News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by stavros on Monday November 22, 2021 @12:21PM (#29308935)
I don't understand how the same institutions can come out with something as good as the GDPR and as bad as this bullshit. It's very tiring to have to fight against these things all the time, and it feels like our concerns aren't being heard.
Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by jacquesm on Monday November 22, 2021 @12:29PM (#29309048)
The EU is a fairly massive entity at this point and its government(s) are no exception. There are several arms of that government that are firing on all cylinders, privacy, and the cartel watchdog come to mind. There are also arms that are not effective or even detrimental. But these operate relatively independent of each other.

Note that you are comparing a proposal on the one side with a law on the other.

Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by GrayShade on Monday November 22, 2021 @12:43PM (#29309275)
The EU Commission is the especially scummy part of the EU.
Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by bko on Monday November 22, 2021 @12:29PM (#29309047)
I think its about opening an avenue to regulate internet. For instance most regulations start at the extreme (e.g. child safety). And over time once that avenue is open, special interests and police state can use those channels to impose their will. Going from 0 to 1 is the difficult part. Going from 1 to N is a lot easier.
Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by BongoMcCat on Monday November 22, 2021 @12:44PM (#29309280)
It probably isn't the same institutions..

Or, to be clear, it isn't.

For this to be turned into a law it would need to go through several steps, and currently there really isn't any reason to think that it will.

Maybe this is why we are reading this on a blog from an email provider and not the front page of a newspaper.

Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by stavros on Monday November 22, 2021 @12:45PM (#29309303)
Ah, that's encouraging, at least.
Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by turbinerneiter on Monday November 22, 2021 @12:25PM (#29308988)
They are just going to try over and over again, until there is Olympic games or a football Worldcup to distract the people.
Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by brewdad on Monday November 22, 2021 @12:46PM (#29309324)
Guess what's coming in 2022?
Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by jend on Monday November 22, 2021 @01:50PM (#29310171)
GDPR was actually by "accident".

Jan Philipp Albrecht was appointed as rapporteur of the European Parliament for the process of the GDPR law making. His job was to take care of the process to find compromises between many opinions and fill them into law. Since he actually cares about privacy, he was in a position to make sure that the compromises keep a certain level of privacy protection. He's from the german "green/environmental" party. There is an interesting documentary about his role and the process: "Democracy: Im Rausch der Daten". I don't know if there is an english version. There is a german version on youtube. The "mistake" was to appoint him as rapporteur.

The "mistake" was not repeated, when Axel Voss from the german conservative party was appointed as rapporteur for the "Directive on Copyright in the Digital Single Market (2019)".

(Note: The law making process in the EU is long and complicated and I do not know where this draft is currently in the process.)

Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by stavros on Monday November 22, 2021 @02:14PM (#29310441)
Ah, that's interesting background, thanks!
Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by closeparen on Monday November 22, 2021 @01:03PM (#29309576)
That’s more or less the argument for liberalism. A climate of intense regulation will sometimes ban stuff you hate but also sometimes ban stuff you like.
Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by AlexanderDhoore on Monday November 22, 2021 @12:25PM (#29308984)
It feels like that because "our concern" ARE NOT being heard. The privacy concerns voiced on HN are far removed from what the voting population here (Belgium) thinks. Most people don't mind surveillance "because they aren't doing anything wrong". You have to put in a lot of EFFORT to explain it to them. "First they came for the socialists..." and all that.
Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by stavros on Monday November 22, 2021 @12:29PM (#29309050)
Yeah, unfortunately that is a big problem. People don't care about privacy until it affects them, but then it's too late.
Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by 1cvmask on Monday November 22, 2021 @12:26PM (#29309001)
You think GDPR is good? It entrenches the monopolies of the Googles and makes it harder for a startup in a garage in Berlin.

-

I am sure there are some people who clearly enjoy pressing on the cookie popups when they travel to Europe like popping zits. Maybe it is the Eurocrats in Brussels.

Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by jacquesm on Monday November 22, 2021 @12:27PM (#29309021)
This is nonsense. You could simply decide not to track you users and then your garage in Berlin works just as well as your garage in Palo Alto would (though the latter would likely lead to an easier round of funding).
Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by flipbrad on Monday November 22, 2021 @12:31PM (#29309089)
GDPR also applies to the data you process about your prospective, current and former employees; the data you hold about your customers in order to fulfil your contracts with them; their feedback; etc. You can't avoid GDPR just by not tracking users; that does help you avoid a different law though (the ePrivacy directive's so-called "cookie rule".)
Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by jacquesm on Monday November 22, 2021 @12:35PM (#29309142)
Yes, which is excellent.

But the start-up in a garage example was - at least, that's the way I read it - meant as there currently not being a level playing field with respect to end users, not necessarily employees. And let's be perfectly clear here: employers that are callous with their employees data are to be avoided like the plague, no matter where they are located.

As for your customers: yes, you should be careful with that data, and no, their feedback does not necessarily fall under the GDPR, only when it concerns the privacy of the individuals mentioned therein. But normally speaking such feedback would not be about such specifics but about the product itself.

Not tracking your users has a big impact on how a company is set up, what data marketing has access to, what data system administrators and sometimes even programmers have access to. Storing your data in an anonymized way can make good sense. It likely will impact your business, but leaking of that data will impact the lives of your customers more, so that's why the GDPR is written the way it is: you minimize your footprint to that which you need and you will be doing just fine.

Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by flipbrad on Monday November 22, 2021 @06:41PM (#29312941)
"I like your Widget Max Pro, it's better than the Rival X1 I had last year. But I dropped it in the toilet and now it won't turn on, so I suspect you're lying about its IP56 rating".

Let's says that 1 out of every 3 product / service reviews is like this. Do you (a) block/filter them out and treat the remaining ones as non-personal data, or (b) treat your feedback pipelines/database as personal data regardless of whether some of the reviews are, somehow, devoid of personal data?

(Or (c), do you not think the example above contains personal data?)

Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by jacquesm on Monday November 22, 2021 @09:55PM (#29314121)
C
Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by flipbrad on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:11AM (#29315347)
Because it fails the Breyer test (no reasonably likely means of identification of the data subject), or the Nowak test (no link to a particular individual, by virtue of the data's content, purpose or effect)?

I'd say it definitely is my personal data, telling you - inter alia - about the objects I own, the opinions I hold, and my recent behaviour.

Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by stavros on Monday November 22, 2021 @12:28PM (#29309031)
> It entrenches the monopolies of the Googles and makes it harder for a startup in a garage in Berlin.

In what way?

Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by adventured on Monday November 22, 2021 @01:14PM (#29309714)
The start-up in the Berlin garage is hampered in its ability to make money via advertising vs the US-based Google (or Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, Reddit, Snapchat, Amazon).

Unless the plan is to go straight to the US market, to domicile there and to hire employees there to get started, as it's a radically more lucrative advertising market than the EU, in part thanks to GDPR.

The US market still largely has a comparatively laissez-faire approach to advertising, personal information and privacy. In the US you can still build a tech juggernaut in the way Google and Facebook did, by way of rather invasive advertising practices. You can't do that in the EU today, zero chance. In the US market you can jump-start a company that way, and if you have to later on you can look at dialing back or changing your exact business model. You don't have that option in the EU, you're far more heavily restricted, it cuts off your ability to liberally utilize a gigantic advertising market in the way US companies can. It provides US start-ups a big advantage. You set up in the US, grow into the huge US market, then use your resources to go into Europe and comply with their various requirements (along with paying their slap-on-the-wrist fines inevitably).

Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by stavros on Monday November 22, 2021 @01:16PM (#29309738)
So the startup in the EU can't play fast and loose with my data to get rich? And that's bad how?
Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by turbinerneiter on Monday November 22, 2021 @12:30PM (#29309060)
The cookie banners are a good example for a perversion of the law and if companies will keep up the dark patterns and law-hacking, the EU will update the GDPR laws to also forbid dark pattern cookie banners and BS EULAs and all the other crap.
Re:The latest EU plan to outlaw encryption and introduce com... by flipbrad on Monday November 22, 2021 @12:28PM (#29309035)
The GDPR isn't great, but several of its more bureaucratic requirements kick in only once you have over 250 employees (assuming you're not doing relatively risky/intrusive stuff with data), so it's not the end of the world for startups.