News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by qwertox on Thursday November 18, 2021 @02:50PM (#29269589)
Apparently this happened before:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smallpox

> On July 1, 2014, six sealed glass vials of smallpox dated 1954, along with sample vials of other pathogens, were discovered in a cold storage room in an FDA laboratory at the National Institutes of Health location in Bethesda, Maryland. The smallpox vials were subsequently transferred to the custody of the CDC in Atlanta, where virus taken from at least two vials proved viable in culture.[130][131] After studies were conducted, the CDC destroyed the virus under WHO observation on February 24, 2015.[132]

Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by chasil on Thursday November 18, 2021 @02:58PM (#29269678)
More than once.

"The smallpox virus escaped three times from labs in England in the 1960’s and 1970’s, causing 80 cases and 3 deaths."

https://thebulletin.org/2021/05/the-origin-of-covid-did-peop...

Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by prox on Thursday November 18, 2021 @04:03PM (#29270497)
There was an interesting discussion in r/labrats about hoarding old stuff in labs. Can definitely see it happen.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by jweir on Thursday November 18, 2021 @03:15PM (#29269918)
Then a good deal of the population was vaccinated. The US stopped vaccinating for small pox in, I think, 1972... just before I was born.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by ChrisMarshallNY on Thursday November 18, 2021 @03:41PM (#29270235)
I was vaccinated. Back then, it was meant to last a lifetime. Not sure that's the case, though.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by bawolff on Thursday November 18, 2021 @07:49PM (#29272516)
Its one of the oldest vaccines. We started giving it in the 1800s and it was eradicated in the 70's. If immunity waned, it would have been noticed back when smallpox was still a thing by people getting smallpox.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by CapitalistCartr on Thursday November 18, 2021 @06:12PM (#29271811)
The military was still vaccinating in '81, when I joined.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by ericmay on Thursday November 18, 2021 @08:36PM (#29272830)
Still vaccinating in select areas. In 2007 deployed to the Republic of Korea and was vaccinated.

It sucked and that was just a baby version…

Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by foo92691 on Thursday November 18, 2021 @03:00PM (#29269710)
Deciding to culture the samples, versus just destroying them without analysis, must be accompanied by an interesting risk/benefit analysis.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by morpheuskafka on Thursday November 18, 2021 @03:10PM (#29269821)
They were transported to the existing, single approved location for processing these samples before being cultured. So the risk may not have been any more than existing research at that facility.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by ajsnigrutin on Thursday November 18, 2021 @05:56PM (#29271672)
I was always under the impressions, that they keep the samples frozen in some big "freezer", and that they don't poke them around and "play" with them... so opening an unknown vial of an unknown sample of possibly smallpox, having the sample analyzed, and all the procedures needed for that, seem (to me) more risky than just keeping the freezer running.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by phendrenad2 on Friday November 19, 2021 @01:06AM (#29274314)
People make mistakes under pressure. So it's a good idea to induce limited pressure from time to time. Having to go through the proper preparations to analyze these samples was probably a valuable and rare training opportunity.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by WastingMyTime89 on Saturday November 20, 2021 @07:58AM (#29287687)
Analysing unknown samples is part of the mission of these facilities, think about studying a new pathogen from human or animal samples for example. It’s fairly routine for them. They have the equipments and know how to do it safely.

In this case, I think it was done to assess the risk of this kind of discovery in the future. If these samples had failed to be viable that would have been a huge relief for everyone.

Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by lazide on Thursday November 18, 2021 @03:31PM (#29270108)
If you’re trying to decide how big a risk it is that there are other vials out there, definitely. Especially since we’ve stopped wide spread vaccination as it’s considered eradicated.

If some gov’t lab deep in Siberia has some samples - how big a problem would i be? actually?

Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by krisoft on Thursday November 18, 2021 @05:07PM (#29271250)
> If some gov’t lab deep in Siberia has some samples

That's not an if. We know that the Vector Institute has smallpox samples and they are headquartered in Siberia.

let's use this source maybe: https://slate.com/technology/2014/07/vector-institute-in-nov...

or maybe this one: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/sep/17/blast-sparks-f...

It's really not a secret, and definitely not an "if"

Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by tibbydudeza on Friday November 19, 2021 @05:36AM (#29275796)
It is also pretty secure place and there is a detachment of the Russian Army nearby just in case.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by killjoywashere on Thursday November 18, 2021 @03:37PM (#29270186)
Spritz it on some freshly laundered towels in a 5-star hotel (lots of international travelers) and you have a hot mess fast. Same thing in a Motel 6, you get longer dwell the in the first country before it spreads overseas.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by lazide on Thursday November 18, 2021 @04:09PM (#29270602)
That was the 80’s and 90’s ‘wake up in a cold sweat’ nightmare, when one wasn’t having it about nukes, the Cold War, and MAD anyway.

