Re:Singapore’s tech-utopia and surveillance state
by kubb on Thursday November 18, 2021 @03:01PM
(#29269721)
From your comment, I'm getting the sense that you live in a besieged fortress. It doesn't have to be so extreme though.
Singapore is no dystopia, and neither is London (in fact, I'd prefer living in the latter than the former if only because of the weather). They just make different tradeoffs in how they're organized. And they deal with different (though overlapping) sets of issues.
Re:Singapore’s tech-utopia and surveillance state
by BlueTemplar on Thursday November 18, 2021 @04:28PM
(#29270819)
Sorry, but this sounds like a "someone else would have robbed you anyway, and probably even killed you" bandit "defense". While it is somewhat compelling from a birds eye view of bandit sociology and figuring out better anti-bandit countermeasures, it is terrrrible as an ethical defense.
Re:Singapore’s tech-utopia and surveillance state
by bllguo on Thursday November 18, 2021 @03:56PM
(#29270419)
you lump the western world together, but the vast majority of the derision is directed at the US. Worth considering why that is?
"Not angry about this situation" describes European foreign policy, not American
We're constantly being accused of being xenophobic, racist, imperialist, etc. Our prideful "Western thought" is arrogant.
These accusals are a constant assault on our nationalistic sense of shared identity and worth. The idea that no matter where we came from, that this is a melting pot. One where we admire rugged individualism and freedoms, and have a sense that if we work smart and hard and try our luck enough times, we will succeed.
There's an endless barrage of voices telling us we're horrible. It's starting to seep into the youth and shape their worldview. Most of this is coming from the outside.
The thing is, we know that there are a lot of broken things. We're working on it. Democracy is a work in progress. To quote Snowden, it's "a direction". Every new year is better.
America was never going to have a monopoly on power. Globalism accelerated Asia's rise to our level within just a generation, and now we have to work much harder to stay at par. When we praise our system and decry others, know that we're not angry about this situation.
Other countries are more appealing now as a result of this great averaging out of wealth and productivity. But the rapid increase in quality of life will taper off and begin to look just like America. We're not in decline - the world is catching up.
But even amongst equals, we Americans have a pretty good idea of the shape of the world we want. We want liberty, freedom of speech, and a subservient government. We want the opportunity to beat anyone. To not have our government stand in the way as a cabal. We want to swear at our leaders and draw funny cartoons of them without having to worry about our safety. We want to vote them in and out and investigate them when they do wrong. Because sometimes we think we know better, but even if not, it's what we think we deserve.
And before you raise Singapore on a pedestal above us, please realize that they kill people for minor drug possession [1]. I'm incredibly glad we don't emulate this model. It's not for us. (We do bad enough already...)
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Misuse_of_Drugs_Act_(Singapore...