News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rust Moderation Team Resigns by zozbot234 on Monday November 22, 2021 @10:37AM (#29307503)
> they would have initiated a ban but they were not able to ban a core team member

If that was the case, the obvious response would be a formal statement of rebuke and censure wrt. the offending member's behavior, which would clarify that such things aren't welcome in the project. The fact that we aren't getting anything close to that extreme suggests that this is in fact a big fat nothingburger. (Unless you think that CoC violations are so widespread in the Rust Core Team that naming the specific people involved would have made no discernible difference, but so far we've seen nothing to indicate that.)

Re:Rust Moderation Team Resigns by babyblueblanket on Monday November 22, 2021 @10:41AM (#29307557)
It might be that they cannot censure the offending member in any capacity, due to their core team member status. In that case, resignation is the only thing they have to effectively rebuke behavior.
Re:Rust Moderation Team Resigns by zozbot234 on Monday November 22, 2021 @02:22PM (#29310528)
As pointed out on r/rust, the approved Governance RFC states quite unambiguously that the Core Team is accountable to the community wrt. their behavior:

> Subteam, and especially core team members are also held to a high standard of behavior. Part of the reason to separate the moderation subteam is to ensure that CoC violations by Rust's leadership be addressed through the same independent body of moderators.

https://rust-lang.github.io/rfcs/1068-rust-governance.html

Re:Rust Moderation Team Resigns by loeg on Monday November 22, 2021 @10:48AM (#29307645)
Public shaming by respected community members is probably somewhat effective. However, they chose not to do that here. Without knowing more, I have to trust their judgment. But I recognize that it’s unsatisfying.
Re:Rust Moderation Team Resigns by jacquesm on Monday November 22, 2021 @11:57AM (#29308578)
This has a much worse effect though. Instead of damaging a single member they are now damaging the whole core team by leaving it unspecific, and they are damaging Rust as well.
Re:Rust Moderation Team Resigns by ChuckMcM on Monday November 22, 2021 @01:21PM (#29309807)
I suspect that doing it this way puts pressure on the core team members who don't subscribe to the behaviors moderate the people on the core team who are problems. But one can never know.
Re:Rust Moderation Team Resigns by jacquesm on Monday November 22, 2021 @01:26PM (#29309868)
Yes, that's how I read it too. At a guess, if the threat to resign didn't change anything the resignation also won't change anything and strongly suggesting the core team can not be trusted not to lie is a very harsh move that has the power to destabilize the whole Rust experiment. Massively dumb move this.
Re:Rust Moderation Team Resigns by raxxorrax on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:19AM (#29315709)
I think the only thing damaged is the concept to follow a COC to the letter. This was expected, people complained about it thoroughly and I think communities work better with a flexible approach as I don't think any personal conflicts have caused problems anywhere to a relevant degree. There are neither judges nor attorneys here.
Re:Rust Moderation Team Resigns by SamoyedFurFluff on Monday November 22, 2021 @12:26PM (#29309013)
It might be that the details would also damage the core team and The Rust community much worse with a flood of people leaving or people being targeted for harassment/abuse.
Re:Rust Moderation Team Resigns by jacquesm on Monday November 22, 2021 @12:32PM (#29309107)
I'll give that the benefit of the doubt, but if that is the case then Rust is dead because if the core team can't be trusted to handle something like this then probably Rust as an experiment has failed, you won't get further corporates taking a gamble on Rust if this sort of cloud is hanging over the core team.
Re:Rust Moderation Team Resigns by jbjohns on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:00AM (#29315281)
Well I think Amazon has a vested interest in the language at this point. Does the core team even matter that much now? If the core team falls apart could Amazon not simply pick up the reins? It doesn't seem to have hurt C# or Swift to be driven by a company.
Re:Rust Moderation Team Resigns by reshlo on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @05:26AM (#29316293)
There have been many points of friction in the history of C# and Swift caused by company-driven goals influencing the development of the language ecosystem in ways that some of their communities disagreed with. Leaving that aside, those languages were purpose-built by those companies for their use. Amazon didn’t create Rust, and it’s hard to imagine a hostile takeover would be received well.
Re:Rust Moderation Team Resigns by jbjohns on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @08:46AM (#29317704)
Friction points are unavoidable. The point is they survived and have flourished under the direction of these companies who benefit from their continued existence.

I agree a hostile takeover would not be good for anyone but if the existing management structure turns out to be a roadblock maybe stewardship from a big tech company wouldn't be so bad.

Re:Rust Moderation Team Resigns by loeg on Monday November 22, 2021 @12:12PM (#29308790)
Whether it’s better or worse is unknowable.
Re:Rust Moderation Team Resigns by jacquesm on Monday November 22, 2021 @12:16PM (#29308853)
Yes, because if you accuse a group when you should be accusing an individual you are doing all of the people in the group a disservice. Then you should just say nothing. 'wie A zegt moet ook B zeggen'. If there are major upsides to this approach then I'm not aware of them, do tell.
Re:Rust Moderation Team Resigns by CRConrad on Saturday November 27, 2021 @06:39PM (#29364723)
TAN:

> 'wie A zegt moet ook B zeggen'.

Someone else mentioned "the Russian proverb, 'If you've said A, say B'"... In Swedish it's "Har man sagt A får man säga B". Seems rather international.

Re:Rust Moderation Team Resigns by whimsicalism on Monday November 22, 2021 @11:01AM (#29307821)
Is there any possibility they are under formal legal contract ie. NDA? Don't know how formal the Rust organization is setup/whether that would be a part in the process of joining the moderation team.
Re:Rust Moderation Team Resigns by jacquesm on Monday November 22, 2021 @11:58AM (#29308588)
A moderation team under NDA might as well not exist. Moderators should always be free to speak their minds.
Re:Rust Moderation Team Resigns by Jensson on Monday November 22, 2021 @12:03PM (#29308662)
Is HR on the employees side? No. Same thing here, the moderation team didn't realize that their job was to protect the core team from the rest, holding the core team accountable wasn't a part of their job even if it was warranted.
Re:Rust Moderation Team Resigns by phendrenad2 on Monday November 22, 2021 @12:18PM (#29308886)
An NDA for an open-source project? I sincerely hope no one tried that, but if they did, that's a radical idea and the effects must be studied (never let someone doing something weird go to waste, science can learn from it!)
Re:Rust Moderation Team Resigns by whimsicalism on Monday November 22, 2021 @01:47PM (#29310131)
I don't know what changes when formal structures like a foundation start getting involved.
Re:Rust Moderation Team Resigns by hoseja on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @06:36AM (#29316652)
I don't understand, why would you trust the judgement of volunteer moderators instead of core technical people?
Re:Rust Moderation Team Resigns by CRConrad on Thursday November 25, 2021 @07:12PM (#29346297)
Well obviously you wouldn't, on technical stuff, -- but that's not what this is about, now is it?