One can hope that anyone with the resources and intelligence to pull that off, would 1) have something better and more useful to do with their lives, and 2) would have someone they care about somewhere and realize it would almost certainly blow back on them too.

Definitely not guaranteed, but so far seems to be panning out. Let’s hope it stays that way.

Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by a2tech on Thursday November 18, 2021 @08:13PM (#29272668)
I've always thought the smart move would be a first strike with nukes followed up with aerial application of weaponized smallpox over non-nuked areas. The nukes would slow down and hamstring efforts at containment and let the biological agents get a good foothold.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by dTal on Friday November 19, 2021 @08:19AM (#29276832)
For months, almost the entire Western world just watched slackjawed while Covid spread outward from China - presumably hoping it would just go away.

I wouldn't worry too much about hamstringing containment efforts.

Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by jacobr1 on Friday November 19, 2021 @02:30PM (#29281225)
Wasn't that because the virus has hit some kind of local maxima of morbidity and human-fear?

If it was some kind "new ebola," I could imagine a much more aggressive response, with much less political polarization.

Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by ricardobayes on Saturday November 20, 2021 @06:00AM (#29287016)
Can't blame them (us) too much. It was unprecedented, and all previous dangerous fledgling pandemics in the past 10 years did just stop in time somehow. H1N1, MERS, SARS, Ebola etc.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by jacobr1 on Thursday November 18, 2021 @04:59PM (#29271174)
The scarier thought is some kind of gene-targeted virus that avoids the blowback
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by K0balt on Friday November 19, 2021 @11:38AM (#29279046)
I don’t think that people understand how relatively practical this is, and it wouldn’t even have to be a dramatically or overtly “bad” virus to have very useful economic effects. Just a virus that dramatically increases the chance of cancer, or screws with nuerons low key causing early onset dementia after years, or whatever.

The incentives that support this type of research will be (or are) too high to ignore.

Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by tomjen3 on Thursday November 18, 2021 @05:44PM (#29271568)
Honestly I am more concerned with the transport. If I had found the samples I would consider burning down the lab.

Sorry, but the end of Smallpox is one of the greatest medical success stories ever. I am not going to be the one who reopens that particular Pandoras box.

Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by nicoburns on Thursday November 18, 2021 @06:54PM (#29272145)
I suspect transporting sealed samples intact is much safer than burning down the lab and hoping they get anihilated.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by elzbardico on Thursday November 18, 2021 @07:13PM (#29272285)
Nuke'em! Nuke'em from orbit! it's the only way to be sure.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by p1mrx on Thursday November 18, 2021 @07:23PM (#29272360)
Nuking from orbit works better if you're in orbit.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by elzbardico on Thursday November 18, 2021 @07:32PM (#29272411)
a matter of personal taste, Sir.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by NaturalPhallacy on Thursday November 18, 2021 @08:07PM (#29272631)
Fire on position!
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by jopsen on Thursday November 18, 2021 @07:36PM (#29272437)
Don't we have vaccines?

I mean sure an outbreak would be pretty horrific. But once the pictures start circulating, I suspect vaccine hesitation would evaporate pretty quickly.

Yes, yes, we should go far to avoid an outbreak, but would it really be so world ending? Wouldn't we just contain it, vaccinate widely and be done with it?

Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by mynameisvlad on Thursday November 18, 2021 @07:50PM (#29272523)
I'd maybe buy this comment a few years ago.

We are barely able to vaccinate against a global pandemic as it is. Our society would honestly probably crumble if you brought in a really deadly virus like smallpox to the fold.

Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by throwawaylinux on Thursday November 18, 2021 @08:27PM (#29272758)
Not for lack of people being willing to take the vaccination though.

People look at risks and benefits and generally make their minds up pretty rationally, if you account that not everybody values things exactly the same as you do.

Covid is really not that much of a risk if you're otherwise healthy and the vaccines are not highly effective as the smallpox one is (in fact stated definitions of vaccine had to be revised so it would not be excluded). The absolute risk reduction is just not all that high, and some people are disinclined to jump to getting new therapies without much long term data.

