1. I don't have an account with this site. They say that if I have an account with (any of these other OpenID-supporting sites), though, that that one would work instead. Neato, but I don't use any of those, so:
2. I'll click on the register link here. Ah, here's a registration page. It doesn't have the site's logo on it, but they said that would happen--they've outsourced this part.
3. Registered. They gave me a link, and said "just treat it as your username." OK; I'll try to remember it, then. "It'll also work on all those other sites we mentioned, and more every day." Neato again; I might check some of those out.
4. I'm back on the site I started at, and I've already been logged in. They got my nickname right and everything.
(days pass)
5. "You've been logged out of the site due to inactivity." Oh, well, what was my username again? That link thing? Oh, here it is in the autocomplete.
6. Hey, it didn't ask me for my password! What the heck? I'm just logged in all of the sudden. I guess that's good, then.
(weeks pass)
7. "You've been", "inactivity", blah blah blah. Autocomplete.
8. Oh, I'm back on that site that did the registration. They're asking me for my password. Makes sense--they're the only ones that I told that particular detail. Put that in...
9. Ah, I'm back on track and logged in again. Nice.
They know how standard registration/login works. They have a browser that remembers passwords for them. They don't need OpenID.
Why is this confusing but e-mail isn't? If I want to send and receive e-mail, I have to find my own provider. I also have to remember this weird string, "[email protected]". THAT'S TOO HARD FOR THE AVERAGE USER!!11!
I tried using openID once. It directed me to google or yahoo or something to log in... So then I had to decide if it was really google or yahoo, or if it was some phishing site.
It's a terrible idea, which is sure to fail. There is no compelling reason for people to use it.
The only problem at this point is the URL username. To answer that, think about what, for example, gmail does: when you have a gmail.com address, you can drop that part and just use the username part of it. Likewise, I'd allow my users to strip off the domain part of whatever my "preferred provider" was, and just say that the "foreign IDs" basically need a "passport stamp" to get in--an attached domain name.
Still too confusing?
Those that know about OpenID can use their own providers, but those that don't care won't have to think about it; they'll just use the one I pick (which is no worse than trusting me with their made-up-on-the-spot credentials, which is what they'd be doing otherwise anyways.) If they start caring, they can make a new ID with a provider they choose--I fully allow for account URI changes; it's not that hard to implement. In fact, the whole OpenID set-up for me was two library calls (discounting the fact that I had to hack the library itself to add in Simple Registration support, so I could automatically set users' nicknames to their OpenID accounts' nicknames on each login. It's discountable because I submitted a patch, so no one else will have to worry about it.)