News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:To my fellow Hacker News contributors by redler on Thursday August 25, 2011 @01:45PM (#2925750)
I think you're spot-on. This has to be a part of it. Whatever its issues, the visible point system was a way for readers to interact with the site in a way that produced a response for all to see. Whether this encouraged herd behavior or changed the shape of discussions in an unfavorable way is another issue.

Comment-dimming notwithstanding, that feedback has been removed. There's a class of reader whose desire for a kind of interactivity is no longer satisfied by the voting system; for them, pile-on voting has been replaced by pile-on posting (albeit often in the more thoughtful HN style). Which in turn begets more such posts, and thus a more polarized conversational shape.

Re:To my fellow Hacker News contributors by tptacek on Thursday August 25, 2011 @02:01PM (#2925805)
I think you guys are falling in love with a clever narrative about voting and comments and socialization and aren't remembering all the pointless and objectively stupid arguments we were having about transient down and up fluctuations in comment scores when we could see them all.
Re:To my fellow Hacker News contributors by grandalf on Thursday August 25, 2011 @02:28PM (#2925914)
Perhaps -- but then it was about points and not about ideologies.