News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by _dain_ on Friday November 19, 2021 @06:30PM (#29283965)
this is a city that puts up billboards telling junkies how to "safely" shoot up heroin
Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by blunte on Friday November 19, 2021 @06:35PM (#29284005)
You're not going to stop a junkie from shooting up (without a comprehensive, life-changing program). So barring that, you might as well teach them how to be more safe so they don't end up in a hospital spending your tax money for emergency care... or worse, dead somewhere and likewise then consuming public funds to deal with it.

[added] Since this is such a controversial topic, I would recommend reading about Portugal's approach to solving drug problems (hint, it has been quite successful(): https://transformdrugs.org/blog/drug-decriminalisation-in-po...

Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by _dain_ on Friday November 19, 2021 @06:43PM (#29284073)
but it also sends the message that shooting up heroin is tolerated, even encouraged. it's like the people running the city have completely giving up on expecting any kind of standards of public decency or even upholding civilization itself. they gave up on collecting trash, they gave up on arresting thieves, they gave up building houses, they're considering whether to give up teaching calculus. nothing we can do! we'll just manage the decline into thirdworldization, be careful not to overdose while you drug yourself into a stupor.
Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by nkrisc on Friday November 19, 2021 @06:59PM (#29284229)
> but it also sends the message that shooting up heroin is tolerated, even encouraged

So what? An addict is going to shoot up whether it’s tolerated or not, and non-addicts aren’t going to take up heroin because they say a billboard. If you really want to end it, it’s going to need to be a lot more comprehensive, expensive, and expansive than the presence or absence of a billboard.

Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by _dain_ on Friday November 19, 2021 @07:04PM (#29284269)
okay, how about we put up billboards saying

>When you smash a window to rob a store, be careful not to cut yourself on the glass. Wear thick gloves.

after all, a billboard is not going to stop a burglar, is it? and if we're going to have burglaries, it's better that the burglars don't injure themselves while committing their crimes, because after all it will reduce the burden on hospitals. it will also protect the store owners from liability!

I'm not a nietzchean but I start to sympathize with how zarathustra must have felt when he saw those pathetic last men, bleating about "harm reduction" as they huddled together for warmth.

Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by nkrisc on Saturday November 20, 2021 @12:46PM (#29290183)
Why would you put up those billboards? What's the intent? Is there an epidemic of burglars bleeding to death in the streets? Sure it makes a good analogy, but it has nothing to do with the reality we live in. We don't live in a hypothetical world, so it's appropriate to consider methods that are specific to the realities of the world we really do live in.
Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by minitoar on Saturday November 20, 2021 @10:15AM (#29288786)
Is there an epidemic of burglars injuring themselves I’m not aware of?
Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by WalterBright on Saturday November 20, 2021 @10:27AM (#29288895)
The local public library has a sign that says obeying the law is required in the library.

I asked the librarian if there really was a problem with the library being a law-free zone. She shrugged saying "what can I say". Personally, I doubt that a sign would dissuade the types who go to the library to commit crimes.

Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by satvikpendem on Saturday November 20, 2021 @11:44AM (#29289609)
Addiction is a physiological disease. Burglary is not. You cannot compare them just because they are both crimes, as they have different causes. Those that burgle choose to do so (and yes, their circumstances may lead them to do so, such as poverty) but those who are addicted cannot really choose, their body demands that they abuse the substance.
Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by mensetmanusman on Sunday November 21, 2021 @01:05PM (#29298260)
Many burglers are addicts trying to get resources to satisfy their body’s demand though.
Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by mbrodersen on Saturday November 20, 2021 @09:02PM (#29293536)
The heavily funded “Just Say No” campaign never worked. So what makes you think a billboard will somehow be more powerful than that?
Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by tekproxy on Saturday November 20, 2021 @06:48AM (#29287254)
Just move. California doesn't deserve you. People there think you can only use carrots and sticks are immoral.
Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by _dain_ on Saturday November 20, 2021 @07:08AM (#29287388)
oh I don't live in CA, I just know people who do
Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by DantesKite on Friday November 19, 2021 @06:37PM (#29284022)
You can stop a junkie from shooting up by imprisoning them, or better yet, putting them through drug rehab.

Everything else is not a solution and only exacerbates the problem.

There's nothing safe about staying addicted to drugs.

Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by wolverine876 on Friday November 19, 2021 @10:20PM (#29285275)
> You can stop a junkie from shooting up by imprisoning them, or better yet, putting them through drug rehab.

