You're right--they are about 10 times dumber. Have you been on Facebook or MySpace, or read YouTube comments lately?
Even taking the youtube commenters I suspect, most of them, would be able to grasp openid if it stood between them and the next ROFLMAO-able video.
I actually think that most people are not dumb ... they just behave that way because it makes them look cool, or because they lived in a cave all their lives and don't know any better.
Instead of being arrogant, treat them the same as you would a smart and educated individual, and I think you will have quite a few surprises.
In fact I rarely meet dumb people, and I'm not living in Silicon Valey, but in a third world country with a corrupted government, and a shameful school system.
Heck, that's how I signed up for Hacker News. You wouldn't be reading this wonderful prose right now if not for OpenID.
I think this guy would dislike e-mail if Facebook messaging had been invented before it. "Everyone with their own domains? That's too confusing. How will we ever explain it? Everyone except me is too dumb to understand!"
(As an aside, why is everyone so obsessed with making things "easy" for "users" they've never met? People aren't as dumb as you expect. Make it work for yourself first -- at least it will be good for one person that way. Your unresearched assumptions are harmful.)