Re:What every IT person needs to know about OpenBSD Part 3: ...
by upofadown on Saturday November 20, 2021 @10:07PM
(#29293835)
I am not sure what is meant by this. It certainly seems to have QoS in the form of the queue directive. It works for me for limiting buffer bloat on my VDSL model upstream. The defaults work well for my VOIP stuff so that all I have is this in my pf.conf:
queue outq on re1 flows 1024 bandwidth 3000K max 3000K qlimit 1024 default
I think the magic is in the "flows" part.Added: Relevant articles:
* https://dataswamp.org/~solene/2021-08-30-openbsd-qos-lan.htm... * https://www.pauladamsmith.com/blog/2018/07/fixing-bufferbloa...
Re:What every IT person needs to know about OpenBSD Part 3: ...
by knorker on Sunday November 21, 2021 @06:57AM
(#29295727)
Like I said, this is a very superficial view of QoS.
And I'm surprised OpenBSD only did the bare minimum.
Re:What every IT person needs to know about OpenBSD Part 3: ...
by hansel_der on Sunday November 21, 2021 @07:19AM
(#29295834)
as said, the "flows" keyword actually summons fq_codel to the task which represents the state of the art in sane-by-default QoS implementations.
Re:What every IT person needs to know about OpenBSD Part 3: ...
by ratorx on Saturday November 20, 2021 @06:38PM
(#29292800)
Not sure what exactly you mean by QoS, but there is the `prio` keyword, which lets you put packets into priority queues.
However, I tried it a while back and couldn’t actually make it do anything useful, but that might have been me misconfiguring it.
Re:What every IT person needs to know about OpenBSD Part 3: ...
by chayleaf on Sunday November 21, 2021 @01:26AM
(#29294581)
you can filter packets by TOS bits and queue them the way you want
Re:What every IT person needs to know about OpenBSD Part 3: ...
by upofadown on Sunday November 21, 2021 @08:06AM
(#29296022)
OpenBSD is pretty good by default. Traffic with different TOS is separately queued with reasonable priority defaults. So you normally don't have to do anything.
I was a bit surprised that my VOIP stuff was just working when I moved my router from Linux to OpenBSD and had to go looking to figure out why.
Re:What every IT person needs to know about OpenBSD Part 3: ...
by hansel_der on Sunday November 21, 2021 @05:37AM
(#29295347)
state of the art is to put packets into separate queues based on the 4-tuple (src,dst,port) then dequeue them fairly based on packet- and queuesize
I was shocked that a server OS this old could be this immature on something this basic.
It pretty much excludes it from being a serious router/firewall.