Those responses have been tried for many years, with very poor results. Also, it's not clear that there is anything criminal about the vice of drugs, and thus taking away their freedom would be highly unjust. We take away people's freedom for bad behavior or because other people are uncomfortable.

Based on the little I know, what does help people is giving them access to social services. I think several American cities are pioneering bringing the services to the person - when authorities are called, they don't send police or only police, but people who can connect the person to various agencies.

Apparently this approach results in a much higher rate of service use (which makes sense commercially - if someone had to wait in long lines and fill out dozens of forms, and then face long delays for service, you wouldn't have many customers. If someone showed up, when need the service, and offered it on the spot, you'd sell a few more). And those people gain more stable lives and are able to better care for themselves.

We can see plenty of wealthy professionals turn to damaging behavior under great stress. Imagine how they would do if added to that stress is having no roof or reliable food, the loss of safety, the loss of any credibility - even enough to get basic jobs, the harassment, etc. But then them: 'We'll take care of the shelter, food, etc., and here are classes to help cope with your other problems without using drugs', and I can imagine they would have a much better chance.

Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by alphabettsy on Friday November 19, 2021 @11:45PM (#29285628)
There are drugs available in jails and prisons. Incarceration does not solve addiction and worse it groups troubled people together.
Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by blunte on Friday November 19, 2021 @06:45PM (#29284093)
Putting a junkie in prison will indeed stop them, for the time they are in jail. But once they get out, they will return to the life they know. And then you're back with the original problem, but you've now also spent a ton of money to imprison them.

Obviously there's nothing safe about being addicted to drugs. But there are certainly methods of drug use which have wildly varied risk levels. Same for other things - drinking alcohol, eating unhealthy foods, etc.

Portugal is the best example of how to tackle the drug problem. There are many articles, but here's one: https://transformdrugs.org/blog/drug-decriminalisation-in-po...

Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by rufus_foreman on Friday November 19, 2021 @08:27PM (#29284738)
>> Putting a junkie in prison will indeed stop them, for the time they are in jail

Sadly, no. The junkies I knew, back when I knew junkies, were terrified of rehab, not of prison.

One of them told me, to justify behavior that was mystifying to me, "I can still use in prison".

Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by _dain_ on Friday November 19, 2021 @07:11PM (#29284318)
portugal does arrest drug users, and drug dealers. the users get treatment and the dealers get punished, neither of which SF deigns to do.

https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1451913061380476932.html

Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by pwthornton on Friday November 19, 2021 @06:42PM (#29284064)
Wait until you find out about drug abuse in prisons.
Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by nbardy on Saturday November 20, 2021 @01:36PM (#29290637)
I’d welcome Portugal’s approach, but it is very different. San Francisco doesn’t prosecute dealers, and encourages open drug markets and camps on the street by funding and encouraging the behavior with permanent enabling, no path towards rehabilitation, and lack of law enforcement on the dealers and the non-drug crimes the commit.

Compassion and understanding of drug use issues is a different world than enabling spiraling dens of despair.

[dead]
Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by _dain_ on Friday November 19, 2021 @06:49PM (#29284135)
I'm the GP poster but I don't agree with this social darwinist crap at all. I bet you would never apply this logic if your own kids fell into drug addiction. it is not "nature" taking its course here, it is a sick, stupid society that tolerates the proliferation of mind-altering poisons and then shovels vast amounts of public money into useless fake "rehab" charities run by politically-connected grifters. there are people out there getting rich off all this misery and it isn't just the dealers.
Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by 1123581321 on Sunday November 21, 2021 @01:58AM (#29294678)
That gets at the heart of the issue, which is our weak social and familiar bonds. Addiction remains prevalent because so few individuals or social groups have the courage and standing to significantly intervene. A parent would hopefully neither let their child die nor abandon them to an enabling harm reduction program. But most adults do not have anyone who loves them enough to take them to a safe place—likely at some expense—for two weeks to help with withdrawal. It’s heartbreaking.
Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by dang on Friday November 19, 2021 @07:00PM (#29284242)
Please keep this sort of generic flamewar comment off HN. It will only lead to hell.
Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by yeetman21 on Friday November 19, 2021 @09:19PM (#29285020)
Sorry, will not happen again
Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by dang on Friday November 19, 2021 @10:46PM (#29285380)
Appreciated!
Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by ketzo on Friday November 19, 2021 @06:37PM (#29284019)
which is an important, proven way to save lives.

responsible treatment of drug addicts =/= the government somehow telling people to throw trash in the streets.

Re:Clean Streets: People taking San Francisco’s trash into t... by tshaddox on Friday November 19, 2021 @06:38PM (#29284025)
How are those things related?