Re:Fingerprints can be hacked
by darkwater on Monday November 22, 2021 @09:06AM
(#29306394)
I always thought that since the beginning, but unfortunately the world went into another direction. People always said "something you have and something you know", but now for most cases it's just "something you have - your body". Obviously if in the future remote mind-readers are invented, the "something you know" part will also get obsolete, but for now we should stick to it.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I believe it's
- Something you have (key, device,...)
- Something you know
- Something you are (biometry)
In Europe there is a regulation (PSD2) that defines a strong authentication as 2 of the 3 listed above.
I've always disliked this breakdown. My body is something I have -- it's just potentially (not always practically -- see the article) more difficult to clone or otherwise use without my consent than a key fob or something.
Edit: To be clear, I don't think this is an argument for biometrics, but rather an argument against them. They can't complement something I have in a two factor scheme, because my biometrics are something I have.
Re:Fingerprints can be hacked
by jagged-chisel on Monday November 22, 2021 @10:19AM
(#29307223)
But it's the parts that are easily forgeable (fingerprints, retinas, etc) that are being relied upon. By "forgeable" I mean "things that someone else can also have by creating copies."
I don't think we have yet good metrics on how to detect specific individuals using a full-body scan. Not to mention the invasiveness of creating your personal initial dataset. Most folks won't stand for it. So right back to parts that are forgeable...
Re:Fingerprints can be hacked
by avianlyric on Monday November 22, 2021 @11:01AM
(#29307827)
Your body isn’t very easy to replace. Passwords and devices are.
This is precisely why he is a poor “password” / secret replacement.
Whelp, your fingerprints have been cloned. Time to go get them burned off and get some new ones. Yeah, that’s not gonna work.