News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by hash872 on Thursday November 18, 2021 @08:44PM (#29272891)
The US was stable for the entire 20th century with FPTP. If it's so bad, why was the US stable for so long with literally the exact same system we have now? Canada's used FPTP for its entire democratic existence, it's one of the most stable democracies on Earth. Britain not only uses FPTP, but uses the most extreme version possible in the Westminster system where the losing party has far fewer rights than they would in the US. Again- another perfectly stable 1st world democracy.

Meanwhile, lots of far more consensus-oriented political systems have utterly collapsed. Weimar Germany used PR- so did Argentina when Peron took over. Rwanda was using PR leading up to its famous genocide in the 90s! The number of parliamentary countries using PR that have collapsed probably exceeds the total number of FPTP countries globally.

Voting or electoral systems just don't matter that much- culture does. If you're a basically stable society, you can use any voting method and be fine- if Japan or the Scandinavian nations adopted FPTP tomorrow, nothing fundamental would change. If you're unstable, you'll be unstable no matter what type of voting system you use. Governments are not computers where a different operating system leads to different results, I'm sorry

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by krapp on Thursday November 18, 2021 @09:53PM (#29273257)
You spent two paragraphs arguing that FPTP voting systems are responsible for the stability of the US, Canada and Britain, ("If [FPTP is] so bad, why was the US stable for so long with literally the exact same system we have now?") whereas countries that use consensus-oriented systems tend to collapse into autocracies ("The number of parliamentary countries using PR that have collapsed probably exceeds the total number of FPTP countries globally.") ... and then your final paragraph argues "Voting or electoral systems just don't matter that much- culture does. If you're a basically stable society, you can use any voting method and be fine."

So which is it? Is FPTP the lynchpin of stable democracies, or otherwise irrelevant? Are you making an explicit statement about politics or an implicit statement about culture, here?

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by hash872 on Thursday November 18, 2021 @10:33PM (#29273507)
>You spent two paragraphs arguing that FPTP voting systems are responsible for the stability of the US, Canada and Britain

I did not say that, I'm sorry that you got that impression. I am saying that political systems overall are simply much less important than many people, including anti-FPTP campaigners, believe. These examples were simply meant to illustrate the non-correlation between government structure & stability- I could just as easily point to how stable most European PR countries are, or how unstable FPTP users like Jamaica, Pakistan and Yemen can be. It's my belief that the US, Canada and Britain would be equally stable under PR. I am very much making an implicit statement about culture.

Fun fact, with a little more research I learned that both South Korea & Taiwan use FPTP for at least some parliamentary offices. Again, if the voting system makes such a huge difference....

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by Taikonerd on Friday November 19, 2021 @10:53AM (#29278424)
Lee Drutman talks a lot about this in his book, "Breaking the Two-Party Doom Loop." [0]

Short version: there used to be much less "party discipline" in US politics. There were lots of sub-factions within the two big parties that would vote differently, depending on the issue. So, it was common for bills to pass with (say) 50% of Democrats voting for them, and 60% of Republicans.

In the 90's (according to Drutman), the parties started being much more "coherent" -- like, all Democrats would favor a bill, and all Republicans would oppose it. This makes it much harder to pass legislation.

[0] https://www.amazon.com/Breaking-Two-Party-Doom-Loop-Multipar...

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by hash872 on Friday November 19, 2021 @02:31PM (#29281246)
I read it, I thought it was pretty handwavey. Anyways, doesn't explain how Canada, Britain, South Korea & Taiwan all manage FPTP successfully as stable democracies
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by ClayShentrup on Sunday November 21, 2021 @12:32PM (#29298006)
Yeah I don't think Lee is a super deep thinker and he gets a lot of basic things wrong. I corrected some of his obvious errors in this piece.

https://thefulcrum.us/amp/actually-approval-voting-beats-rcv...

As a general rule, it is true that plurality voting absolutely sucks. The vast majority of highly rated democracies use something different. The UK and US are ranked 16th and 25th respectively.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index

Taiwan and South Korea both use a significant amount of proportional representation.

But Drutman's biggest fallacy is thinking that you have to have proportional representation. Simple approval voting would plausibly have as big or greater impact.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by hash872 on Monday November 22, 2021 @09:25AM (#29306588)
You missed Canada at #5. And Taiwan (#11) & SK allocating around 15% of their seats to PR- recently, as in the last three years- I would not call a 'significant amount' of PR
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by godelski on Friday November 19, 2021 @08:02PM (#29284611)
> doesn't explain how Canada, Britain, South Korea & Taiwan all manage FPTP successfully as stable democracies

There's a lot of other factors in there besides the method of voting. People often compare the US to other countries over voting but ignore that the systems are substantially different. For example, the UK parliament (and many parliaments) has proportional representation. This is something we don't see in the US congress. And it is important to distinguish that presidential elections are vastly different than congressional/parliamentary elections. Then again, maybe this is part of the problem, that US is hyper focused on the presidential elections but nowhere near similarly engaged in the congressional ones.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by hash872 on Saturday November 20, 2021 @10:26AM (#29288877)
The UK does not have proportional representation, that's not correct. FPTP & PR are opposites- you have to choose one system or the other. I agree that presidential systems are probably suboptimal, but it is worth noting that South Korea has a president in addition to FPTP, single rep districts, etc. Again my point- if you're a stable culture, you can make any system work!
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by ClayShentrup on Sunday November 21, 2021 @12:34PM (#29298023)
On Korea: The National Assembly has 300 members elected for a four-year term, 253 in single-seat constituencies and 47 members by proportional representation.
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by hash872 on Monday November 22, 2021 @09:22AM (#29306555)
Yes, and I believe Taiwan has started doing something similar. That's still under 16% of all seats, and- they just started doing this in the last couple of years. They were 100% similar to the US system until very recently