You see the rational behavior play out when you look at vaccinations by age. 98% of people over 65 in the US have had one dose and 86% have had two. Because that's where the risk gets higher. Elderly people are not vastly better educated, smarter, less susceptible to propaganda, or lean toward political ideologies that are more inclined to take it, or have significantly easier access to it.

It's just that they get more benefit from the vaccine and they understand that and act accordingly.

If there was an especially transmissible smallpox epidemic killing 30% of people who contracted it and a vaccine that provided lasting immunity to 95% of people who took it, 99.something% of people would take it I bet.

Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by ricardobayes on Saturday November 20, 2021 @06:02AM (#29287027)
A comment like this got me banned from reddit, stating I was downplaying the risk of Covid. Not saying covid is not dangerous, it really is, but just looking at numbers even diarrhea kills 10M people yearly. It's just not visible to us in the western world and not picked up by the media.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by throwawaylinux on Sunday November 21, 2021 @05:40PM (#29300494)
A lot of people can't cope with hearing about different peoples' perspectives or learning about new ideas that might contradict their own beliefs. They don't go on the internet to be challenged, they go on it to be comforted and assured that their beliefs are right and that other people believe the same things.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by tzs on Friday November 19, 2021 @08:10AM (#29276754)
> People look at risks and benefits and generally make their minds up pretty rationally, if you account that not everybody values things exactly the same as you do.

But what about when how they value things is not rational?

Consider for example people who are rejecting COVID vaccines because they believe that they contain luciferase (they don't, BTW, although luciferases were likely used in the development of the vaccines). Why, you might wonder, would someone care about whether or not the vaccines contained bioluminescent enzymes?

I've seen two reasons. (1) somehow the bioluminescent enzymes are supposed to make it so the government can track you, and (2) the name comes from the word "lucifer" when clearly means that the vaccine is the work of or promotes Satan.

If someone truly believes either of those things then arguably it is rational for them to decide that the risks of the vaccine outweigh the benefits, but nevertheless I would not call their overall behavior rational.

Quite a few of the reasons for rejecting COVID vaccination given by people who end up as the subjects of /r/HermanCainAward or /r/CovidAteMyFace posts would apply just as well to smallpox vaccination, and quite a few of those people are in high risk COVID groups or situations.

Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by throwawaylinux on Friday November 19, 2021 @06:49PM (#29284139)
I don't know, what about them?

I'm talking about the vast majority of people who are not vaccinated because they just aren't inclined to rush to get new medical treatments of little benefit to them.

Do the stats for the over 65 group honestly not make the situation clear to you? Focusing on the 0.1% lunatic fringe doesn't help your understanding, and it's the reason so many people are utterly baffled by what is easily explainable. Life is not the 20 loudest and most obnoxious twitter accounts.

Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by wutbrodo on Thursday November 18, 2021 @10:34PM (#29273510)
There are many people who don't make their vaccination decisions out of a mystic adherence to the very concept of a vaccine, but based on what they perceive to be a cost-benefit analysis (with the level of rigor varying wildly, naturally).

Unlike covid, there's no large cohort of the population for which smallpox is a fairly negligible personal risk, and smallpox outbreaks provide much more dramatic and visceral evidence of their harms than covid does (not sure if you've ever seen an image of smallpox).

The lessons of covid vaccine hesitancy are barely applicable to a hypothetical smallpox outbreak.

Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by mynameisvlad on Friday November 19, 2021 @01:50PM (#29280788)
Highly disagree. Most people make their vaccination decisions, like most other decisions, based on highly biased information that they have obtained from others around them. There is little "cost-benefit" analysis being done when you aren't actually comparing the real costs and benefits, but rather an extremely skewed interpretation you hear from the bubble you're in.

Given that, regardless of the actual risk or visceral evidence provided, almost anything can be spun as a positive or negative with enough determination, and on the heels of a major anti-vax campaign with Covid, there would be sure to be major overlap between the two were a smallpox outbreak to occur right now.

The first vaccine hesitancy campaign literally was against the smallpox vaccine in Stockholm, so I don't see how you could say that there would be no hesitancy to it. History has already shown that to not be the case over and over again.

Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by wutbrodo on Friday November 19, 2021 @08:04PM (#29284618)
> based on highly biased information that they have obtained from others around them. There is little "cost-benefit" analysis being done when you aren't actually comparing the real costs and benefits, but rather an extremely skewed interpretation you hear from the bubble you're in.

