I, for one, do not think the COVID vaccine specifically should be mandatory, nor do I think coercive tactics should be used. I think freedom of conscience is important generally and people should not be compelled against their consciences to do things they do not think they should be doing. We should also avoid fixating on COVID as if it was the be-all and end-all of human existence. It is one consideration and also one that does not justifiably admit imposing a blanket burden on everyone. Perhaps this is the result of the law of instrument: some epidemiology-informed considerations could be so hyperfocused on COVID, everything else if forgotten.
A treatment of this topic is also available here which touches on these considerations: https://edwardfeser.blogspot.com/2021/10/covid-19-vaccinatio...
What I'm proposing is not black and white but instead two things that give people a range of choices.
The role of government is to cover for market failings, and spillover costs are a prime example of an area where markets are essentially guaranteed to fail.
These are not the same thing. One is an inaction, the other is an action.
It's like saying that forcing someone to have an abortion is the same thing as banning abortions.
Lastly, even all of that aside, there's no rule that says the government can only mandate actions or prohibit actions. There are plenty of examples of both things in the US legal code.
https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2021/09/07/1033677...
I will say that I do not particularly trust NPR any more; they have misreported events in direct contradiction of clear video and audio feeds of the events.
90% discount on lung cancers of nonsmokers
General 30% discount for people exercising regularly
Etc...
For instance, the coverage of tests and vaccines has been legislated and repeatedly updated through the course of the pandemic in the country where I live.
At this point, what I'd like to see:
a) accept natural immunity alongside vaccination status, probably need some kind of antibody count test for that to work
b) "incentives" for vaccinated population, e.g. 90% discount on COVID treatments while unvaccinated pay full price