Ignoring this, Purism takes security more seriously, because they give the user full control over the OS with possibility to replace/reinstall or harden it. In contrast to that, rarely updated iMessage is impossible to uninstall on iOs.

Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by kelnos on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:23PM (#29322076)
> i think what we want is for apple to ‘actually try’ to provide security, in some way that results in security order of magnitudes better than we enjoy today

That's a pretty tall order, and would likely result in a device that is much more expensive and has a user experience that users would not like. Assuming "orders of magnitude better" is even possible, of which I am skeptical.

Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by tptacek on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:30PM (#29322192)
I co-sign this whole comment and answer the rhetorical question: $50MM for an exploit chain would not stop a state-level adversary. Their alternatives for these kinds of operations is human intelligence; they'd pay more just in health benefits to staff those operations.
Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by matheusmoreira on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:06PM (#29322651)
> literally treating any piece of software running on the device as a potential threat vector even more than they already do

Sounds amazing. Every operating system should be designed this way. Only free software should have full access. Proprietary software cannot be trusted and must be regulated and controlled.

Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by Sporktacular on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:36PM (#29323116)
"Right now a chain of exploits is ~$5M on iOS. What if it was $50M? Would that actually stop a nation state?"

Yes, some states yes it would. That could make it unaffordable for many of NSOs clients.

The result would not be perfect, just better.

Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by Sporktacular on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:52PM (#29324023)
It's not clear the user experience would have to suffer. Maybe there are more groups doing for software architecture what Signal did for messaging. Groups like Heisers' SEL4 and Qubes. As for expense, imagine how much more we would have paid today, in real and opportunity costs, if over the last 20 years everyone used this "no such thing a perfect security" fatalism as the excuse to not just do things a bit better.
Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by DSingularity on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:56PM (#29323399)
Apple will advance the security of their platform more by suing NSO and lobbying the US gov to position the official view of the US gov regarding nation-state sponsorship for malicious software as reprehensible efforts which harm everyone (eg like biological/chemical weapons). If the US sanctioned Israel and critiqued them as reckless maybe less countries will support organizations like the NSO group.
Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by fsflover on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:29PM (#29322163)
> The attack surface of software as complicated as a modern operating system (iOS or MacOS, etc.) is simply too large to lockdown without dramatically hurting the user experience (assuming you could actually achieve a lockdown in the first place!!).

https://qubes-os.org

Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by tptacek on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:31PM (#29322203)
You talk to a lot of people who use Qubes day to day? I do. What have you heard about how Qubes life is?
Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by fsflover on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:32PM (#29322207)
I am gladly using Qubes myself as a daily driver. Can't recommend it enough.
Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by tptacek on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:39PM (#29322293)
Hey, my Qubes friends keep using it too. I'm not saying it's un-usable. Is dys-usable a word?
Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by fsflover on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:43PM (#29322360)
This is a vague and unconstructive criticism. Perhaps you could say something more to the point.

In my opinion, most of the HN audience would be able to use it to their benefit.

Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by tptacek on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:40PM (#29323189)
That might be true! But it's not very relevant to the NSO problem, because the mass market will not be able to use it.
Re:Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored... by high_byte on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:45PM (#29322383)
if it was 50m there would be significant increase in reports, for sure. problem is Apple has a reputation for not paying bounties...