You're talking about the quality of the cost-benefit analysis, which I alluded to in my charitably-phrased parenthetical about rigor. That doesn't mean it isn't a cost-benefit analysis, and doesn't make it the same thing as religious adherence to pro- or anti-vaxxing. While some portion of the population engages in this approach, my point is that it's a lot fewer than most people think. That doesn't mean I think the cost-benefit analysis is high-quality, but that modeling these people as dogmatically irrational instead of very bad at being rational is misleading.

In stark contrast to Covid, the nature of smallpox outbreaks makes it so that even an extremely dumb person nominally engaging in cost-benefit analysis would have little trouble making basic inferences about the outcomes faced by people they knew who contracted it vs people they knew who didn't. I got vaccinated because I estimated that my low risk of a bad time after contracting Covid was higher than my low risk of a reaction to the vaccine. If for some reason, I didn't have access to the vaccine, it very likely would not have materially changed my young, healthy, no-comorbidity life.

There's another trivial rebuttal of your hypothesis, outlined in a sibling comment:

> You see the rational behavior play out when you look at vaccinations by age. 98% of people over 65 in the US have had one dose and 86% have had two. Because that's where the risk gets higher. Elderly people are not vastly better educated, smarter, less susceptible to propaganda, or lean toward political ideologies that are more inclined to take it, or have significantly easier access to it.

In your model of most people as not considering the cost-benefit tradeoff of vaccines, how do you explain the significant age disparity?

> The first vaccine hesitancy campaign literally was against the smallpox vaccine in Stockholm

This was _literally the first vaccine for a contagious illness_. You'd have to be irrational _not_ to have some degree of skepticism about being infected with a contagious disease, especially in an era with a population accustomed to a state with infinitely lower capacity and infinitely lower reach into everyday life. A quarter of a millennium later, in a society where the state licenses and ensures our safety in a trillion different publicly-known ways, the reactions of 1750s Swedes could not be less applicable.

Again, the pivotal difference relative to my framing is the approach to vaccines as an all-or-nothing tenet of religious faith, to be rejected with prejudice or embraced with devotion. This is obviously a fairly popular (implicit) perspective on public health, which makes it easy to lose sight that most people do not think like this, even the dumb ones.

> I don't see how you could say that there would be no hesitancy to it.

Kindly don't put words in my mouth. I said that Covid hesitancy is a different enough context that it's not usefully-applicable to a hypothetical future smallpox outbreak.

Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by crate_barre on Friday November 19, 2021 @04:22AM (#29275315)
Shows how vain society is. If COVID was a harmless and flu-like, but causes a permanent mole on your nose, then I can promise you everyone would get the vaccine.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by jopsen on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:10AM (#29315034)
Hehehe, I bet that's true :)
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by COGlory on Thursday November 18, 2021 @08:27PM (#29272763)
Covid and smallpox are very, very different.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by blindmute on Friday November 19, 2021 @10:36AM (#29278232)
Smallpox is actually dangerous, and the smallpox vaccine is like 200 years old. Not even 1% of people would refuse that vaccine in that scenario.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by mynameisvlad on Friday November 19, 2021 @01:41PM (#29280703)
Once again, two years ago I would have believed it. But considering a sizeable amount of people think that the Covid vaccine "allows governments to track you", "has 5G" or whatever other nonsense has permeated that discourse, I'm not as confident.

Especially if it happened right now with all the controversy around the Covid vaccine, it'd surely be spun as the Covid vaccine in disguise, or the government forcing its way into tracking us all with nanotechnology.

Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by ricardobayes on Saturday November 20, 2021 @06:01AM (#29287022)
or bird flu. That stuff gets me scared, almost 100% lethality
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by tomjen3 on Friday November 19, 2021 @12:54AM (#29274266)
All it takes is one to get away on a subway near an airport. Some of the original vaccine hesitancy was about the smallpox vaccine when it was endemic, so not everyone would take it.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by AceJohnny2 on Thursday November 18, 2021 @03:16PM (#29269924)
Tangentially, I've been on an SCP [1] binge lately, and it's interesting to see the cues SCP takes from the real world. Your quote could be taken verbatim from one of their stories.

[1] https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com

Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by marcosdumay on Thursday November 18, 2021 @03:34PM (#29270151)
Well, SCP would refer to the cultivation media by name.
Re:Vials labeled ‘smallpox’ are found in Pennsylvania labora... by bitwize on Thursday November 18, 2021 @03:21PM (#29269986)
I'm sure a FOIA request will reveal heavily redacted containment procedures for those vials that look straight out of the Foundation, as well :)